With respect to distributive justice, controversies over the sufficiency of a conception of impartiality generally involve the problem of how a standard of rational justification ignores features, values, or attributes of individuals or groups placed under scrutiny. This problem of justification has often been referred to as the adoption of “monological” moral reasoning which, as Seyla Benhabib puts it, “proceeds from the standpoint of the rational person, defined in such a way that differences among concrete selves become quite irrelevant.”Footnote 1 The stronger contention derived from this criticism is that a theory of impartiality is impossible since it must assume some rational principles which will inevitably exclude diverse others.Footnote 2
Amartya Sen offers a comparative account of impartiality in which difference and individual perspective are taken seriously. Throughout Sen’s analysis, it is clear that he relies on epistemological criteria to justify certain procedures while discounting others, or what Elizabeth Anderson refers to as an “epistemological strategy for dealing with the multiplicity of evaluative perspectives.”Footnote 3 At the same time, this account is, as Anderson notes, “pragmatic” with respect to finding resolution by removing the most agent-relative reasons through a process of critical scrutiny that employs trans-positional objectivity and an open impartial observer.Footnote 4 (I will explain these concepts later.) However, while Sen makes the argument that his theory avoids any kind of monological reduction or universalization of rational principles, there is a problem concerning the role of socially and historically determined normative valuesFootnote 5 and how Sen expects that a process of critical scrutiny will weed out unreasonable values, claims, and principles in order to arrive at “shared reasons.”Footnote 6
Beyond his reference to normative concepts and diversity of influences gleaned from sociological analysis,Footnote 7 there is a lacuna in which Sen leaves underdeveloped a treatment of ‘non-rational’ beliefs determining our behaviour and ethical reasoning. I use the word non-rational to reflect factors whose efficacy in shaping our ethical reasoning needs to be taken into account, yet in such a way that we should not expect these to conform to the remit of conventional standards of what it means to be rational or have adequate justification.Footnote 8 Such beliefs are not irrational but, as I will argue, in large part, constitute our human understanding since they are substantive ethical beliefs which we inherit by virtue of the historical and cultural transmission of knowledge, or those beliefs which are ‘prejudices’ according to the original, non-pejorative meaning of the word.Footnote 9 Following Paul Ricoeur, I will discuss these beliefs more specifically in terms of ‘ethical convictions’ (hereafter shortened to ‘convictions’).
This strategy is by no means trivial. As I will show, there is more to the kinds of convictions of which Ricoeur speaks than meets the eye. They are not just beliefs that favour partiality or care towards oneself or a member of one’s group. Rather, they form part of the bedrock on an entire ethical order,Footnote 10 in which meanings and values are ascribed not only to others but to what is ultimately at stake in one’s existence—eschatological, political, or otherwise. To be sure, philosophers often pay attention to such orders, particularly with reference to religious conflict (either between religions or with secularism). However, part of what Ricoeur understands by the term ‘ethical order’, and which I will explain in more detail later, is how convictions within an order are largely, if not totally, incommensurable with other orders.Footnote 11 This does not mean that the one who holds convictions is incorrigibly stubborn. Rather, it is to suggest that the order in which one’s values emerge is largely untranslatable into another order, especially one which attempts to enact an impartial form of mediation. In this respect, it is worthwhile noting that much of the analytic literature discussing debates between impartiality and partiality tacitly assume that different discourses and languages respective to competing groups are, to a large degree, unproblematically inter-translatable.Footnote 12 Or if the literature does not make this assumption, then clarification of meaning is seen to be one of the virtues and results of a process of public reasoning, coordination, or progression to more sufficient types of justice.Footnote 13 So, bringing Sen and Ricoeur into dialogue with one another offers a way of introducing and rethinking “the fact of pluralism” not simply in terms of competing values, allegiances, or moral requirements but of recognizing how such conflicts involve convictions (and therefore ethical orders) that make translation significantly problematic.
My thesis on Sen is that his theory of impartiality is incomplete insofar as he maintains that critical scrutiny from various points of view can sufficiently secure impartial judgement. Sen, I will argue, does not adequately develop a role for convictions, relying too heavily on the critical role of reason as a means of stemming and even correcting convictions. Can one accurately distill convictions into reasons given different cultural and historical traditions that inform the understandings of others?
