When Elizabeth Gaskell died in November 1865, she left unfinished her final novel, Wives and Daughters (1864–66). The Cornhill Magazine's editor, Frederick Greenwood, published a tribute to Gaskell with the novel's final installment. Her fiction, he wrote, pulls you from “an abominable wicked world, crawling with selfishness and reeking with base passions into one where there is much weakness, many mistakes, sufferings long and bitter, but where it is possible for people to live calm and wholesome lives . . .” (Gaskell 685–86; ch. 60). As Linda K. Hughes and Michael Lund observe, Greenwood shaped Gaskell's reputation for a hundred years “as an author whose work captured . . . the idyllic charm of a lost era” and took “readers away from unpleasant realities” (158). Notably, Greenwood's list of “unpleasant realities” (wickedness, selfishness, and base passions) implicitly refers to capitalism — that is, to the economic world of the 1860s from which Gaskell ostensibly encouraged her readers to retreat.
Recent criticism, however, has questioned this view of Gaskell's fiction as disengaged from the capitalist culture of mid-Victorian Britain. In particular, Andrew H. Miller argues that Cranford (1851–53) engages with the legal issue of limited liability as articulated in the Joint Stock Companies Act of 1856. By configuring the novel's two main characters, Miss Matty and Mary Smith, as representations of pre- and post-limited-liability eras, he argues, “Cranford registers the ethical complexities within the discourse of liability” (153). Similarly, Natalka Freeland contends that the plot of Ruth (1853) dramatizes the market forces of sex and capital: “Ruth's sexual transgressions . . . become a critique of the market economy as a whole” (199). A new view of Gaskell's fiction has thus emerged, demonstrating its deep involvement in mid-Victorian debates about emergent capitalism.
We, too, interpret Gaskell's work as participating in contemporary debates on the new credit economy of the 1860s. Specifically, we argue that characters in Wives and Daughters thrive or fail based on their relations to credit and debt and that such economic outcomes are shaped by the novel's underlying Darwinian interest in how characters adapt to changing conditions. Previous Darwinian readings of Wives and Daughters represent Roger Hamley as embodying the competitive advantages of scientific knowledge, intelligence, vigour, and health, whereas the rest of the Hamleys risk “fossilization” (Debrabant 18). Mary Debrabant, for example, stresses the genetic factors that lead to the decline of “the Hamleys, a race rooted in archaic, elitist customs and running the risk of extinction” by following “the law of primogeniture” and perpetuating “social homogeneity by the consistent practice of marrying within one's social class” (17). According to this reading, the Hamleys are saved from extinction by Roger, who represents the “democratizing force” of science (17), and by the genetic variations offered by the marriages of Osborne to Aimée and Roger to Molly, a servant and middle-class woman respectively (19–20). We suggest, however, that success or failure in this most Darwinian of Gaskell's novels extends beyond bloodlines to money: success for the novel's characters is largely economically contingent. Our reading thus harmonizes with Carol A. Martin's analysis of North and South as a Darwinian economic narrative that portrays “the death of those characters who are too rigid to modify in changing conditions and the survival of characters who do adapt” (92). In Wives and Daughters, as we will show, such adaptations are related to the productive use of credit. The novel thus reflects the specific cultural matrix of the early 1860s: a booming economy, widespread market speculation, and the popularization of Darwinian theory. As a “commodity-text,” therefore, the realist novel (including the supposedly idyllic Cranford) participated in this burgeoning market (Feltes, Modes 8).
Before exploring the novel's representation of credit and capitalism in relation to evolutionary paradigms, we will provide two key contexts for our analysis. First, we invoke the speculative climate of the 1860s, with its attendant anxieties concerning survival in this newly competitive market. Second, we identify Gaskell's awareness of the marketplace, as expressed in her fierce negotiations with editors and publishers, as well as in her fiction itself.
The Speculative Economy and the Literary Market of the 1860s
The mid-Victorian period witnessed economic boom, speculation, and a new liquidity of credit following the Joint Stock Companies Act of 1856. Eric Hobsbawm posits that, in the period from 1848 to the early 1870s, “the world became capitalist,” with a number of countries shifting to industrial economies and Europe enjoying an “extraordinary economic transformation and expansion” (43). As Walter Bagehot (a regular contributor to the Economist) observed, this transformation was spurred by the “ability to rush speculative capital with mercurial swiftness to whatever sector of the economy offered a chance of profit” (qtd. in Herbert 188). In Britain, several legal changes underpinned this speculative boom, including (1) the concept of limited liability, which reduced the financial risk of investors (as opposed to the partnership model, under which investors were liable to their “last shilling and acre” [qtd. in Miller 142]); and (2) the establishment of the gold standard, designed to reassure investors and to prevent panics by tying the currency to gold reserves. The boom of the 1860s and this climate of speculation prompted anxiety, however, because Britain had experienced repeated cycles of boom and bust, with financial crises occurring at roughly ten-year intervals, in 1825–26, 1837–39, 1847, 1857, and 1866.Footnote 1
Literature represented this anxiety in the figure of the immoral speculator, who could be blamed for unwise speculation and cycles of financial crisis. Writing in 1852, Bagehot deplored ignorant speculators as dangerously volatile and naive: “railways should not be promoted by maiden ladies, or canals by beneficed clergymen” (275). He urged investors to be prudent: “We hope that people will be wise – that capitalists will exercise discretion – that merchants will not overtrade – that shopkeepers will not overstock – that the non-mercantile public will bear the reduction in income – that they will efface superfluities, and endure adversity, and abolish champagne” (274). Similarly, Victorian fiction often vilified the speculator as immoral: as John Reed notes, characters such as Merdle in Little Dorrit (1855–57) or Melmotte in The Way We Live Now (1874–75) stand for “Mammonism, . . . the chief economic disease of their time” (183).
