Suzanne Gauch offers a cogent and comprehensive overview of cinema of the Maghrib (Algeria, Morocco, and Tunisia) produced primarily in the 21st century. While concentrating her analyses on contemporary cinema, she maintains that Gillo Pontecorvo's iconic, neorealist film La Battaille d'Alger (The Battle of Algiers, 1966), continues to “exert a hold on popular imaginations worldwide” and, thus, thematically has reduced films from the region to certain stereotypical assumptions “limited by post-independence classifications” (pp. 2–3). Pontecorvo's film has also “continued to be fetishized as a national narrative in Algeria and far beyond” (p. 3). Additionally, Gauch argues that considering films from the region only in terms of social realism and/or ethnography does a disservice to the “transformations in knowledge and understanding” that have occurred in the region since decolonization (p. 3).
Gauch's work analyzes “nine films and film cycles” which she explains were chosen for their “experiment with conventions of perception and established relations on a range of formal as well as thematic levels, and because they are broadly accessible” (p. 3). The accessibility caveat is one that many film scholars have confronted when trying to work on films produced in Africa. The availability of films and their distribution dictate to what extent scholarship on them can be achieved. For the most part, films discussed in her book have been distributed internationally with subtitles in English and/or French. Her nine cycles are also “nine movements in motion” that structure three larger thematic foci: Part 1, “Sight Lines”; Part 2, “Hero Complex”; and Part 3, “Scan Backward/Scan Forward.” Through these principal parts, Gauch argues that the films explored “ignore the boundaries imposed by various national and international film histories” (p. 9). They also are not politically defined in the sense of former third cinema films which were ensconced in their dedication to breaking with commercial arenas in order to appeal to art houses in the west. Where third cinema called for the complete decolonization of the subjects depicted in them, as well as original auteur forms to be created, these more recent filmmakers’ films are primarily concerned with seeking to “dynamize popular interest rather than cultivate personal style.” They also produce works that “probe the political boundaries erected in and through film” without succumbing to social-realist and documentary styles evidenced in films prior to the late 1990s (p. 9).
In the first part of the book, “Sight Lines,” Gauch examines films that privilege mobility in the postindependence era. She explains that films such as Moroccan Farida Benlyazid's Door to the Sky (1988) and Algerian Mohamed Chouikh's The Citadel (1989), Youssef (1994), and The Ark of the Desert (1997), and Tunisian Nacer Khemir's The Wanderers of the Desert (1986) and The Lost Ring of the Dove (1992), for the most part, are unique in that they address how the Maghrib, almost thirty years after independence, seeks to reinvent itself in order to “open up new fields” of sociopolitical introspection (p. 10). These filmmakers’ films take to task both regional and national sight/site plans in order to “reconceptualize the look, function, and future,” not only politically, but also cinematically, of the nation. These cinematic oeuvres also emerge from a systematic conundrum that confronts filmmakers working in the region: How should they pay allegiance to nations whose national film industries have supported their work, while they also challenge certain nationalist self-representations that, fabricated by governing authorities in the postindependence era, have negatively impacted society?
Part 2, “Hero Complex,” “rescript[s] globally popular genre films from within regional particularities” (p. 10). Gauch explains that films such as Moroccan Nabil Ayouch's Mektoub (1997), Algerian Lyès Salem's Masquerades (2008), and Tunisian Nadia El Fani's Bedwin Hacker (2003), while thematically pleasing to global audiences because they tend to be more universal in scope, also “reject imitative relationships to European, American, Asian, and Middle Eastern cinematic models,” primarily because they “challenge audience expectations” (p. 10). All three filmmakers offer films that are multidirectional and contest “relationships of post-independence cinema to the nation-state” (p. 11).
Part 3, “Scan Backward/Scan Forward,” examines films by Tariq Teguia (Algeria), Faouzi Bensaïdi (Morocco), and Nejib Belkadhi (Tunisia) for their “radical transformations of perception” which Gauch maintains are inspiring a new generation of filmmakers in the 21st century. They “address the shifting terrain” of Maghribian cinema in the wake of geopolitical shifts, such as the Arab Spring and massive immigration due to conflicts in the region (p.11). These films “remain open-ended” with respect to making final conclusions on what globalization and transnationalism will mean for the Maghrib (p. 132). Tariq Teguia's Rome Rather than You (2006), for example, happens, in media res, to trace “the frustrated and frustrating perambulations of young characters seeking to escape the drudgery and violence of a once revolutionary country” (p. 132).