While this is a problem concerning the adequacy of Sen’s theoretical account, it has a significant practical implication. If convictions constitute a substantial foundation for ethical reasoning, then shared reasons gained through a procedure of impartial mediation will not fully address or resolve the stronger motivations of an individual or group holding a conflicting view. In other words, one might agree to reasons, but this agreement may be superficial, even with the best intentions to attain consensus or reconciliation. As we will see, convictions are not readily revisable in view of shared reasons, and this is because they involve substantial commitments to an interpretation of how existence should be lived according to inherited ethical norms whose authority has been legitimated as a result of a group’s historically constituted identity. In many cases, especially in serious instances of cultural conflict, one is not merely faced with the task of finding shared reasons but reinterpreting centuries of a tradition of understanding and practices.Footnote 14
Ricoeur’s theory of impartiality, on the other hand, provides both a strong contrast to criticize Sen and an alternative to the resolution of conflicts within the domain of distributive justice. In short, there are two significant differences that should be noted. First, Ricoeur anchors impartiality not to a notion of objectivity but to a willingness towards mutuality. He sees impartiality as a broad ethical concept that is defined, motivated, and justified by one’s own moral tradition. Impartiality, in other words, presupposes a normative commitment to be responsible towards and respectful of ‘an other.’ Second, Ricoeur maintains that prior to reasons are convictions. If the roots of convictions run deep in how we form and assess fair procedures for resolution, then we require a conception of impartiality that does not simply attempt to bracket them out. Instead, impartiality is possible only after the conflicting parties have understood each other’s convictions. This entails not looking for reasons upon which they can agree, but making the attempt to become familiar with the history and cultural nuances of the other person’s tradition and, as mentioned earlier, ethical order. As we will see, the attempt to understand another’s ethical order differs from Sen’s appeal to positional objectivity. But for now it is necessary only to mark that Ricoeur’s approach offers a distinct advantage; namely, it does not attempt to redescribe convictions as that which are opposed to reason but instead as a major component of our rationalizing process. This not only claims a more realistic account of conflict but, as importantly for Ricoeur, it places distributive justice within a project of mutuality as opposed to agreement.
There is one qualification to note about my analysis of Ricoeur’s conception of impartiality. Ricoeur often speaks of impartiality in relation to corrective justice and legal systems. I therefore take some liberty in interpreting how impartiality relates to the distinct field of distributive justice. My claim is that this maneuver is not far-fetched if one bears in mind that while corrective and distributive justice both use impartiality to establish a “just distance” in which testimony can be heard, the latter is distinct in its search for mutual understanding.Footnote 15
This essay is divided into four sections: I will provide an analysis of I) Sen’s account of open impartiality and how it avoids the charge of universalization; II) how Sen’s theory remains incomplete when assuming that reasons are sufficient in mediating conflict; III) Ricoeur’s conception of conviction; and IV) Ricoeur’s theory of impartiality and how it involves the aim of mutuality.
I. Recapitulating Sen
For Sen, distributive justice is, in large part, secured by open impartiality, which is a participatory process that moves towards ‘better reasoning’ by exposing to critical scrutiny the rational principles which inform our commitments, choices, and value judgements.Footnote 16 The decisive part of this process is how open impartiality involves the employment of a global dimension of evaluation where reasons derived from different perspectives can be tested for justification beyond the consideration of the groups and institutions immediately involved, or what Sen calls “focal groups.”Footnote 17 Because Sen takes the role of different perspectives seriously, he is sceptical of theories of justice predicated on a conception of universality, that is, when a theory is founded on or presupposes a uniformity of principles upon which we can all agree. Sen is also critical of such theories insofar as he deems the role of universality as unnecessary and insufficient for a theory of justice.Footnote 18 He argues instead that agreement does not arise by applying an ideal standard of rational justification or set of putative universal principles, but is achieved by virtue of the participants working out their disagreements and ideally finding reasons they can share.Footnote 19 Anderson describes this as a “learning” process of reason that can help to achieve a “superior evaluative perspective.”Footnote 20
Sen is careful when explaining exactly how this alternative is theoretically and practically viable. I will summarize his account according to three stages: 1) positional objectivity; 2) trans-positional objectivity; and 3) open impartiality.
First, Sen acknowledges that positionality is inescapable and significant in the formation of values and relations to things and others; an account of perspective needs to be included when attempting to understand the value judgements of a person. Sen uses the concept of positional objectivity to explain how objectivity is present in individual perspective: what each perspective entails is a view of reality whose objectivity can be confirmed if “such an observation could be reproduced by others if placed in the same position.”Footnote 21 Thus positional objectivity is “the objectivity of what can be observed from a specific position” by anyone.Footnote 22 In this respect, Sen departs from the traditional epistemological notion of objectivity that does not require the inclusion of individual perspective in striving for interpersonal invariance.
Second, because something can be viewed from many different perspectives, there is a need to include a variety of positionally objective perspectives. Sen observes that positional objectivity from several positions is therefore “not so much a ‘view from nowhere,’ but a ‘view of no one in particular’.”Footnote 23 The collection of positionally objective views is what he refers to as a “trans-positional” form of assessment. “The constructed ‘view from nowhere’ would then be based on synthesizing different views from distinct positions.”Footnote 24 Trans-positional assessment forces a heavier justificatory burden on evaluation since we are asked to form a coherent view from the different positions.
Third, Sen makes clear that trans-positionality does not refer to a viewpoint alien to the immediate context of focal groups. Because of this, there is a caveat to trans-positional objectivity insofar as the various positions within a focal group can fall prey to “systematic illusions,” like the flatness of the earth, and “persistent misunderstandings,” like the inferiority of women.Footnote 25 What can arise from these illusions is a sense of impartiality that is fair when it is actually limited by agent-relative beliefs or misinformation. Sen refers to this as a “closed” impartiality which has three traits: “Procedural parochialism” (shared prejudices of the focal group), “Inclusionary incoherence” (exclusion of others by the criterion of the internal consistency of focal beliefs), and “Exclusionary neglect” (neglect of others outside the focal group and affected by decisions).Footnote 26 So what becomes prudent for Sen is to include an open and impartial perspective alien to the trans-positional group.