Although many Victorian writers deplored speculators in their fictions, they themselves participated actively in the market, negotiating and speculating on the value of their texts as commodities. As Norman Feltes observes, after The Pickwick Papers (1836–37), the Victorian novel became a “commodity-text,” forged in “the new capitalist mode of production, produced in struggle by the new ‘professional’ author” (Modes 8). Indeed, Patrick Brantlinger argues that the realist novel “was from the outset, a creature of ‘credit’ . . . a commodity, produced to be transformed into money in the increasingly capitalized and bourgeois literary marketplace” (150). Gaskell participated in this marketplace with determination and success, struggling with Charles Dickens in the 1850s for authorial control over the serializations of Cranford and North and South and negotiating fiercely with her publisher, Edward Chapman, about numbers, copyright, costs, and payment (Schor 85, 92; Ingham xxvii).
In the 1860s, Gaskell's publication of Cousin Phillis (1863–64) and Wives and Daughters in Smith, Elder's Cornhill Magazine identified her with a new and well-paid mode of publication.Footnote 2 In each shilling monthly issue, the Cornhill offered two illustrated serial novels by leading authors, as well as essays, poems, and short fiction. To leading writers, the magazine made payments “lavish almost to the point of recklessness” (Smith qtd. in Vann 82).Footnote 3 With her own career thriving in the 1860s and Wives and Daughters featured as the leading text in the Cornhill, Gaskell was thus deeply attuned to “the mechanics of book production, the business of publication, and the nature of reception” (Hughes and Lund 3).
Not only did Gaskell play an active role in the competitive Victorian literary marketplace, but her own relation to credit provides a key context for Wives and Daughters. Indeed, Gaskell used Wives and Daughters to finance her purchase of a home for her husband's retirement, hoping ultimately to bequeath the house to their unmarried daughters. Gaskell bought The Lawn for £2600 in the summer of 1865, just as Wives and Daughters hit its midpoint of serialization; she also needed £500 to furnish it for a tenant. She had saved £1600, including £100 from the copyright of North and South, which Smith wanted to reprint. He had paid her £2000 for the copyright of Wives and Daughters Footnote 4 and lent her £1200 on an “equitable mortgage” (qtd. in Uglow 573). Gaskell intended to rent The Lawn for three years until she could repay Smith's loan through her writing. Importantly, she financed the house without her husband's knowledge because William “sternly disapproved of debt” (Uglow 573).Footnote 5 As she wrote to her friend, the American author Charles Eliot Norton, “I did a terribly grand thing! and a secret thing too! . . . I bought a house and 4 acres of land in Hampshire” (qtd. in Uglow 572).
As Jenny Uglow points out, this purchase represented “concrete . . . evidence of [Gaskell's] independent achievement. It was . . . a whole house of her own, won and paid for by her writing” (567). Uglow, however, does not remark that married women's property law prohibited Gaskell from buying or owning property, controlling her earnings, or taking on a mortgage. In 1856, Gaskell had signed Barbara Leigh Smith's petition calling for married women's property law reform,Footnote 6 a petition that drew attention to “professional women earning large incomes by pursuit of the arts” whose husbands controlled their earnings and copyright (qtd. in Burton 70).Footnote 7 Nine years later, when Gaskell used her professional income and credit to finance The Lawn, the law remained unchanged. Although Gaskell was thus legally unable either to buy property or to assume a mortgage, she undertook both, effectively trying to assume the legal role of the femme sole as she arranged for the purchase, mortgage, and tenancy of The Lawn. Wives and Daughters’ composition, then, was spurred by Gaskell's need to “write off” the debt on The Lawn, with Gaskell worrying that “I shall never write up the money for the house I'm afraid” (Chapple and Pollard 938).
