State and local governments in the United States have attempted to control and shape the influx and impacts of immigrants throughout the country's history. Still, the US national government has claimed nearly exclusive control over “gatekeeping” issues of immigration policy since the early twentieth century, and state and local governments have been largely responsible for policies dealing with immigrant integration. Perceiving themselves under unusual pressure and strain from the inflow of new migrants in the last several decades, and frustrated by the failure of the US Congress to adopt a comprehensive immigration reform law in 2006–7, a number of cities and states have adopted policies aimed at reclaiming a local role for controlling the inflow of immigrants, and particularly unauthorized immigrants.
Produced under the auspices and sponsorship of the Center for Comparative Immigration Studies at the University of California, San Diego, the edited volume under review brings together a high-quality and multidisciplinary selection of discrete studies presented at a May 2008 conference at the Center. The papers have been rewritten and edited for this volume. Though not organized in this way, the papers address a number of important issues generated by these state and local government activities.
The first issue addressed by the volume is how best to explain the increased efforts by state and (mainly) local governments to affect the influx and/or status of (especially undocumented) immigrants in their jurisdictions. Two main theories are presented by multiple authors: 1) Immigrant-driven demographic change has generated social and/or cultural changes in many localities that seem threatening to many people, and these perceived threats have resulted in legislation aimed at controlling or expelling the new residents. The major problem with this theory, as noted by several authors in the volume, is that some of the localities legislating on this issue are not among the communities most affected directly by contemporary immigration, and only some (not all) localities experiencing this demographic change have adopted restrictive legislation. Thus, 2) the analysis by S. Karthick Ramakrishnan and Tom Wong (Chapter 4) finds that Republican Party dominance, and not social or cultural change, is the most powerful variable for explaining municipal government legislation that aims to reduce the influx of migrants.
A second issue addressed (in the introductory essay by the editor and in another multiauthored essay, Chapter 2) is the jurisdictional question of the limits on state and local authority to attempt to influence the settlement of immigrants in their territorial spaces, a subject that remains unsettled in the courts in a variety of ways.
The third question in focus here concerns just how state and local governments have attempted to influence the influx of (especially undocumented) immigrants into their jurisdictions. This question receives the greatest attention in the book. With the exception of one chapter on inclusionary policies (Chapter 3), most of the analyses focus on efforts to control, restrict, and/or repel the migrants from the localities under study. Generally, these have involved one or more of the following: 1) helping to enforce the national government's immigration policy, either by direct referral of undocumented immigrants to US Department of Homeland Security's Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents or through so-called 287(g) agreements; 2) policing to restrict the employment of undocumented immigrants through various forms of work-site regulation (e.g., requiring employers to use ICE's e-Verify system to check employment-related documents, regulation and/or restrictions on immigrant day-labor sites, criminalizing the employment of undocumented workers, etc.); and 3) providing incentives to undocumented migrants to “self-deport” by, for example, making it very difficult for them to rent housing, to obtain a driver's license, as well as to secure and keep gainful employment.
A fourth question concerns the effects that these state and local government efforts have on the country's overall policy approach to immigration, on the localities under study, and on significantly impacted subgroups of the population (including the immigrants in question). Most of the authors seeking to address this question (primarily through case studies of particular states or localities) indicate that it is too early to answer it with any degree of confidence, and this reviewer certainly agrees. Moreover, the approaches to understanding the effects of these policies vary widely among the authors who address this question at all, especially as the authors come from several social science disciplines.
These are all-important questions, and there is a wealth of valuable information in this volume regarding how to answer them. As is typically the case in edited volumes of collected papers, apart from the general focus of the book indicated in the first paragraph of this review, there is no central theme or overarching analytical framework that has guided these inquiries. And as the authors come from different disciplines, it is a shortcoming that the editor and/or publisher have not seen fit to provide any information about the contributors' home disciplines or institutional affiliations. This limits the book's utility as a teaching tool, since it makes it more difficult for instructors to guide students through a critical comparison of multiple methods of inquiry.
The most important element missing from the book, however, is a systematic and sustained inquiry into the role of racial animosity and bias in these state and local government efforts to control and limit the influx of immigrants. While immigration restrictionists are nearly always vehement in their denial of racial bias in relation to immigration policy, there are plenty of good reasons for subjecting this claim to systematic and critical inquiry. Although some chapters in the book take note of the historical role of racism in several localities being studied here, and of claims of racial bias in contemporary immigration politics, the absence of a sustained inquiry into the question is a major lack in the book as a whole.
Still, as noted, Taking Local Control contains a wealth of good information, including multiple analyses of the subject of state and local government efforts to limit and control the influx of (especially undocumented) immigrants into their communities. These efforts will no doubt be a factor in U.S. politics for some time to come, and for those taking note of these political efforts, this collection is an excellent way to gain some initial understanding of what is going on in the field. Therefore, this reviewer highly recommends the book for those interested in gaining a basic understanding of this phenomenon, and it would also be a good text to use in upper-division courses on state and local government and/or immigration politics.
