For years, what has animated the study of the Islamic law of marriage and divorce has been a focus on the state of Muslim women today. How refreshing, therefore, to find a study of the topic that takes a different starting point, one that seeks to understand the ways that premodern Muslim jurists constructed notions of family, femininity, and masculinity. While certainly aware of modern debates, Kecia Ali argues that scholars have not fully understood the dynamics that created premodern legal discourses in the first place. Marriage and Slavery in Early Islam is therefore not only an exemplary study of Islamic law in the formative period, but it also sets the stage for a new sort of feminist inquiry into the past.
Despite the title, Ali's focus is squarely on the institution of marriage and divorce; she uses aspects of slave law only as a foil for understanding the ways that jurists conceived of marriage. As she clearly indicates, she is not trying to reconstruct what marriage was actually like for Muslim men and women of the formative period. Rather, her quarry is a thorough understanding of the imaginary worlds of the Muslim scholar and the ways that logic and semantics determined the outcome of arguments. As such, this book serves as an excellent introduction to Islamic law, specifically to the ways that Muslim jurists developed categories and arguments.
Ali opens her book with a useful overview of the formative period in Islamic law, including the problems of relating legal texts to social practice. Immediately, she demonstrates the power that narrative held in the early texts. Al-Shafiʿi discusses a Bedouin woman who was brought before the Caliph ʿUmar ibn al-Khattab, accused of having sex with her male slave. She had assumed that the right given to masters to have sex with their slaves extended to her. For Ali, al-Shafiʿi's use of this tale represents a moment when experts on Islamic law began to develop a hermeneutical system that would prevent this sort of “incorrect” interpretation of the authoritative texts. The result, she argues, was a “surprisingly coherent vision of marriage” (p. 24).
Ali devotes the rest of her book to laying out this vision. In Chapter 1, she again uses narrative to call attention to “the universe of unspoken agreements” (p. 30) that formed the foundation of jurists’ discussions. Ali deftly points out that in spite of their many disputes regarding interstitial categories, they agreed on basic roles for women and men in any marriage agreement. She also, slowly, develops a larger argument in this chapter that results in an application of Ehud Toledano's definition of slavery to marriage; she observes that “wives were legally subordinate to a lesser extent than slaves . . . and yet still capable of responding within the constraints of the unequal legal and human relationships they had with their husbands” (p. 64).
A nuanced understanding of both marriage and slavery in this period is an essential basis for the central three chapters of this book, as Ali walks readers through the major legal institutions of marriage: maintenance support, rules on apportionment of time among multiple wives, and divorce. The pattern she follows for each of these chapters is to begin with a key narrative, delve deeply into the notions that occupy the jurists, and close with a discussion of larger comparative frames. In Chapter 2, she begins by clarifying that while both wives and slaves were due to receive maintenance support, the rules were different for each, since wives received support regardless of need. Ali's conclusions in this chapter reveal her debt to Jewish feminist scholarship, as she states: “sex, support, reproduction, and household labor are common concerns for the rabbis and their Muslim counterparts, but what they do with them differs considerably” (p. 95).
The subsequent chapter addresses one of these unique aspects of Islamic law: its demand that a man with multiple wives give each of them equal time. Once again, Ali points out that while polygamous marriages may have represented a small minority of all marriages in the social reality of the formative period, they nonetheless represent the norm in the texts of Islamic law. “The categories . . . structure the types of answer that can be given but also, more basically, the types of questions that are asked” (p. 98). Here and in the next chapter, Ali is well aware of Muslim feminists who argue that fundamental rights were accorded women in Islamic law. But as Ali points out, most schools of law did not recognize a woman's right to sexual satisfaction in the marriage once that marriage had been consummated (pp. 114–15), and while the jurists were ready with advice to treat wives humanely, the notion of marital rape was “an oxymoron,” since rape was understood as a property crime (p. 120). In the conclusion to Chapter 4 on divorce, Ali squarely addresses the arguments of three Muslim feminists in what she calls “a common failure to see the interconnected nature of jurisprudential discourse” (p. 161).
Chapter 5, in a sense, is the coup de grace for this line of argumentation. Here Ali looks at three specific cases to understand what precisely is meant by the fact that both marriage and slaveholding are referred to as forms of milk (dominion). The conclusion to this chapter responds again to modern concerns by driving home the point that while the various legal schools differ in small details, “the basic control over [the wife's] sexuality and physical mobility that the husband gains by the marriage contract . . . is the same” (p. 186). Once again benefiting from Jewish feminist interpretation, Ali declares that this male privilege means that “there can be no level playing field” for women in matters of marriage and divorce (p. 195).
It is important to remember that a shared discourse does not mean that premodern jurists agreed on a common vision of the world, only that they discussed it in similar terms. Likewise, it is important not to overemphasize the extent to which their system was sealed off from social reality. As Ali points out, many of these jurists were slaveholders and husbands (pp. 21–22). Finally, while issues of sex, power, and household formation are still very much alive today, the Muslim world has changed dramatically in the last 1,000 years. Within this changing world, it is reasonable to turn to founding discourses for guidance, and Marriage and Slavery in Early Islam will help Muslims and non-Muslims alike to read those sources in an engaged and honest fashion. It is a polished, well-written text, ideal for the advanced undergraduate or graduate classroom and suitable for any general reader ready to delve deeply into the formative discourses of Islamic law.