We have said that Gaskell “bought” The Lawn, but because of contemporary law she could not hold the property in her name. Gaskell resisted but had to capitulate to the somewhat humiliating device of a trust; in doing so, she relied for legal advice and help on her son-in-law Charles Crompton (Flossy's husband) and Thurstan Holland (Marianne's fiancé and cousin), both lawyers, as well as William Shaen (her solicitor). As she wrote to Holland on 31 August 1865, she preferred no trustees for the house: “If trustees are necessary I shd like none better than you & Charlie, but I wd rather do without trustees” (Chapple and Pollard 770). In the same letter, she announced her intention that The Lawn should ultimately serve as a home for her unmarried daughters (Chapple and Pollard 770) – an inheritance that they, as femmes soles, could legally own. The purchase and financing of The Lawn, which so consumed Gaskell in the summer of 1865, were thus intimately connected to the legal status of women as wives and daughters. As we will suggest, the novel takes up and dramatizes these concerns, exploring the central themes of money, debt, and credit in relation to gender.
Writing in the mid-1860s, with her own relation to money and credit in mind, Gaskell sets Wives and Daughters in the late 1820s but infuses this earlier historical moment with a mid-Victorian view of women, personhood, and money. In this respect, it is important that this novel turns away from the femme sole, Gaskell's focus in Cranford, to contemplate women as relative creatures (wives and daughters). Focusing on this group – legally defined as outside the credit economy but increasingly demanding participation in it as a sign of personhood – Gaskell represents women's relationship to money as intrinsic to their social identities and maturation. In Gaskell's version of the female bildungsroman, Molly and Cynthia reach womanhood not only (as is usual in this genre) by achieving maturity, moral growth, and marriage, but through learning the importance of good and bad debt, productive credit as opposed to money spent on ephemera. Writing in the 1860s, before the Married Women's Property Act of 1870, Gaskell unambiguously suggests that women's personhood is inextricably linked to their active participation in the economy.
“The Root of All Evil”: Credit in the Cornhill
Money and credit lie at the heart of the novel's female maturation plot and place Wives and Daughters at a nexus of such concerns in the Cornhill in the early 1860s, when the magazine published rich discussions of political economy and credit in fiction and articles by such leading writers as Anthony Trollope, Fitzjames Stephen, and John Ruskin. “Credit, – credit, – credit. Get credit, and capital will follow,” declares the comic character of George Robinson in Trollope's satirical novel The Struggles of Brown, Jones, and Robinson, serialized from August 1861 to March 1862 (Aug. 1861: 181). The text depicts the misadventures of a haberdashery firm, which in turn mimic the boom and crash of speculative economies. Existing almost solely on credit, Magenta House creates an image based on the visual pleasures of “glass, gas, gold and glare” (Sept. 1861: 324), advertises improbable stock such as African monkey muffs (Nov. 1861: 552), and encourages buyers to pay cash for non-existent goods. As the narrator (an advertising copy writer) notes cheerfully in his preface, “Credit is the polished shaft of the temple on which the new world of trade will be content to lean. That, I take it, is the one great doctrine of modern commerce” (Aug. 1861: 181). The topic of speculation also attracted more serious treatments in the Cornhill, with Fitzjames Stephen lamenting in his essay on “Luxury” that
The greater part of the national energy has since the peace been directed to the accumulation of wealth or of the means of providing it. . . . It has thus come to pass that the love of money, which an Apostle declared to be the root of all evilFootnote 8 . . . has come in these days to be looked upon as combining in its favour the suffrages of experience, religion, and philosophy. (Sept. 1860: 346)
Both Trollope and Stephen thus provided middle-class Cornhill readers with cautionary commentary on the booming speculative climate of the early 1860s. This caution was heightened between August and November of the same year, when the magazine serialized John Ruskin's Unto this Last. Ruskin's “The Roots of Honour” (Aug. 1860) argued that the relationship between manufacturer and worker should be familial rather than purely economic: in a financial crisis, Ruskin suggested, the manufacturer is “bound to take the suffering of it with his men, and even to take more of it for himself than he allows his men to feel; as a father would in a famine, shipwreck, or battle, sacrifice himself for his son” (166). Ruskin insisted that “this unselfish treatment will produce the most effective return” (158), whether in the form of “material service” or “protective watchfulness” of those less tangible assets, “interest and credit” (158). Notably, Ruskin defines credit broadly, including moral as well as financial interpretations. Together with Stephen's “Luxury” and Trollope's The Struggles of Brown, Jones, and Robinson, Ruskin's essays register the high topicality of speculation and critique the credit economy of the early 1860s. The discursive matrix of the Cornhill, then, allowed this critical possibility even as the magazine itself participated in the economy of speculation, risking what George Smith termed recklessly “lavish” (qtd. in Vann 82) sums on leading authors.