This book is noteworthy for its comprehensive array of film analyses, thus making it a useful resource for students and scholars alike in film studies. While the author's goal is to study these films primarily for their cinematic qualities, extracting them from “boundaries imposed by various national and international film histories” (p. 9), at times the overarching comparisons seem to lessen the specificity of each film. For example, Gauch's analysis of Moroccan Ayouch's Mektoub, analyzed in Part 2 as a film that “pushes against official censorship as well as broader societal taboos” (something Ayouch is known for, as evidenced in his most recent film Much Loved [2015]), does not adequately address the sociopolitical climate in which the film was made. Although she does explain that the film references the famous Tabite Affair, involving the despotic police inspector Tabite who in the 1980s committed a series of rapes that he filmed on video (he was eventually prosecuted), we are not privileged to other sociohistorical information that allows for a better understanding of the film's backstory in Morocco. Tabite's crimes have served as platforms for several Moroccan filmmakers to scrutinize the many years of dirty politics, torture, and abuse of human rights in Morocco during the repressive Les années de plomb (The Lead Years) under King Hassan II, who ruled from 1963 to 1999. What Gauch does not reveal in her summary, though, is that Ayouch was able to make his film (one of the first to criticize the Hassan II regime in the late 1990s) and avoid censure because of the transforming political scene at the time. Ayouch took advantage of King Hassan II's slipping hold on the country and the push for more transparent legislation known as L'Alternance (literally, The Altering) to enact political reforms. These reforms came about primarily due to demands made by the international community mandating that Hassan II admit to massive human rights abuses and the International Monetary Fund's mandate that Morocco structurally adjust its economy. L'Alternance ultimately led to later, more positive reforms carried out by King Mohamed VI in the 2000s. This period, although accomplishing little with respect to changing the monarchy's status quo, did allow for increased political space at the grassroots level of society. Moroccans found themselves living in a somewhat more transparent and democratic system that has continued to develop in the new millennium. Ayouch's film is firmly couched in this political era of transition.
With respect to Algeria, films from the early 2000s, such as Lyès Salem's Masquerades, were monumental as some of the first cultural productions to be produced after almost two decades of civil war. Many of the thematic choices made by Salem came from a need to rebuild the decimated Algerian film industry. Equally important for Salem and other filmmakers was the revival of cultural production in Algeria after the ravages of the civil war between the Front de liberation government and the Front Islamique du Salut, enduring from the early 1990s to 2005 (when an armistice was finally signed).
While Gauch's desire to remove films from the weight of sociopolitical frameworks in order to study the originality of their artistry is applauded, it is important also to contextualize their messages through the contemporary histories of the countries from which they emerge. In short, these films, no matter their artistic qualities, are always responding to the sociocultural and the political climates in which they are produced. In her desire to compare these films, Gauch at times reduces the very different cinemas of each nation to overarching common denominators. Such comparisons can be limiting, since they lessen the importance of each film's contribution to their nation's evolving contemporary histories.
Despite this minor criticism, Gauch's volume is remarkable for its depth and scope, including analyses of a plethora of films that make this work one of the most useful among recently published cinematic studies on the region. She is certainly right when she insists that Maghribian filmmaking offers a window onto a region that is not often on the radar of the United States or other parts of the Anglophone world. Although newer films are more transnational in scope and theme, because of former colonial ties to France, their distribution internationally has tended to be coopted by the former colonizer and European francophone distribution outlets and festivals. Gauch's work will help define why these films deserve international recognition beyond the limits of their colonial and postcolonial historical ties to France. As she states in her conclusion, Maghribian cinema is in continuous transformation, documenting the day-to-day unfolding narratives of countries in flux. Although social media have overshadowed cinematic industries all over the world, Gauch rightly points out that “film . . . is not dead” and will continue to contribute to the ever-changing face of the Maghrib (p. 191).