Sen’s claim is that open impartiality facilitates the process by which the reasons of competing parties can be rationally scrutinized and the process of fairness can be optimized.Footnote 27 Through an open, impartial observer values can be compared and assessed in order to identify unreasonable biases lurking under the veil of positional and trans-positional objectivity.Footnote 28 Sen’s comparative theory attempts to secure objectivity by placing the claims in question in dialogue with an observer outside the immediate debate.Footnote 29 As a whole, this process forces a comparative form of assessment whose aim is the distillation of general reasons to produce impartial reasons, or “what others cannot reasonably reject.”Footnote 30 Moreover, this comparative process is not simply formal in the sense that it provides steps to be taken; rather, it is the instantiation of reason itself since in illuminating impartial reasons, it requires us to explain such reasons in a way that others can follow.
While Sen’s theory admits some features of universalized conceptions of impartiality that rely on the ability “to represent the theoretically relevant interests of all involved persons,”Footnote 31 he refrains from the temptation of universal truth claims and the traps of stringent epistemic and cognitive requisites by reducing the remit of impartial assessments to specific situations. The role of impartiality is, above all, only situationally directed; what arises from the mediation by impartiality is never anything like the result of submitting one’s maxim to the test of the rule of universalization.Footnote 32 Instead, we hope to settle differences by consensus; and a conclusion by consensus in itself means very little to the establishment of universal values and precepts for the whole of the global community.Footnote 33 Impartiality exposes the sufficiency of reasons which at best become shared reasons amongst diverse groups with respect to a specific conflictFootnote 34 and therefore is concerned with “actual freedoms,” that is, the freedom an individual has in order to pursue his or her ends and the capability to achieve those ends.Footnote 35
Having said this, is there still a way to reassert the charge of universalism against Sen? One might allege that despite the inclusion of the third, impartial observer, procedures of reasoned scrutiny cannot but help impose some standard of justification that would misrepresent one of the parties’ beliefs. A reply to this charge lies in showing its unreasonableness. The danger of arguing from a robust notion of pluralism, or an ideology of difference, is that it forces a continual retreat from resolute judgement by forever protecting individual identity against others. As a proponent of much of Sen’s philosophy, Anderson has clarified how theorists critical of impartiality misunderstand the pragmatics of public debate if such they think preservation of individual identity is the most significant aim. Ricoeur shares this criticism when noting how “[t]he paradox is indeed that the praise of difference ends up reinforcing the internal identities of the groups themselves.”Footnote 36 Anderson concludes that what is of most importance is that individual claims are not seeking “validation of their parochial positionality as particular, but to offer up their perspective as universal, as properly shared by all.”Footnote 37 It is the supposition of universality which lends itself to genuine debate. But while assuming universality to be an integral motivation for debate, Sen’s situationally based, comparative approach does not assume that a process of debate will reach the establishment of universal principles. In any situation concerning conflict over reasons, one need only attend to the debate at hand without concern for an overarching doctrine of what constitutes justice or reason.Footnote 38 Commitments to open impartiality, as long as they are identified by each party, enable a particular debate to follow the process of scrutiny more successfully and therefore articulate and represent respective identities.
Nevertheless, one can still persist in criticizing Sen’s approach. While practical, Sen’s attempt to mute universal claims through a comparative approach leaves the role of convictions unaddressed. Even if the comparative process is not interested in establishing universals, the people engaged in debate often are, or at the very least, they see any substance of their claims as predicated on their universality. The problem with Sen is not the marginalization of diverse identities, but rather, his assumption that shared reasons are adequate for providing understanding in situations of conflict.
II. Incompleteness of Sen’s Account
The critical reading of open impartiality that I will be providing in this section relates to Sen’s account of rational debate as the process by which the diversity of values informing a person’s rationality can be translated into reasons through the use of critical scrutiny in public, reasoned debate. While his efforts have transformed the way in which economics approaches rational behaviour, my intent is to push his account further by maintaining that given the diversity of normative values, some of these values are not easily or readily translated into reasons that would have a wide public acceptability. Indeed, in cases where there tends to be a significant level of disagreement, the problem of understanding the meaning of unfamiliar concepts and practices appears the fundamental obstacle.Footnote 39
In his critical analyses of maximizing behaviour,Footnote 40 Sen acknowledges the legitimacy of normative values as influences on volitional choice-making. He rightly broadens a conception of rationality and how rational agents may be acting from convictions, precepts, or principles beyond self-interest or utility maximization. Sen therefore leaves the category of normative broad since he is content to accept it as something which is, despite whatever specific content it may have, complex and therefore not easily decipherable. He argues that it is the task of evaluative theory employed by economists to recognize the variety of normative values and be able to accommodate them in their explanatory and predictive models.Footnote 41 For instance, looking at the theory of “revealed preference” in economics, where a preference is presumed from a choice taken by an agent,Footnote 42 Sen refers to the complexion of normative influences under the term ‘social’:
[M]an is a social animal and his choices are not rigidly bound to his own preferences only. . . . An act of choice for this social animal is, in a fundamental sense, always a social act. He may be only dimly aware of the immense problems of interdependence [of “different people’s choices”] that characterize a society . . . [b]ut his behaviour is something more than a mere translation of his personal preferences.Footnote 43
‘Social’ in one sense can be defined as the relations and practices that generate what one believes to be ethical precepts consistent with the group with which one identifies.Footnote 44 Indeed, an agent’s choice does not always reveal his or her preference, and there may be other normative commitments involved.