Wives, Daughters, and Credit
It was in these cultural and discursive contexts that Gaskell published her novel of female economic and moral maturation. Wives and Daughters’ temporal setting in the years 1827 to 1830 situates its main action on the cusp of the railway boom that would thrust ahead the industrial revolution and the Reform Bill that would consolidate the power of the mercantile class. Feltes has noted that for mid-Victorian authors, the late 1820s held symbolic value as a key phase of early capitalism, a moment dominated by the individual owner-manager, before the era of limited liability and joint-stock companies (“Community” 358–59). He notes, for example, that Eliot's The Mill on the Floss (1860) is set in the 1820s, a period of transition in which the novel contrasts the traditional money management of the Gleggs with that of the entrepreneurial Deanes. Poised between the two families, Tom Tulliver must choose between their attitudes to money; he eventually redeems his family's lost credit by taking his Uncle Deane's advice and speculating in the new market (358). In Wives and Daughters, Gaskell, like Eliot, looks back from the credit economy of the 1860s to its origins in the late 1820s. It is in this economy that Cynthia and Molly must learn to flourish, using their credit both productively and morally, as Ruskin suggests.
We use the term morally because Gaskell did not support a purely profit-driven market in which only the most ruthless would survive. Wives and Daughters dramatizes her opposition to such an ethos when Mr. Gibson facetiously suggests that his medical practice would thrive better if he let the poor patients die and looked after only the rich ones. His apprentice observes that he does not follow this premise, remarking that “you go every morning, sir, before breakfast, to see old Nancy Grant, and you've ordered her this medicine, sir, which is about the most costly in Corbyn's bill?” (46; ch. 4). Gibson's dry question, “Have you not found out how difficult it is for men to live up to their precepts?” (46; ch. 4), encapsulates Gaskell's ambivalence about the profit economy and supports scholars such as Gordon Bigelow who argue that her novels critique “the philosophies and forces of the capitalist market” (144).
However, neither did Gaskell advocate a separation from the market: Margaret Hale's investment of her inheritance in John Thornton's humane factory in North and South (1854–55) indicates the author's belief in capital's possibilities. Wives and Daughters similarly suggests that credit and capital can be used productively and morally in the community and that those who decline market involvement will not survive the advent of Victorian capitalism. It is in this moment of transition that Gaskell depicts her two main characters, Molly and Cynthia, coming to womanhood.
Early in the novel, a gambling scene establishes Molly's and Cynthia's initially very different attitudes towards speculation and debt (a gambling trope that Eliot would later use to open Daniel Deronda [1876]). Playing cards at the Miss Brownings’ house, Molly manifests complete financial disengagement, setting down “two counters, indifferent as to whether she won or lost” (250; ch. 21). By contrast, Cynthia gambles recklessly: she “staked high, and was at one time very rich, but ended by being in debt to Molly something like six shillings” (250; ch. 21). These responses reveal their attitudes to money and to debt, both of which, Gaskell suggests, are flawed. Through her mother's example, Cynthia has pursued an unwise course with money, but through Mr. Gibson's mentoring and Molly's friendship, she will learn new ways. For her part, Molly must learn how to take risks and enter the credit economy; otherwise, her unworldliness will prevent her from succeeding in the changing world of the 1820s. In order to thrive in the new economy, Molly must learn to use credit productively, whereas Cynthia must temper her propensity for risk.
In this narrative of economic and moral maturation, Mrs. Gibson provides a comic foil for her daughter and stepdaughter. Of the novel's females, Clare stands out as the most morally dubious. Her first marriage to a “poor curate” (8; ch. 1) was motivated by social and economic ambition: as she says to Molly, “if three of his relations had died without children I should have been a baronet's wife” (18; ch. 2). The relations do not die; however, the curate does, and Clare works as a schoolmistress to make ends meet. Her straitened finances prompt her to marry Mr. Gibson, after a courtship in which the chief attraction is economic security: “‘Oh! Mr Gibson,’ [Clare] said; and then . . . burst into hysterical tears: it was such a wonderful relief to feel that she need not struggle any more for a livelihood” (109; ch. 10).
Though morally dubious, Clare represents the novel's most adaptable character, showing resourcefulness and practicality. She uses to advantage what little money she gets; she is (unlike the upper-class Osborne Hamley) “always uneasy till she [is] out of debt” (144; ch. 12). She also prioritizes strategically, as when she buys her trousseau, forgoing new undergarments in order to make a show with her outer clothing: “She argued with herself that linen, and all underclothing, would never be seen; while she knew that every gown she had, would give rise to much discussion, and would be counted up in the little town” (145; ch. 12). Significantly, Gaskell identifies Clare's opportunism with crass profit motives: on her first night in her new home, as Mr. Gibson goes out to treat a dying patient, Clare echoes the earlier conversation with his apprentice when she asks Molly, “But if this Mr Smith is dying . . . what's the use of your father's going off to him in such a hurry? Does he expect any legacy, or anything of that kind?” (179; ch.15).
