A more informative title for Patricia Fara's bold, wide-ranging and well-illustrated book would have been ‘Science in Context: A Four Thousand Year History.’ She gives an account of the development of scientific knowledge not for its content, but rather for its fit with the times. She bases her book on wide reading of English-language secondary sources.
The clever organization is two-tiered. The first level consists of seven main parts corresponding roughly to large historical periods. Thus I, ‘Origins’, deals with antiquity; II, ‘Interactions’, with China, Islam and the Middle Ages; III, ‘Experiments’, with the Renaissance and sixteenth and seventeenth centuries; IV, ‘Institutions’, with the eighteenth century; V, ‘Laws’, with the nineteenth century; VI, ‘Invisibles’, with the early twentieth century; and VII, ‘Decisions’, with big science following the Second World War.
Each of the seven parts is divided into seven sections, within some of which are encapsulated thumbnail summaries of the science done in accordance with the theme of that section. Thus the seven sections of Part VI, ‘Invisibles’, are labelled ‘Life’, ‘Germs’, ‘Rays’, ‘Particles’, ‘Genes’, ‘Chemicals’ and ‘Uncertainties’. The mystic appeal of the number seven is the first theme of I, 1, ‘Origins’.
As an example, let us take VI, 4, ‘Particles’. It opens with Mendeleev and the periodic table of elements arranged in accordance with their chemical properties. Nothing was then known of the internal structure of the atom. It later turned out that the descending order of the columns is determined by the number of protons in the nucleus and the rows by the number of free electrons in each atom. Bohr then modelled the structure of the atom as a miniature planetary system. Discovery of the neutron, the positron, the neutrino and so on followed. Finally Murray Gell-Man, even like Mendeleev at the level of elements, developed a model arranging these particles in a pattern, leaving a gap while predicting that another particle would be found to fill it. Sure enough – and Gell-Man looked inward to imagine a family of still smaller particles, internal components of protons and neutrons, which he called quarks. In order to explain the nature of mass all this culminates in the prediction of bosons, which have yet to be detected.
The topical sections are uneven in quality. IV, 7, ‘Disciplines’, for example, conflates the professionalization of science in the nineteenth century with the formation of disciplines. Nothing is said, however, of the development of the discipline of rational mechanics in the eighteenth century. The names of Varignon, the Bernoullis, Euler, d'Alembert, Lagrange, and Legendre nowhere appear. Nothing is said of the formation of mathematical physics except that there was a dispute between followers and opponents of Laplace about the nature of light. The names of Ampère, Arago, Biot, Cauchy, Fourier and Poisson are nowhere. Nothing is said of the formation of a rigorous biology through the junction of comparative anatomy and experimental physiology in the early nineteenth century. Nothing is said of the roles of Cuvier and Lamarck in the former nor of Bichat and Magendie in the latter. Mesmer is taken to have been a respectable physician victimized by a scientific and medical establishment bent on protecting its dominant status and prosperity. I think that is false. In any case Mesmer is irrelevant. He flourished in Paris in the late 1770s and 1780s, well before the professionalization of science.
Other sections are unduly Anglocentric. British scientists and institutions are the only ones mentioned in IV, 3, ‘Careers’. Investigation of electricity is treated as a function of the careers of Franklin and Faraday. A conventional summary of the Industrial Revolution in Britain is the sole subject of IV, 4, ‘Industries’. Although secondary, France was far from an industrial backwater in the same period. For worldwide history of science, moreover, the importance of German industry in the nineteenth century and American industry in the twentieth is scarcely to be ignored. Section V, 1, ‘Progress’, concerns the popularization of science in Victorian Britain and nowhere else.
Some readers – and the undersigned is one of them – may find certain features of the tone of the book to be jarring. It is often iconoclastic and occasionally dogmatic and polemical. Although Fara allows the likes of Kepler, Galileo and Newton to be brilliant, she systematically deflates the credit to be attached to leading scientists throughout history. Here, for example, is her account of Galileo. He was an ‘astute campaigner’. He made ‘flamboyant speeches at dinner parties and wrote persuasive polemical books’. He drew ‘large audiences with his pithy propaganda pieces, leaving out the formulae and boasting with a conjurer's panache of unfolding great and very wonderful sights’ (p. 116). Fara says nothing of Two New Sciences (1638), the work that underlies modern physics.
Fara makes as much of Newton's alchemy and his roots in the past as she does of the theory of gravity, the laws of motion and the Opticks, with its prescient queries. She imputes commercialization and politicization to science well before the era of big science after 1945. Popularization of the Principia at the hands of Desaguliers and others is ‘marketing’ (p. 141). Fara likens Lavoisier's confidential (she says secretive) preparation of the reform of chemistry to the tactical planning of a political agitator preparing a revolution (p. 177). In many, if not most, instances she writes less sympathetically of leading figures such as Lavoisier and Newton than of their rivals or critics such as Priestley and Goethe. In some sections introductory remarks have the effect of deploring the developments to be described. For example, VI, 5, ‘Chemicals’ opens with a paragraph castigating nineteenth-century science for legitimating belief in the superiority of men over women and Europeans over Africans. The ensuing discussion of chemicals is limited to their use in medications.
Fara criticizes previous historians of science, though without naming them, for naïveté in taking science to be a disinterested march toward truth insulated from mundane concerns. Her account of Chinese contributions, for example, is couched as a defence of Joseph Needham against ‘traditional historians’ outraged by his suggestion that prior Chinese knowledge, techniques and practices contributed to the Western scientific enterprise of reaching universal knowledge.
Readers of this review may like to be reminded of a recent book that also consists of a history of scientific context, and expressly so: Servants of Nature: A History of Scientific Institutions, Enterprises, and Sensibilities (New York and London, 1999) by Lewis and Susan Sheets Pyenson. The Pyensons employ a similar organization. Their account is divided topically into three categories, ‘Institutions’, ‘Enterprises’ and ‘Sensibilities’, with appropriate subdivisions, some sixteen in all. They treat each one throughout all appropriate times and places but insert no encapsulation of bits of science. The Pyensons include ancient India as well as China and Islam, of which their account is fuller than Fara's. They also tell of the reciprocal export of modern science from West to East. Nowhere is their account judgemental, whether with respect to science, to its practitioners or to its historians. They begin, indeed, with a respectful history of the historiography of science. In these respects their mode of writing history makes a contrast with Fara's more personal approach.
Still, whatever one's reservations – and mine are many – her readable, breezily written and opinionated book may well have the effect she hopes for, which is to attract a larger public of readers to the history of science, and that would be all to the good.