In order to make his account more accommodating to the mire of competing normative claims, Sen relaxes some of the criteria traditionally seen to constitute rationality—such as internal consistency and completeness of rankings. In addition, he acknowledges that the interpretation of language is a perpetual obstacle; this includes not only languages foreign or unfamiliar to a focal group but also, as Sen points out, diverse “language games” in which even the same language can involve different meanings, connotations and especially “social elements” which serve to create an impasse to communication.Footnote 45
Nonetheless, despite these concessions, there is an assumption in Sen’s argument that in the arena of debate, normative values and claims can be translated into reasons that are more or less accurate in representing and justifying others’ points of view. He refers to this at one point as:
the extensive use we make of rationality in understanding what others are doing and why, and also what they know, what we can learn from what they know, and so on.Footnote 46
As Sen explains, this process is “foundationally connected with bringing our choices into conformity with critical investigation of the reasons for that choice.”Footnote 47 My contention is that he takes an overly pragmatic view to the resolution of conflicts. Instead of persisting with the uniqueness of discourses and language games, Sen maintains that the process of reasoned debate requires conflicting parties to express their “non-conformist proposals” through “conformist rules.”Footnote 48 This assumes that an articulation of beliefs according to existing rules is not significantly problematic.Footnote 49 But there are at least two reasons as to why we should think otherwise. First, conformist rules and the concepts employed by these rules are taken to be adequate in representing a person’s point of view and the tradition to which he or she attaches meaning. Second, Sen assumes that people involved in reasoned debate understand the rules and concepts presented to them and the authority the rules have in governing the debate. As we will see later, for Ricoeur the project of translation ought to include the attempt to understand an ethical order from within its own system and concepts. This provides not only a more sufficient means of understanding the claims of another, but it can also provide a critical function for an existing institution or focal group by contrasting a convention with what would be normally viewed as unfamiliar or even prohibited.Footnote 50 Sen’s approach assumes that this critical function can still retain its integrity when another’s claims are translated by “conformist rules.”Footnote 51
A concrete instance of the problem of translatability, and one relating directly to claims of distributive justice, is the conceptualization of land as an economic factor of production. Especially, since the marginal revolution of the 1870s, it is now commonplace to assume land is not a distinct factor of production; it is either subsumable under labour (as with Marx) or capital (as Pareto declared).Footnote 52 The loss of this classical distinction arguably endorses a legal conception of landownership that allows land to be exclusive, private property since it is not seen as something ontologically distinct and therefore requiring special treatment or definition. For example, opposed to the idea of exclusive, private property in land is the notion of possession of land by usufruct—that is to say, one retains legal possession of land only insofar as he or she is using it for production or to live. There are, of course, many reasons one can cite in favour of and against usufruct. Such debates originated with the classical economists (i.e., Smith, Malthus, and Ricardo) and continue to this day with respect to a neutral land value tax.Footnote 53 My point here is that, despite the wealth of reasons for possession of land by usufruct, there may be underlying normative values that act as substantive meanings for why someone might insist that there can be no such thing as exclusive, private property in land. Native North Americans, the True Levellers, and supporters of Henry George share this idea but have, nonetheless, different ethical orders underwriting their convictions.Footnote 54 Is it enough in these instances to rely merely upon reasons in conformity to existing rules of a focal group?
It seems difficult to say ‘yes.’ By digging deeper into meanings, values, and concepts, one begins to understand more fully how and why a position is taken, and what may in fact result is a view through which the predominant focal group’s practices can be revised.Footnote 55 To see the expediency and sufficiency of a land value tax that is often paired with usufruct, in other words, is not the same thing as seeing why exclusive claims to land are ethically prohibited. To allow this misunderstanding to persist is not only to misunderstand the distinctness of ethical goods versus economic ones, but also to ignore the kinds of practices and ends that inform one type of goods compared to the other. To maintain the distinction in choosing ethical goods, on the other hand, allows the ethical force of something like a land value tax policy to be apprehended as a form of ethical practice (and not simply a value-neutral or even optimal policy). Moreover, it helps one make sense of our own historical traditions—i.e., the classical period of political economy, where one finds other ethical norms underwriting, for example, Adam Smith’s decision to uphold landownership despite the just nature of a land tax.Footnote 56
Returning to issues concerning rules of debate and translatability, there is the problem of Sen’s conception of rational discussion which seems to ignore contingent features involved in the endeavour to achieve successful communication. In procedures of debate where convictions are no longer legitimate and where the only things admissible are reasons, actors within a debate can tend towards a compromise of their own beliefs in view of a possible remedy to a conflict. This often happens in everyday circumstances where one person will translate another person’s thoughts (“Is what you mean this . . . ?”). The other person often consents in the interest of moving the discussion forward, not realizing until later that the terms have shifted the focus and potential outcomes of the debate. Such shifts, as Hagi Kenaan points out, create distinct standards of successful reasoning in communication, standards which exclude a middle ground where meaning is only inchoately understood because it is difficult to articulate in another way.Footnote 57 It seems likely that Sen can only view the establishment of such standards as a process of moving towards better reasoning.