The novel extends no prospect of moral growth for Clare; instead, it turns its searchlight on Cynthia and Molly, each to be schooled in the moral use of money and credit. Before the novel opens, the young Cynthia has incurred debt, frittering away the £20 she borrowed from Preston on travel, boots, gloves, gowns, a mantle, and a bonnet. In making these choices, she shares her mother's love of dress but not Clare's practicality in avoiding debt. Moreover, just as Clare's fate reminds us that economic fortunes are largely determined by gender, so Cynthia accrues debt in a system that conflates women's spending with sexual obligation and/or promiscuity. As Freeland observes of Gaskell's Ruth, women whose bodies over-circulate in the sexual market lose social credit (205). Similarly, Cynthia's promiscuous spending of Preston's money invites a sexual interpretation: by entangling herself financially, she risks entangling herself sexually. Preston makes this conflation explicit when he says that his loan will be cancelled when she marries him, thus refusing to acknowledge Cynthia's right to incur debt except when she pays with her body. When the reader first encounters Cynthia, she is trying to restore her sexual credit by restoring her financial credit: she has saved almost all of her allowance to reimburse Preston and thus has very few new clothes. Cynthia, then, can only achieve independence by paying Preston back with money – £20 plus five percent (the standard legal interest rate before the usury laws were repealed) (Chambers 156).
Molly, in turn, comes to adulthood when she convinces Preston to accept Cynthia's repayment, an action that involves her own entry into the credit economy. Significantly, Molly is never otherwise associated with money; this fact has contributed to critical readings of the novel that characterize her, like Gaskell, as removed from consumerism's “muddy vesture” (Greenwood qtd. in Gaskell 685; ch. 60). But Molly enters the speculative marketplace when she risks her social credit to redeem Cynthia's by being seen exchanging notes and money with Preston. Gaskell explicitly associates Molly's actions with financial credit: when Molly is seen in compromising meetings with Preston, the Miss Brownings replay the bank failure scene from Cranford – the scene that, as Miller has convincingly argued, links that novel with the economic discourses of the 1850s. When Miss Phoebe hears of Molly's loss of social reputation, she is so distraught that her sister suspects some monetary disaster has occurred: “‘Is the Highchester Bank broken?’ ‘Oh no sister, . . . Molly Gibson has lost her character, sister’” (535; ch. 47). Molly's social reputation is restored by Lady Harriet when she uses her credit to restore Molly's. As she walks the “unconscious Molly” (560; ch. 49) up and down the main streets of the town, Lady Harriet restores Molly's depleted moral credit with her own social credit by coupling their names on her calling card, an activity that she sees as “a good day's work” (561; ch. 49).
Molly comes to maturity, then, through a new and unconventional relationship with money and credit, one that echoes Gaskell's own exercise of economic autonomy in her purchase of The Lawn. As Hughes and Lund argue, “Molly has appropriated agency where money is concerned (Preston's loan to Cynthia), defied her father (who demands to know why she met Preston), and interfered in a pledged courtship – all actions that generally lie beyond a Victorian woman's sphere” (19–20). Perhaps most importantly, Molly exhibits calm control in her new use of credit. Unlike Bagehot's hysterical maiden ladies, she is calmer than Mr. Gibson as she risks her social and moral credit, reassuring him as his courage falters: “We shall outlive these rumours, never fear” (545; ch. 48). Molly's generous and productive use of her social credit – a practice associated with the early credit economy, in which the primary instrument of credit was the reputation of the signatory – signals her maturity. Very significantly, then, Molly enters a love relationship with Roger (the bildungsroman's traditional sign denoting female maturity) only after she has established her survival skills in the emergent capitalist economy of the late 1820s.
Evolutionary Discourse in Wives and Daughters and the Cornhill
We use the term survival skills advisedly because Wives and Daughters’ evolutionary terms of reference suggest that this bildungsroman should be read as a tale of adaptation and survival as well as of successful maturation. As is well known, Gaskell was a cousin of Charles Darwin and loosely based the character of Roger, naturalist and traveler, on him (Gérin 277). Although critics have traditionally downplayed Gaskell's knowledge of or interest in Darwin's thought, recent scholars have suggested that Wives and Daughters “renders visible the pervasive, if muted, influence of Darwinian evolutionary theory” (d'Albertis 137) and that Gaskell “adopts a narrative technique which consistently reveals an evolutionary perspective” (Debrabant 15). The novel is not mentioned in Gillian Beer's Darwin's Plots or George Levine's Darwin and the Novelists; nevertheless, it possesses many of the hallmarks that Levine identifies as Darwinian (13–20).Footnote 9 These include the novel's pointedly secular frame of reference, a third-person observing narrator, an emphasis on ordinary life, and a plot in which “characters, like Darwinian organisms, learn to adapt to their environments” (Levine 19).
