Published as the fifth volume in the Colección Historia Social Política y de la Cultura by the History Faculty at the University of Michoacán (Mexico), this volume is an ambitious and information-packed overview of Chilean economic history, politics and entrepreneurship from the 1820s to 2007. Núñez Arancibia surveys the vast literature on Chilean economic history and considers the standard treatments of economic models and policy: reliance on mineral exports and foreign investment until 1930; import substitution industrialisation (ISI) from 1930 until 1973; the restructuring of the economy by neoliberal agents of the military regime between 1973 and 1990; and economic policy since 1990. For each period the author focuses on types of entrepreneurs in Chile, their social and economic networks, and their relations with labour, government (‘the State’) and foreign investors. The study concludes by considering the changes in entrepreneurship that have resulted from the new globalisation in the last part of the twentieth century.
Based on an extensive re-reading of Chilean political and economic history, Núñez presents a review of research by Chilean, European and US academics on Chilean economic history. His review is useful, especially for non-specialists, but not innovative. The synthesis of the 1930s is no surprise: ‘from the mid-19th century until the Great Depression, Chile was integrated into the world economy through export of natural resources and the use of foreign capital and technology’ (pp. 75–6). During this period much of the literature portrays Chilean businessmen as backward, but Núñez seeks to rehabilitate some of the early pioneers in mining and banking, as well as the numerous European immigrants who came to dominate the emergent industrial sector after the 1880s. Nevertheless, rather than being the driving force of the economy, national entrepreneurs played second fiddle to a centralised state and the influence of foreign capital, especially in the key mining sector.
Núñez relates that from the 1930s until 1973 entrepreneurs gradually moved from patrimonial firms to ‘economic groups’ (in the 1960s), but acted ‘corporatively’ to obtain benefits from the state, including participation in the public enterprises created during the ISI phase. Most business interests did not oppose the mixed economy, with its substantial state regulation and public enterprise, that characterised Chilean society into the 1970s. The reformism of the Christian Democratic government of Eduardo Frei Montalva (1964–70) opened the door to Salvador Allende's Popular Unity coalition and the so-called ‘peaceful road to socialism’. Battered by threats to private property and the expanding role of the state in the economy – to their exclusion – the political and economic Right melded together, joined by a majority of Christian Democrats who called on the armed forces to ‘save’ the country from Marxism: ‘defense of private property became the leit motiv of the entrepreneurial class, that felt itself not only distanced from State activities, but attacked directly in its identity’ (p. 141).
All of that changed with the coup of 1973 and almost 17 years of military government. While the military regime deregulated and privatised much economic activity after 1973, Núñez suggests that the efficacy of government action became a foundation for the new economic order. The authoritarian neoliberal project provided incentives and opportunities for a new class of Chilean entrepreneurs. Although it disadvantaged the old industrial groups reliant on tariff protection, it provided cultural and social legitimacy for entrepreneurs and entrepreneurship more generally, greatly enhancing the social prestige of business elites and the centrality of private enterprise in Chilean life. In Núñez's understated version of the extent of political repression necessary to make these changes, installing this new regime required creating a new social consensus and the ‘temporary distancing’ of popular sectors from access to government decision-making, as well as intensified social polarisation (p. 500).
Núñez argues that the policies and efficiency of the State under the military government contributed to the competitiveness of the Chilean economy in the decade of the 1990s and into the twenty-first century. Protected and ideologically supported by the military junta, Chilean entrepreneurs could overcome the uncertainty of the past and take advantage of market opportunities (p. 35). By the mid-1980s, the new business class recognised that its presence was ‘indispensable’ in state policy-making: entrepreneurial leaders appear to have taken hold of the idea that they, along with the state, constitute the leaders (liderazgo) of the system (p. 175). Thus, the annual Encuentro Nacional de la Empresa en Chile (National Meeting of Enterprises in Chile, ENADE) in 1986 had as its theme ‘El empresario, motor del progreso’ (‘Entrepreneurs: Motor of Progress’) (p. 174).
According to Núñez, the installation and success of the economía de mercado in Chile required leadership by a new state elite composed of military officers, economists, technocrats and entrepreneurs. This new elite re-engineered government institutions and economic policy. The ascendancy of technocrats in league with business elites continued after transition to civilian government in 1990. Chilean entrepreneurs overcame the fear of foreign competition and made progress in business management (gestión de empresas) and commercialisation of products. They also demonstrated increasing autonomy from the state and a focus on exports and alliances with foreign capital (pp. 502–3). Internationalisation of Chilean business stimulated modernisation of companies and ‘transformed the country into a sort of model for the development of the private sector in the rest of the region [Latin America]’. Despite these signs of entrepreneurial development, however, the last words from the author lament ‘deficiencies in the use of human capital’, the confrontational positions of labour, and suspicions by entrepreneurs that labour organisations are not fully committed to ‘investments in production’, thus perhaps limiting maximisation of productivity and innovation (p. 509). Human rights violations by the military regime, crushing of the labour movement and the persistence of great social and economic inequality are mentioned along the way, but are not a central focus of this volume.