In view of these contentions, it is questionable whether Sen accounts for other people sufficiently. Indeed, he mentions only how rational agents need to take into account other people beyond the narrow description of agency as self-maximizing.Footnote 58 Within Sen’s development of commitment, relation to others, even if altruistic, is a relation to their welfare and not necessarily their beliefs. This formulation is overly narrow since it does not require an adequate understanding of another.Footnote 59 So while Sen may be sympathetic to identifying normative values when theorizing about them, I think there is a pressure on him to do more. Reasons, in other words, only scratch the surface of what is happening in conflicts of distributive justice.
III. Ricoeur on Convictions
Ricoeur develops his account of convictions according to an epistemological distinction he finds not only more realistic in view of everyday conflicts but productive when understood in a broader framework. Because theories about argumentation like Sen’s often focus on separating forms of bad reasoning from forms of better reasoning, there is a correlative tendency to view beliefs like convictions as those things which need to be discarded if they lack a certain standard of justification. When understood as beliefs lacking reasoned self-scrutiny, convictions occupy the place of parochial reasoning that Sen describes. Contrary to this, Ricoeur insists that convictions express a form of commitment to values and meanings whose normative content has authority for a focal group yet remains to be worked out and justified practically, that is, according to emergent situations of conflict. Convictions, as he will say, are therefore always “considered convictions,”Footnote 60 that is, beliefs that express a universal claim but are inchoately justified because they have yet to be applied and worked out according to real situations.
For Ricoeur, there is no epistemological foundation for convictions if what is meant by foundation is a self-secured and certain beginning. Convictions are ethical beliefs that arise from within the context of an already existing ethical order or system of values.Footnote 61 As he qualifies, convictions are not ‘beliefs that’ but ‘beliefs in’; exactly that to which the ‘in’ refers involves already existing values one has inherited through history and tradition.Footnote 62 So, in this respect, one has a belief in one’s capacity to make decisions by virtue of an existing order of ethical values. As ‘convicted,’ I am convinced a decision made is ‘good’ according to the context of my ethical values. Convictions are truly normative in the sense that they are possible only because an ethical order provides a “totality of signification” in which one can distinguish between good and bad actions.Footnote 63 Ricoeur, like Alasdair MacIntyre, describes this feature of knowing and decision-making in terms of order, that is, an order of some kind that precedes each of us and is often recognizable as a tradition of practices and shared understanding:
The term “order” conceals the greatest difficulty for ethico-juridical philosophy, namely, the status of the authority attached to this . . . order, that which even makes it an order.Footnote 64
We recognize ethical orders according to the way in which we recognize what has authority over our decision-making. Thus, to reason one’s way to a judgement about a choice requires the values, given by and accepted on authority, in order to delineate a good choice from a bad one. Ricoeur’s fundamental point is to show that, within the ethical domain, our reasons for acting in one way and not another are not reasons in the fully choate form of being justified. Rather, they are convictions that arise from within an ethical order which we are then brought to justify in situations of conflict.
In other words, convictions act as criteria for what an agent believes to be the basis for a prudent choice. These criteria are not identical to justifications: In situations of moral conflict, rational agents make decisions concerning how to act as if they were anticipating a requirement of justification. Criteria can then be employed in the task of justifying an action should the agent be held accountable by someone else, an institution, or even the agent him- or herself. The criteria provided by an ethical order enable an agent to believe (to be convinced) that what he or she is doing is good, right, or prudent. But the move from relying on criteria for justification presupposes the language in which justificatory statements are made is either unproblematic or transparent in meaning. And this, as we will see in the final section, is precisely that with which Ricoeur takes issue. But for now, let us note how Ricoeur emphasizes that convictions are beliefs that enable one to act (‘I can’), whereas Sen holds a weaker standard for responsible agency insofar as we need only make causal connections between our choices and possible outcomes.Footnote 65 And this standard is perhaps presupposed by his assumption that shared reasons can be rather easily and practically ascertained.
Nonetheless, a critic of Ricoeur might argue that the relation of convictions to justification is viciously circular, epistemologically and ideologically. If we do not appeal to anything beyond convictions, whatever we argue will simply presuppose those convictions. Ricoeur’s counter is that any circularity between convictions and justification entails a process of critical revision wherein the demand for justification becomes a way of revising one’s convictions from within his or her ethical order.