Recently, Leon Litvack has illuminated the novel's complex references to evolution, demonstrating that these meticulously locate Roger in terms of the 1820s’ Geoffroy-Cuvier debates on comparative anatomy, debates that predated and informed Darwin's theory. Although George, Baron Cuvier established that previous life forms had become extinct, he did not believe in the mutability of species: “Organisms were, he held, functional wholes; any change in one part would destroy the delicate balance” (Litvack 732). Lord Hollingford finds Molly impressively well informed because she has read Cuvier's Le Règne Animal (1817); however, Roger writes an article refuting the “view of a great French physiologist” (Gaskell 311; ch. 26). Litvack suggests that the physiologist is Cuvier and that Roger objects to his views on the fixity of species (732). Roger concurs instead with Étienne Geoffroy St. Hilaire, who developed the theory of “transcendental anatomy,” concluding not only that all vertebrates were “built to the same blueprint,” but that “all animal life . . . could be strung into a continuous, related series, rather than broken into Cuvier's discrete divisions” (Litvack 734). It is “Geoffroi St. H –” who invites Roger to dinner, wishing to “meet the author of the paper which had already attracted the attention of the French comparative anatomists” (Gaskell 315; ch. 27; qtd. in Litvack 732). Litvack's research provides evidence that Gaskell had a far more sophisticated grasp of pre-Darwinian comparative anatomy than scholars have previously recognized and that the text's Darwinian narrative traits are reinforced by its carefully researched pre-Darwinian context.Footnote 10
This evolutionary frame of reference is reinforced by the novel's context in the Cornhill: in the early 1860s, the magazine was responding to and popularizing Darwin's On the Origin of Species (1859). As Anne DeWitt has convincingly shown, the novel's periodical context is rich with references to “men of science” engaged in natural history as endeavour (1). Notably, George Henry Lewes’ “Studies in Animal Life” ran in the magazine from January to June 1860,Footnote 11 laying “before the general reader the great arguments of the day in the natural sciences, taking particular account of Darwin's Origin of Species” (Ashton 204) and making specific reference to Cuvier and Geoffroy.Footnote 12 Lewes laid out the crux of the argument about the variability of species:
To what extent are animal forms variable? The answers given have been two: one school declaring that the extent of variability is limited to those trifling characteristics which mark the different Varieties of each Species; the other school declaring that the variety is indefinite, and that all animal forms may have arisen from successive modifications of a very few types, or even of one type. (Apr. 1860: 444)
In chapter 5, Lewes identifies the two schools as that of Cuvier (“the dog has remained a dog” [May 1860: 599]) as opposed to that of Darwin and others, including GeoffroyFootnote 13 (“new types may be formed by the union of pre-existing types; and consequently that species are variable” [May 1860: 605]). Lewes cautiously affirmed Darwin's theory, arguing for a “high degree of probability” that species were variable. In April 1860, two months before the famous debate between T. H. Huxley and Bishop Wilberforce, this was a controversial stand: Rosemary Ashton remarks that the “orthodox” Smith put a rather abrupt end to Lewes's series in June 1860 (204).
By 1862, however, the Cornhill once again addressed Darwinian theory in E. S. Dixon's “A Vision of Animal Existences.” Dixon uses a dream vision to dramatize nightmarish fears about Darwin: the narrator relates how he fell asleep in the Zoological Gardens near a woman reading a thick book (presumably Darwin's Origin) and her child, who is playing with toy animals. A dream sequence ensues, in which the woman guides the dreamer through the zoo; she has now been transformed into the allegorical figure “Natural Selection,” with her boy representing “Struggle-for-Life.” At times, they offer guidance in understanding the variability of species and the earth's geological age. At other times, they brutally enact Darwinian principles, with “Natural Selection” killing most of a herd of antelopes and “Struggle-for-Life” starving a wolf pack until the wolves turn and kill each other, leaving two survivors as a breeding pair. This brutal vision concludes as the narrator awakens and sees the woman once again quietly reading Darwin. The author asks her opinion, which turns out to resemble Lewes's moderate response in “Studies in Animal Life”:
“Here we are offered a rational and a logical explanation of many things which hitherto have been explained very unsatisfactorily, or not at all. It is conscientiously reasoned and has been patiently written. If it be not the truth, I cannot help respecting it as a sincere effort after truth.” (318)
DeWitt has focused on these articles’ representation of science as a form of masculine moral engagement; however, we argue that these discussions of natural history also provide a crucial discursive matrix for Wives and Daughters, indicating the timeliness of its evolutionary themes.
