Rob Conkie offers a bold, theoretically inflected, and formally creative new perspective on how to write about theatrical production. The first word of his title is key. Conkie is writing (enacting) performative criticism, not reading (interpreting) past productions. He acknowledges that theatrical analysis inevitably distorts the (absent) live event, and his response is to keep that process of remediation before our eyes by playing with the codex form in such a way as to “confront habituated reading practices” (23). He writes himself as artist and spectator, practitioner (director, actor, rehearsal observer) and critic.
In Chapter 1, Conkie shuttles between student rehearsals of Pericles and Romeo and Juliet, attending to the archival materials generated by theatrical labor. Props feature prominently, with the live performance in front of a paying audience coming to seem just one more point on a creative timeline. Conkie represents these materials and labor with a pinboard (i.e., bulletin board) on which are displayed fragments of text and images, which he subjects to “active reading” (30). His goal here is to prompt the reader to trace among these archival materials and rehearsal processes her own web of associations; we all, as it were, stand in front of the pinboard and become active readers of it.
This visual playfulness (reproduced details of the pinboard occupy the top half of many pages) is pushed further in the second chapter, “Sudoku Shakespeare.” Following a preliminary introduction—which Conkie encourages us not to read—each of the nine main pages in this chapter is divided into nine squares numbered 1–9 and arranged in the manner of a sudoku puzzle. Each square is filled with image(s) or text, and each page is organized in relation to a topic such as sexuality, animals, history, or stupidity. These nine pages relate to a ninety-minute semiprofessional adaptation called Othellophobia that Conkie directed in 2003 and remounted in an altered form in 2004. The box numbers denote particular aspects of Othellophobia, such as text, rehearsal processes, and critical reception.
I intuited from a first (unintroduced) experience of the puzzle that the nine boxes on each page probably share a common topic; by reading the numbered boxes across the nine pages, I likewise gathered that the numbers function to organize certain sustained perspectives on Othello. None of these categories is self-evident, however. To get to grips with the pages and boxes, one either has to commit to working on them as a puzzle, or else cheat and read the introduction (which is what I did the second time through). As with the first chapter, but by very different means, what emerges from “Sudoku Shakespeare” is less performance criticism than “making” performance criticism—this chapter offers partial reflections that explicitly reach out for readerly input on the process of making performance.
Failure is a recurrent theme of the book. By conceptualizing theatre as process rather than product, and opening his own theatrical practice and spectatorship to multiple perspectives and voices, Conkie hails his reader to participate in the (impossible) task of reconstituting live performance through the activity of reading. In Chapter 3, Conkie narrates the sensory experiences provided by physically taking up six different viewing positions on the Globe's 2008 staging of King Lear. Multiple viewing perspectives on Roman Tragedies (dir. Ivo van Hove) are suggested in Chapter 4 through graphic illustration with the help of comic book artist Bernard Caleo, Conkie further letting us “listen in” on an imagined roundtable of theatre critics talking about where they sat to watch this groundbreaking production.
Polyvocality is likewise the emphasis of Chapter 5, with its analysis of an “‘originalish practices’” performance of 1 Henry IV (113) in which Conkie, with a failing voice, performed Hotspur. Here we get the voices of eleven interlocutors who performed in or saw the show at the same matinee. These voices crowd the margins—in places they encroach on Conkie's prose, and sometimes they take over the page entirely. The sixth and final chapter unpacks a staging's pre-preshow labor, Conkie documenting and reflecting on a process of collaboration that might one day lead to an Indigenous staging of Hamlet.
Writing Performative Shakespeares does something very new in terms of producing what Della Pollock (one of Conkie's major influences) theorizes as “nervous” performative writing. Conkie's methodology is set out most clearly in his introduction, where he enthusiastically embraces and details the “inspir[ing]” contributions to Shakespeare performance studies made by certain feminist “heroines” (2). He goes on to critique their writing as flawed, however, because none of them seems particularly “nervous.” Conkie needlessly, and I would suggest misleadingly, constructs recent efforts to write a “‘provisional, contingent, never definitive’” (3) performance criticism (the adjectives are Carol Rutter's) as a peculiarly female discourse, which he then exposes as unduly authoritative in order to reinvent the genre. Male feminist performance scholars such as Anthony Dawson, Stephen Purcell, Robert Shaughnessy, and W. B. Worthen—critics with strong methodological points of contact with the likes of Rutter, Pascale Aebischer, and Bridget Escolme—are literally marginalized, relegated to the footnotes. For some reason, for Conkie, the gender divide matters. As a rhetorical strategy, it is deeply puzzling.
Conkie offers genuinely experimental writing and presses us to ask what we want of performance criticism. I will set this book in the fall as required reading for an introductory theatre studies course. Not having seen any of the shows under discussion, however, I lack the experiential knowledge to “active read” these fragments into anything like an independent argument; I come away without even a strong sense of the productions as theatre history. Conkie's performance, rhetorically nervous though it is, thus (perhaps inevitably) retains the authority of the critic's eye. He sifts the material his reader will see, and he mediates the voice(s) she will hear. The activity of reading Writing Performative Shakespeares—challenging in places and stimulating throughout—provokes an awareness of, and interest in, a fictional character called “Rob Conkie,” who writes (about) these stagings. This book leaves me reflecting deeply on the “performance” that happens in performance criticism. It will sharpen my readings, and perhaps also writings, of live theatre.