Epistemologically speaking, Ricoeur understands ethical reasoning as a reasoning “aware of its own lack of foundation”Footnote 66 and therefore seeking to justify actions through a process of argumentation within one’s own tradition. Because convictions lack certainty (e.g., I am convinced of something but not certain of it), their validation arises through argumentation with others who do not agree. Such challenges put an ethical order under strain to respond reflectively. Similar to MacIntyre’s notion of internal revision of a tradition through rival conflict, Ricoeur emphasizes that any revision is not one in which another order imposes itself. Rather, external pressure allows for a refiguration of existing beliefs and values.Footnote 67 Furthermore, Ricoeur grants that this process of argumentation articulates universal claims with the caveat that no justification can ever completely secure a claim’s universality. So while “No moral conviction would have any force if it did not make a claim to universality,” for Ricoeur, a conviction is “an alleged or inchoative universal seeking recognition.”Footnote 68 The process of seeking recognition is a process of validation through argumentation whose conclusion attests to a universal principle of some kind that itself is subject to further validation according to new situations that arise, or what is a process of verification throughout one’s whole life.Footnote 69 Ricoeur thus sees the paradigmatic model of argument and validation as being “the juridical procedures of legal interpretation” which always hold in view a law in relation to a specific context.Footnote 70 It is worth recalling that Sen sees public debate as a practical, comparative remedy without universal implications. Ricoeur, alternatively, reads the tension between universal claims and historical/situational conflict as a dialectical structure through which universal claims can gain more coherency, especially through their revision.Footnote 71
In terms of social praxis and the critique of ideology, Ricoeur does not see the circular relation between convictions and justification as a form of domination as does, for example, Pierre Bourdieu when analyzing the relation between habitus and modes of production.Footnote 72 Rather, for Ricoeur, because ethical reasoning is often faced with conflicts in specific situations, it forces the reasoning of focal groups to reassess their own assumptions and customs. There is no guarantee that this self-critical scrutiny will emerge; and critics may charge that a conception of ethical reasoning which does not more strongly force self-scrutiny is, to a large degree, inadequate. However, Ricoeur insists that genuine argumentation in the arena of distributive justice and ethics requires an appropriate hospitableness which cannot be forced. He refers to this as an inchoate mutuality in which parties are willing to receive each other. At the same time, he is not saying that procedures of justice, which require debate and arbitration, should be expunged, only that while such procedures may be in place and enforced, they cannot guarantee genuine debate since this requires both parties to be willing to recognize and respect each other.Footnote 73
Ricoeur refers to this generally as a “linguistic hospitality,” noting that the conflicts of distributive justice usually involve conflict at the level of diverse languages; even when parties speak the same language, as Sen too recognizes, different conceptual connotations, customs, and normative meanings can be hidden. Thus, the normativity of different languages requires a translation process between parties. However, unlike Sen, Ricoeur emphasizes the notion of hospitality: Translation between parties is not possible unless a certain amount of charity is granted to the other as expressing a rational and coherent view, which includes and does not omit their convictions:
This phenomenon of linguistic hospitality can serve as a model for all instances of understanding in which the absence of what we might call a third-person overview brings into play the same operations of transference and of welcome whose model can be found in the act of translation.Footnote 74
When referring to the “third-person overview,” Ricoeur is not suggesting, like Sen, that a third impartial observer would help to remedy conflict. Rather, he is suggesting here that its absence is a fact; a third-person overview is not possible because for the third person to be entirely impartial, a neutral metalanguage would be required to translate the points of view of both sides equitably. Elsewhere Ricoeur comments:
The path of eventual consensus can emerge only from mutual recognition on the level of acceptability, that is, by admitting a possible truth, admitting proposals of meaning that are at first foreign to us.Footnote 75
In short, it is the distance in communication separating individuals and groups that provides for a genuine mutuality; genuine because communication must be ‘won’ through understanding a position foreign to one’s own. It is the role of impartiality, as we will see, to ensure this distance is productive.
It is true that Ricoeur places a great deal of trust in an individual’s capacity to admit another according to a linguistic hospitality, but because convictions are themselves never certain forms of knowing, they should be understood to involve a mode of communication which does not stake itself upon a claim to finality. Ricoeur therefore speaks of this component of his theory of justice as an “act of confidence” in our capacity to admit the other person into debate, without which claims to social cooperation and flourishing would be empty or an act of bad faith.Footnote 76
IV. Ricoeur on Impartiality
So far, I have presented Ricoeur’s account of convictions as that which positively and substantially underwrites a group’s claims within the domain of distributive justice. But, then, does not the normative, and therefore prejudicial, nature of convictions make impartiality impossible? In this final section, I will discuss how Ricoeur is able to retain impartiality despite the prevalence he gives to convictions and, moreover, that his account of impartiality is more convincing than Sen’s. Seeing how Ricoeur links convictions to impartial judgement requires a significant shift in assuming what impartiality is. On Sen’s account, impartiality provides an objective standpoint built on shared reasons. But for Ricoeur, since objectivity is impossible, impartiality is more accurately an inter-subjective standpoint potentially providing a “shared understanding.”Footnote 77 Where Sen wants a viewpoint “from nowhere in particular,” Ricoeur desires a more hospitable engagement.