Wives and Daughters: Credit and Survival in the New Economy
The topics of economics and evolution that occupied the pages of the Cornhill in the early 1860s were intrinsically related. Levine notes that Darwin's theory “drew upon the basic themata of modern commercial and industrial capitalist society and that it was quickly absorbed into the ideology of that society” (12), and Timothy L. Alborn observes that economists deployed the discourse of natural selection after 1859 to describe an “evolutionary progress” from prehistoric to civilized economic patterns (190–91). As Alborn notes, Bagehot's essays in the Economist between 1864 and 1866 identify certain investor behaviours as atavistic. Bagehot depicts people who hoard gold during commercial panics as regressing, “descending the evolutionary scale toward increasingly tactile forms of currency” (qtd. in Alborn 192). Bagehot's reliance on Darwinian language becomes more explicit in Lombard Street (1873), where he writes that “the rough and vulgar structure of English commerce is the secret of its life, . . . for it contains the ‘propensity to variation,’ which, in the social as in the animal kingdom, is the principle of progress” (qtd. in Alborn 192). The relationship between economics and evolution finds thematic expression in Wives and Daughters, which shows the most progressive adaptations to be economic ones involving the productive use of credit.
The novel, then, functions as a “provincial laboratory” (d'Albertis 138) in which readers observe characters’ adaptations to the changing economy and social upheaval of the pre-Reform Bill era. The text's characters represent a broad spectrum of provincial society, including not only young middle-class women (Molly and Cynthia), but the squirearchy (Mr. Hamley and his heir, Osborne), the merchant class (Mrs. Hamley before her marriage), the emergent professional class (Mr. Gibson), the Whig aristocracy (the Cumnors), the new scientist (Roger Hamley), the “nabob” or British class enriched by Indian trade (Mr. Coxe, who inherits from his uncle), the governess (Clare/Mrs. Gibson), the spinster (the Miss Brownings), and the servant (Aimée). Gaskell invites readers to apply to her fictional world the detailed observation of the natural scientist, the kind of observation that Lewes invited when he urged readers to “COME with me, and lovingly study Nature, as she breathes, palpitates, and works under myriad forms of Life – forms unseen, unsuspected, or unheeded by the mass of ordinary men” (Jan. 1860: 61). Gaskell deploys thick realistic description to locate her characters in detailed connection to each other and to their historical, cultural, and economic circumstances. And as she invites us to observe the adaptations that characters make (or fail to make), she represents all characters as enjoying the possibility of adapting to the new economy.
At the novel's inception, the Hamleys’ decline is not inevitable; on the contrary, Gaskell holds out the possibility of their seizing advantage of new economic possibilities. The narrator remarks that “they were not an adventurous race. They never traded, or speculated, or tried agricultural improvements of any kind. . . . [C]ontinuing the primitive manners and customs of his forefathers . . . [Squire Hamley] did live more as a yeoman, when such a class existed, than as a squire of this generation” (Gaskell 40; ch. 4; qtd. in Debrabant 18). As Debrabant notes, the terminology (“race,” “primitive,” “when such a class existed”) is Darwinian. However, Gaskell greatly complicates this picture by introducing Mrs. Hamley, daughter of a Russian trader. Inspired by the mercantile ethos of her family, Mrs. Hamley urges the Squire to drain his land, an improvement that could double the estate's value and that temporarily renders him more progressive than the Cumnors and other surrounding property owners. Importantly, however, the Squire is hampered by the estate's entail, which prevents him from financing such improvements: “He had sometimes thought how wise a step it would have been could he have sold a portion of [the estate], and with the purchase-money have drained and reclaimed the remainder” (258; ch. 22). To Debrabant's list of factors hampering the Hamleys (primogeniture, parental control of mate choice, social homogeneity), Gaskell thus adds economic ones (the inability to invest or speculate on their main capital asset, the estate).
Even so hampered, the Squire determines how to raise speculative capital: he “learn[s] from some neighbour that Government would make certain advances for drainage, &c. at a very low rate of interest, on condition that the work was done, and the money repaid, within a given time” (258; ch. 22). However, Mrs. Hamley's death blunts the Squire's productive speculation; without his wife to encourage him, he grows “indifferent” (258; ch. 22). Moreover, Osborne's debts cripple him: the Squire can no longer fund the drainage works and lays off his workers. Significantly, the Squire's greatest humiliation takes place near his abandoned drainage works, close to the Cumnors’ new drainage works (supervised by Preston). The irony is palpable: the Squire was prescient in his drainage project, which is now imitated by others. In this economic context, the main issue facing the Hamleys is not depleted genetic stock but the entail on the estate, which prevents them from selling or mortgaging the property in order to improve it.
