Following renewed scholarly interest in the Constitutio Antoniniana after its (supposed) 1800th anniversary, Arnaud Besson presents ‘an attempt at a synthesis on the socio-juridical impact of this edict […] taking as its central question what it meant to be a Roman citizen, both for individuals and for the provincial administration, in the aftermath of this event’ (17). His main concern is not the motivations behind Caracalla's decision, but rather the consequences of the universalisation of Roman citizenship (18). The resulting monograph, based on a doctoral thesis defended in 2018, has many strengths and some weaknesses typical of this type of publication.
B. offers a valuable review of the many debates surrounding one of the most important issues in the social and legal history of the Roman Empire. He rightly insists that much remains obscure, not least because scholars have traditionally been more interested in the motivations for the CA than in its effects. B. divides his discussion into four main chapters (each with many subsections): ‘I Sources’ (23–104), ‘II Octrois’ (105–81), ‘III Conflits de droits?’ (183–278), ‘IV Institutions exclusives’ (279–371). The focus is on the legal aspects of Roman citizenship and this is the area where the monograph proves strongest. Many legal technicalities are discussed in impressive detail, particularly in chapters 2 and 3. The synthesis of previous work is very complete, insightful, presented in an orderly format and almost always with references to the legal sources, both in the original and in translation.
The effect of this painstaking work is, however, somewhat marred by a tendency to excessive discussion of issues relating to earlier periods that do not do much to elucidate the (supposed) focus of the monograph: the Constitutio Antoniniana. One sometimes feels that the effort to show the full extent of his research causes B. to lose focus on the central questions. The attention given to different topics and texts is also rather uneven. For example, the Tabula Banasitana receives lengthy treatment (153–64), but difficult aspects of other key sources such as Augustus’ Cyrene Edicts (e.g. the term Ῥωμαιότητι or the sequence ἐμ μέρει τῷ τῶν Ἑλλήνων σώματι) are essentially overlooked (148–50). The treatment of other important figures such as Aelius Aristides (256) is superficial and the translation of Menander's πολιτευόμεθα in ‘ce sont en effet les lois communes des Romains qui nous gouvernent’ even misleading. The extremely fragmented structure of the chapters, with excurses on a range of different topics, often makes it hard to get a clear picture of what happened immediately before and after the CA, especially when the patchy analysis of this crucial period is compared to the relatively full discussion of some republican and Justinianic matters. The final chapter is the most disappointing in this respect. Just one example: the interesting issue of what happened to the many conventus civium Romanorum in the third century only receives passing mention and without taking into account all the available evidence (294). By contrast, the discussion of Sidonius Apollinaris’ views on peregrines in the fifth century occupies several pages.
The handling of epigraphic sources does not always show the same deep understanding as that of the documentary papyri. For instance, a discussion of post-CA inscriptions recording the ius trium liberorum only mentions Sparta by name, even though the footnote mostly contains evidence from Termessos (319). When Termessos is mentioned later, in relation to the heres extraneus, there is no reference to the corpus (362). One starts to doubt whether R. Heberdey's material has actually been consulted in the original. This somewhat weaker command of the epigraphic evidence can also be seen in several mistakes in transcribing inscriptions (e.g. 143–4 or 244 where part of the Greek text is superfluous and the translation not provided). There is also a strange — and, for that matter, largely irrelevant — discussion of an Ephesian inscription that appears to mention Ulpian's De Officio; B. seems surprised by the absence of an accent on a particular word (272). There are some other minor typos throughout the main text (e.g. 21, 341, 360), although my main concern relates to the analysis of onomastics. Aurelius and Aurelios are sometimes treated as different names (47, 49), the importance of local epigraphic habits is not discussed and the role of loyalism in the adoption of the imperial nomen very much downplayed. Even granting that the focus of the analysis is determining the date of Caracalla's edict, the list of available evidence could have been more complete.
My review, in any case, shall not diminish the many strengths of this book. The conclusions are solid, the bibliography up-to-date and the indices very helpful. Some important earlier work such as Buraselis’ Θεία δωρεά (1989 and 2007) should have been better acknowledged in the introduction, but the present monograph provides a wider and deeper study than other recent additions to the topic, particularly as regards legal technicalities such as mixed marriages, criminal law, successions and wills, to name a few. Anyone interested in those complex issues will find the book extremely knowledgeable and easily available in open-access. However, a more general public trying to understand the third century a.d. or the social impact of the CA and its implications for issues such as local identity, Roman imperialism or resistance — cf. Artemidorus of Daldis’ view on Roman citizenship as recently exposed by P. Thonemann (An Ancient Dream Manual, 2020) — might not be completely satisfied with the result.