To see the contrast between the two in more detail, let us begin with a point on which they agree: impartiality requires the ability of one group to place itself in the other’s position. Recall that, for Sen, occupying the position of another has as its aim the delineation of objective reasons that anyone occupying that position cannot reject. For Ricoeur, however, the role of placing oneself in another’s position presupposes some degree of a mutuality of understanding. How can one genuinely attempt to occupy another’s position without admitting in some way the convictions of this other person? Finding reasons cannot do this work since there are often concepts foreign to one’s perspective that cannot be easily distilled into reasons that can be shared. Indeed, Ricoeur’s distrust of shared reasons stems largely from his understanding of the complexity of religious traditions and the distinct and separate discourses—or language games—they involve.Footnote 78
But if the turn to objectivity is not possible, and if Ricoeur wishes to retain impartiality as a fundamental feature of debate, he has but one viable option: he maintains that a conception of impartiality is itself normative. In other words, the need to engage with another impartially is itself an ethical good esteemed within one’s own ethical order. But this claim is not simply a reduction of impartiality to a normative framework. Ricoeur’s strategy is to show how the normative framework enables one to transcend parochial limitations by virtue of the burden placed on oneself by the demand for impartiality articulated in one’s ethical order. The ethical demand to be impartial is exceptionally other-regarding.Footnote 79 As we will see below, as such it often identifies exceptions to the norm, according to which convictions can be revised. Ricoeur summarizes this exceptional nature as “the concept of impartiality” placed at “the summit of the ethical life.”Footnote 80
Ricoeur observes that impartiality is possible because one can impute oneself as responsible for being impartial. To impute oneself—that is, to take account of oneself—involves a self-reflexivity presupposed by the demand to be impartial. Without “the capacity of a subject to designate itself, himself, or herself as the actual author of its, his, or her own acts,” that is, “the capacity to posit oneself as an agent,”Footnote 81 one would lack the ability to recognize those situations of conflict in which one ought to strive for impartiality. Indeed, without this capacity, Sen’s explanatory account of the causal connection between a choice and its consequence does not seem sufficient unless it can be shown that this type of causal connection is innately and substantially other-regarding, and not simply concerned about the other’s welfare.Footnote 82 Or, at the very least, Sen would have to account for how different groups may express different beliefs for what it means to be impartial and how this fits with his notion of the kind of impartial judgement that should preside over these diverse beliefs in public debate.
If there are many ways in which ethical orders determine how an action and its consequences can be evaluated under a conception of responsibility,Footnote 83 then basic to these ways is imputability and how a self, situated within his or her ethical order, is held accountable according to what is esteemed or valued in terms of good and bad actions. By virtue of an ethical order, one sees oneself as imputable according to these standards. “[E]thico-moral predicates,” as Ricoeur says,
allow us to judge and evaluate the actions considered good or bad, permitted or prohibited. When these predicates are applied reflexively to the agents themselves, these agents are said to be capable of imputation.Footnote 84
Because imputability is self-reflexive in view of ethical concerns, it designates one of the highest forms of “self-reference” through which events and actions come under consideration and deliberation.Footnote 85 This has the more local effect of integrating oneself within one’s community since it allows one to be placed under the aegis of the authority of the community’s ethical order. Ricoeur writes:
To be capable of entering into a[n] . . . order is to be capable of entering into an order of recognition, of inscribing oneself in a “we” that distributes and apportions the authority of the . . . order.Footnote 86
And elsewhere:
Practices . . . are cooperative activities whose constitutive rules are established socially; the standards of excellence that correspond to them on the level of this or that practice originate much further back than the solitary practitioner.Footnote 87
And because ethical actions, by their very nature, affect others, there is a demand placed on self-imputation to recognize the ethical standing of others beyond one’s community.Footnote 88
More globally, then, the self-reflexive nature of imputation allows one to extend one’s ethical gaze towards difference. But this, of course, is not guaranteed. Ricoeur therefore emphasizes the deliberative aspect of ethical decision-making (phronesis). He adds that imputation allows an individual’s sense of care for the other to be articulated as the internalized voice of practical deliberation which draws upon the resources of an ethical order when attempting to choose well in view of others. “[T]he search for the choice appropriate to the situation,” he comments, “is to recognize oneself as being enjoined to live well with and for others.”Footnote 89 It is in deliberation that the voice of authority ascribed to one’s ethical order is internalized in terms of one’s own thought. The given authority is scrutinized through one’s deliberation in a given situation of conflict. Indeed, to the voice of authority, the internalized voice of deliberation can present the exception to the rule.
Given the important role of imputation, the normative significance of impartiality can be expressed in more detail: in situations calling for impartiality, one’s self-imputation as the deliberator who should be impartial involves the recognition that the others concerned are esteemed by oneself as being worthy of impartial judgement. Impartiality must be won through deliberation, or what Ricoeur describes as the “heroic” and “moral effort” to accommodate the other “against the backdrop of a shared understanding.”Footnote 90
With this recovery of impartiality through the normative framework, Ricoeur subsequently redescribes the kind of distance that impartial judgement is supposed to provide. While conventionally we tend to view this distance in terms of neutrality or objectivity, Ricoeur frames it in terms of a ‘just distance’ that allows for communication. Or if we wish to play with the meaning of the word ‘distance,’ one can say that the estimation of worthiness of the other involved in impartiality allows the initial distance in communication to become a ‘just distance’ where convictions can be expressed. Because the other is worthy of impartial judgement, his or her case can be heard.