Osborne thus emerges as the main victim of the systems of primogeniture and estate entail, which prepare him to be nothing but the future holder of land on which he can raise no capital. He is thus paralyzed in his relation to money by the entailed estate, a paralysis that, as much as his ill health, spells his doom. He borrows, but only as speculation on a static inheritance, one that the text portrays as outside the modern credit economy. And when he does borrow, he spends rather than invests. The text thus distinguishes between productive and unproductive assets, as well as between productive and unproductive debt. Yet Osborne does try to participate in the market by means of his literary skills, imagining earning money in the literary marketplace (as did Gaskell herself, of course, by publishing the novel). Hughes and Lund note that Osborne is familiar with the leading quarterlies of the period, the Quarterly and Blackwood's, and that he contemplates structures, reviewers, and audiences for his poems, speculating that his work would sell “if I called [my wife] ‘Lucy’” (presumably after Wordsworth's Lucy poems) (Hughes and Lund 28; Gaskell 272; ch. 23). He is not incompetent, then, so much as mired in the social expectations borne by the estate's heir. In a scene reinforced in the serial by George Du Maurier's illustration, Osborne bitterly confronts this trap:
“What in the world can I do to secure an income?” thought Osborne, as he stood on the hearth-rug, his back to a blazing fire, his cup of coffee sent up in the rare old china that had belonged to the Hall for generations; his dress finished, as dress of Osborne's could hardly fail to be. One could hardly have thought that this elegant young man, standing there in the midst of comfort that verged on luxury, should have been turning over that one great problem in his mind; but so it was. “What can I do to be sure of a present income?” (269–70; ch. 23)
The inbreeding and fossilization of the squirearchy, therefore, gives us only half the picture. Just as important is Osborne's negative relationship to the market economy, which prevents him from capitalizing on the estate or pursuing a profession. This static relation to money applies similarly to some wealthy middle-class characters: Mr. Coxe, the novel's most ridiculous figure, also inherits wealth that, because he neither earns nor invests it, dooms him to social stasis in Gaskell's view, even as he achieves upward mobility.
In this reading of the novel, Roger emerges not only as a moral man of science (DeWitt 2) modeled on Darwin himself, but also as a man of productive credit who invests his intellectual capital (selling his talents “to the highest bidder” [Gaskell 367; ch. 32]) in order to support Osborne's family and to re-finance the work of improving the estate. When appointed to the scientific expedition, his first move is to borrow on his new credit, insure his life, and hand over the money so that the Squire may continue the drainage works. This move, we argue, is as crucial as the young Osborne's birth in rejuvenating the Hamleys: his productive relation to money and credit will allow Roger to marry Molly, thus blending the gentry and professional middle classes and enriching the family bloodline. In this respect, it is important not only that Roger is “powerfully-made” (87; ch. 8) and “strong-built” (186; ch. 16), terms that, as Debrabant notes, predict his “success and prosperity” in this Darwinian text (18), but also that he is not the first-born son, a position of traditional advantage that Gaskell suggests can be constraining. Instead, Roger's status as the second son opens up possibilities of engagement with the professional world, work, and the market that would otherwise be closed to him. The novel emphasizes the position of the second-born when Lord Hollingford invites Roger – not Osborne or the Squire – to dinner to meet the distinguished scientist “Geoffroi St. H –” (315; ch. 27). The invitation represents the first step up the ladder for the second son, who will earn his way through knowledge and work rather than be stalemated by static inherited wealth. Osborne's death thus simply reinforces Roger's place as the “first” son in evolutionary and economic terms.
In its unrelenting evolutionary logic, the novel starkly contrasts with Gaskell's short story “The Half-Brothers” (1859), in which the weak younger brother is saved from death in a snowstorm by his older and tougher half-sibling. Wives and Daughters permits no such counter-evolutionary heroism: Roger tries desperately to save Osborne but is unable to do so. Yet while the novel's plot unrelentingly follows evolutionary logic, the narrative richly mourns Osborne's death. This death, the old Squire's grief, and Molly's active work in helping the family through their mourning constitute as large a narrative focus as Roger's success – and, indeed, it is Molly's prolonged stay with the Hamleys during the period of mourning that precipitates her renewed romance with Roger.
Thus the anticipated marriage of Roger and Molly represents not just a Darwinian blending of the landed gentry with the professional classes but a coming together of the two people in the text who have learned to thrive in the credit economy, generously and successfully investing their intellectual and social capital. Whereas Cynthia receives an account book as her wedding present from Lady Cumnor, Molly and Roger need no such gift, for they have already established their financial survival skills in the emergent capitalist economy of the late 1820s. Moreover, by exemplifying the patient observer of nature, Roger represents not only the moral man of science, but also the novelist, who studies “forms unseen, unsuspected, or unheeded by the mass of ordinary men” (Lewes Jan.1860: 61). As Amy M. King notes, natural science's “twinned reverence for minute details and for the commonplace finds its cognate expression in literary realism” (159). To this patient study of nature, cognate with the project of the realist writer, Roger introduces Molly; it is thus appropriate that his first gift to her should be a wasp's nest. In this respect, Molly figures Gaskell, who herself came of age in the late 1820s and who in maturity thrived in the increasingly competitive and credit-based literary market of the mid-Victorian period.
