I expected Unfit for Democracy: The Roberts Court and the Breakdown of American Politics by Stephen E. Gottlieb to be an in-depth examination of the controversial decisions of the Roberts Court and an attempt to explain these outcomes. However, there is not a sustained discussion of the Roberts Court until page 189 of the book. The focussed discussion of the Roberts Court runs to about forty pages. In the preceding pages, the author covers a wide variety of issues, some in depth and others more fleetingly, making a broad case for a “democratic” approach to judicial decision making. The purpose of the book, according to the author, is to challenge “every aspect of conservative legal thought, its history, its ethnocentrism, its method of interpretation, its method of interpreting the Constitution, its values, and its democratic bonafides” (4). This is an important goal, but the author fails to make a sustained and coherent case. The effort is much more impressionistic in nature.
The book covers much narrative ground, from twentieth-century court history to foreign courts to historical and contemporary paramilitary groups. But the narrative jumps from issue to issue often quite randomly and abruptly, causing the reader to lose a sense of the overall project. Indeed, the author notes in the acknowledgments that the book contains, in whole or in part, five law-review articles on varying topics. The first two-thirds of the book read like it was sewn together from these articles. After the chapter on the Roberts Court, the book ends on a discussion of constitutional interpretation, with Roberts Court conservatives occasionally woven into the narrative. On its own, the chapter is an effective overview of a variety of interpretive methods, but it might have been more useful at the beginning of the book, not the end.
The chapter on the Roberts Court offers some effective critiques of the court's attacks on racial protections and its support for corporations, although the discussion of Citizens United v. FEC (2010) is quite brief and could have been more effectively deployed to support the author's thesis. As he writes, “As the Court's decisions concentrate wealth they increase the stakes for rich and poor alike, ultimately threatening a showdown over democracy” (226). Discussions of the Establishment Clause and Second Amendment rights are less developed. The latter is a significant gloss-over – the court's activist decision in District of Colombia v. Heller (2008) barely gets a page-length discussion. In that case the court created a new, individual right to bear arms for personal self-defense, departing from two hundred years of jurisprudence in which the Second Amendment was viewed in terms of militia service. This case was the result of a well-orchestrated political and legal strategy to create a New Right from conservative groups, but this is not explored in the book. The author claims that the book includes extensive insights from political science, but this is an area where more attention to the existing literature would have been useful.
The Roberts Court's remarkable decisions on marriage equality, led by Justice Anthony Kennedy and the four most liberal members of the court, is discussed on the last two pages of the book in two brief paragraphs – literally as an afterthought. More attention to these cases might have brought more complexity to the analysis while not taking away from the court's clear conservative shift in many areas of jurisprudence and policy, especially as the Roberts Court, as it has been ideologically constituted for some time, faces an uncertain future.
Gottlieb has an important goal with this book, but he ultimately falls a bit short of making a strong and compelling case, given the lack of sustained attention to the Roberts Court itself and the issues with the book's organization and scope of analysis – sometimes too broad and unfocussed, sometimes underdeveloped.
