The central innovation of Paulina Ochoa Espejo's spectacular On Borders is its focus on place. People inevitably live in geographically delimited spaces, in which they must cooperate with those around them in myriad ways to get through the day. These day-to-day interactions give rise to what Ochoa Espejo calls “place-specific duties.” Place-specific duties attach to individuals in virtue of where they are, not who they are, what role they occupy, or what legal status they hold. They include, for example, duties “of local civic life, like being a good neighbor, respecting sacred places, sharing communal areas, and generally allowing for provision of services and good communal life in the locality” (22). The fulfillment of place-based duties gives rise to corresponding rights, including mainly that others do their duties to support shared communal life (22). It is, Ochoa Espejo says, a view that sets civic participation in local communities as its goal and ideal.
Moreover, an attention to place can help us better understand the role that borders play in the lives of individuals. Attention to place can also guide us (where possible) to shape borders in ways that are more respectful of the communities that people form as they live and work together, and which are often shaped around specific geographical features. To make her case, Ochoa Espejo first outlines what she terms the “Desert Island” treatment of borders, a view that takes for granted that hard borders surround jurisdictions of individuals who are “neatly divided into territories that contain peoples and their just states” (52). But she says, the assumption that territories neatly delineate peoples into independent states is misleading because wrong. The Desert Island model is contrasted with the preferred Watershed model, which recommends instead that borders are drawn around places rather than peoples (173). It is a model developed from within the “topiary” tradition in political theory: “Topian thinking seeks to understand the normative and empirical relations between political institutions and the natural and built environments” (125).
How does this understanding help us to understand where to draw the border? For Ochoa Espejo, the question of where specifically to place a border is about how to “conserve the places and networks of place-specific relations that have arisen in and around the territory and its constituent places” (197). This strategy, she says, is a bottom-up approach to drawing borders, one that better accounts for the lived experience of border placement (198). The advice is sound: Ochoa Espejo demonstrates effectively that the way that residents on the ground experience borders, and also the geographical features that define their shared space, rarely matches how states treat borders and their protection. Ultimately, her advice is not about the proper placement of borders (no guidelines are offered for where to place them if they are contested, for example), but rather about the importance of designing and redesigning borders in collaboration with those who are there.
Territorial rights are plural and include not only the right of border control, but also the rights to govern in a specific jurisdiction and to control and shape resource use in that jurisdiction (207). The right to border control specifically is embedded in, and justified at least in part by, an international system that recognizes the fact of borders and the good they can do in general, to provide stability and enable coordination among states. Respect for the international order of states can also, Ochoa Espejo says optimistically, give relatively weaker states room to work against the inequities of the current world order. Moreover, she adds, “civil practices of transborder cooperation and civic participation in the borderlands can lead to changes in the management and control of border regimes” (217). Crucially, this requirement for cooperation between bordering states means that the unilateral construction of a border wall cannot be justified; among many other harms such an action can generate, is the division of communities that would otherwise prefer to engage in networks of cooperation across “official” borders, but which are denied the ability to do so.
What does such a view recommend with respect to immigration? On this view, migrants who are present and thus involved in local networks of cooperation are entitled to stay, regardless of their visa status. What if their presence seems disruptive to the larger cooperative community, as for example some have said of migrant day laborers in some American jurisdictions, who wait in groups at specific locations with the hope of being hired for the day? Espejo Ochoa dismisses this worry, saying they “disrupt space-specific cooperation only to the extent that they are not allowed to fully participate in it” (245). This response is unsatisfying, however, not because it is wrong (it is not), but because it fails to adequately confront the possibility that those who come first to places may have views about who should and should not be included in those networks of cooperation into the future.
On Ochoa Espejo's account, place-specific rights (for migrants) do not translate directly into the right to stay permanently, that is, citizenship. They may do so in time, in virtue of the inevitable interconnections between place-specific rights in local jurisdictions and the wider set of rights accorded at other levels of government, but they may not. The virtue of this account is its attentiveness to the rights that travel with residence; its vice is that nonstatus migrants’ access to citizenship is contingent and accidental. The account will therefore not satisfy those who argue in favor of naturalizing long-term nonstatus migrants, and Ochoa Espejo does not offer an account of why it ought to do so.
If there is a weakness to this richly textured and deeply insightful book, it is Ochoa Espejo's efforts to paint nearly all of her argumentative foes as hyperfocused on the importance of identity groups in delineating borders; even those who reject an identitarian understanding of borders and focus instead on developing the concept of “people” are accused of doing so implicitly. The fixation on the mechanism by which borders protect and preserve identity groups has plagued much early political theory of migration, certainly, but later political theory of territory has largely dispensed with a focus on identity.
Ochoa Espejo's insistence that recent accounts of territorial jurisdiction rely implicitly on identitarian commitments means that she is less attentive to the ways in which her view is complementary, rather than fundamentally opposed, to earlier accounts, many of which are quite attentive to the place-based considerations that motivate her project. Moreover, because she picks out the worst forms of identitarian policies—she describes Donald Trump as a “leading identitarian”—she risks offending those who may offer good reasons, ones worth engaging with, to think about the value that identity can offer to human lives. Without denying that identity claims often lead to unjustified exclusion, the role that identity connections play in the lives of individuals can be acknowledged. Indeed, many people will describe their place-based duties and obligations in terms of a place-based identity, and it seems straightforwardly wrong that an attention to place requires abandoning an attention to identity.
On Borders is full of illustrative examples from around the world, which help to show the benefits of adopting a place-based view, and it draws on an impressively wide range of traditions in political theory, both historical and contemporary. It weaves in a deep concern with the way in which communities interact with the environment in which they live. Ochoa Espejo's book is a splendid read, and in my view should be required reading for scholars of borders from all disciplines.