Ricoeur’s account clearly moves beyond the aim of shared reasons since it asks conflicting parties to enter and understand a rival tradition with which they are engaged. It may be true that many instances of debate in the realm of distributive justice may not require this depth of engagement, but it is also true that some of the most problematic conflicts involve discussion in which both parties assume a sameness, identity, or simple commensurability between the languages through which each party articulates his or her view. Ricoeur, in this respect, uses tragic situations as the barometer for his theory, insisting that tragic situations of conflict require this deep level of engagement and that therefore a theory of justice should look towards its most volatile and problematic instances in offering a possible process of fair resolution.Footnote 91
To be sure, a thorough account of what Ricoeur sees entailed in shared understanding would require an analysis of his account of mutual recognition and perhaps his discussion of memory and forgiveness.Footnote 92 But with respect to the aim of this article, it is sufficient to refer to two examples that demonstrate how a shared understanding requires a thorough immersion in that person’s order and system of thinking.
First example: Though not an instance of a direct conflict between ethical orders and individuals (but an indirect one at the level of economic goods), the philosopher and economist Philip Mirowski has pointed out, with respect to economic theory, that the metaphors it uses to explain and represent its subject of analysis determine the way in which its various research programs will envisage and represent disciplinary limitations and aims—most notably for Mirowski are the metaphors used to explain physical conservation principles (e.g., substance and field theories).Footnote 93 Gaining perspective on this phenomenon requires entering into systematic concepts and structures in order to understand what may have constituted something like a break or shift in theoretical assumptions—e.g., why something like equilibrium can be deemed a good when it is a practical fiction. Such questions arise because some metaphors and concepts no longer work when attempting to explain economic phenomena. Understanding why this is so involves, on Mirowski’s account, not just offering an alternative theory or assessing reasons but seeing how the problem arose through a historical development of thought. So one is asked to immerse oneself in an unfamiliar historical situation (or what is essentially the ‘other’) in which such metaphors and concepts were posited.Footnote 94 This approach can be said to result in a shared understanding because the inquirer has entered into a specific theoretical system in order to view its commitments and reasoning ‘as if’ in the first person. It does not entertain a simple notion of historical progress but one in which understanding the present and future requires engaging with the past, and indeed becoming aware of how a present view may be dominated by different metaphors.
Second example: MacIntyre has provided a formulation of the ways in which traditions can break out beyond parochial confines through a nuanced process of debate. It involves more than a simple consideration of compelling reasons offered from other rival traditions because each tradition must find a way to accommodate challenges by internally revising its current structures, practices, and concepts.Footnote 95 Like Ricoeur, MacIntyre sees the translation and interpretation of traditional historical texts as central to the project of a tradition’s revivification and ability to address changing historical circumstances. One of MacIntyre’s more convincing instances with reference to moral traditions in philosophy concerns the comparison of the various attempts to translate the episode of Achilles’ rage in The Iliad (I.189–192) where Achilles is conflicted when having to choose whether to strike down Agamemnon. MacIntyre points out that various translators use their own moral precepts to make sense of the conflict—i.e., between “rival thoughts” (George Chapman, 1598), “reason and passion” (Alexander Pope, 1715), and “alternating impulses of passion” (Robert Fitzgerald, 1974).Footnote 96 For MacIntyre, this heterogeneity of translations produces a productive rivalry between moral traditions that ideally enables one to reinterpret ethical precepts by virtue of confronting outside challenges. This is not to forget, as mentioned earlier, that the adherents to a tradition must be willing to do so.
In both the works of Mirowski and MacIntyre, one finds a deliberate and laborious engagement with the historical development of concepts and theories in order to offer a way of revising current methods of inquiry. They see this not as superfluous to an understanding of their respective fields but necessary.Footnote 97 In this respect, their historical concerns are not really a foray into historical details and contexts as much as they are a way of understanding how our current predicaments and impasses have emerged. These two examples, I am saying, help us to better envisage what may be required of shared understanding when engaging in public debate, especially since convictions, as shown earlier, are historically constituted.
V. Conclusion
The starting point of this article was the question concerning whether shared reasons are enough when conceiving the aim of impartiality. Sen’s practical, comparative approach avers that such reasons can be discovered through a process of public, reasoned debate and the inclusion of an external impartial observer. My challenge to this thesis was staked on Ricoeur’s analysis of convictions and how they run deeper than their correlative reasons or justifications may indicate. Simply countering one reason with another, more sufficient one in the process of debate does not address the ways in which convictions operate historically and culturally. A consensus of reasons, or shared reasons, is therefore not enough for a theory of distributive justice which aims to provide resolutions for conflicts. Instead, a more hospitable route that engages with another’s ethical order or tradition is required so that a competing party or external observer can understand the complexities by which specific beliefs are seen as authoritative. Ricoeur refers to this as a shared understanding, shared because one has attempted to occupy a first-person position within the unfamiliar tradition. The implication of this is that a strategy for practical resolution is more complex and laborious than we might otherwise hope. But a truncated, pragmatic alternative seems much more dangerous insofar as we might create an illusion by which we think that we can represent another’s convictions and ethical order by a meta- or neutral language.
Acknowledgements:
This article was originally presented as a paper at the “Reading Ricoeur Once Again” conference in Lisbon, Portugal (July 2010). I would like to thank Tom Angier, Eileen Brennan, Alexandre Christoyannopoulos, David Corfield, Fanny Forest, Valentin Gerlier, Simon Kirchin, Rajesh Sampath, Kenneth R. Westphal, the blind reviewers, and the editors at Dialogue for their comments and suggestions.
