Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T04:10:55.368Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Drag reduction and subcritical turbulence in controlled pipe flows

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 September 2026

Emanuele Gallorini*
Affiliation:
Dipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Aerospaziali, Politecnico di Milano, via La Masa 34, Milano 20156, ItalyUniv. Lille, CNRS, ONERA, Arts et Metiers Institute of Technology, Centrale Lille, UMR 9014 – LMFL – Laboratoire de Mécanique des Fluides de Lille – Kampé de Fériet, Lille 59000, France
Daniele Massaro
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 77 Massachusetts Avenue, Cambridge, 02139 MA, USA
Philipp Schlatter
Affiliation:
Institute of Fluid Mechanics (LSTM), Friedrich–Alexander–Universität (FAU) Erlangen–Nürnberg, Erlangen 91058, Germany
Maurizio Quadrio
Affiliation:
Dipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Aerospaziali, Politecnico di Milano, via La Masa 34, Milano 20156, Italy
*
Corresponding author: Emanuele Gallorini, emanuele.gallorini@polimi.it

Abstract

Content of image described in text.

Pipe flow controlled by streamwise-travelling waves of azimuthal wall velocity is studied using direct numerical simulations at a bulk Reynolds number $\textit{Re}_b=4900$. A comprehensive analysis of drag reduction shows that the flow response differs fundamentally from that of channel flow. Under suitable forcing, pipe flow relaminarises, whereas channel flow does not. Depending on the control parameters, the flow exhibits the spatially localised turbulent state characteristic of transitional pipe flow, with turbulent puffs persisting at bulk Reynolds numbers up to three times higher than in the uncontrolled case. The bulk Reynolds number alone does not determine the onset of localisation. Moreover, drag reduction, which alters the natural relation between bulk and friction velocities, is insufficient to identify a universal onset criterion. An intermittency indicator based on the spatial variance of the cross-sectional turbulent kinetic energy relates the emergence of localised turbulence to the low wall friction produced by the control, although the correspondence is not one-to-one. Despite their qualitative resemblance to canonical turbulent puffs, the controlled puffs exhibit distinct properties; for example, their fronts may propagate faster than the bulk flow. Overall, this work provides a comprehensive characterisation of the subcritical turbulent state and its turbulent puffs in controlled pipe flow, and offers a new perspective on control strategies that aim at flow relaminarisation.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Maps of the percentage drag-reduction rate R$\mathcal{R}$ in the ω−kx$\omega -k_x$ plane for A+=14.5$A^+ = 14.5$. Present results (a) are compared with plane channel flow data (b), extrapolated from Reτ=200$\textit{Re}_\tau =200$ to Reτ=170$\textit{Re}_\tau =170$. Contours are spaced by 10%$10\,\%$ intervals; the thick line indicates the zero contour level. Panel (c) shows the difference ΔR$\Delta \mathcal{R}$ between pipe and channel. In panel (a) the dots show where simulations have been carried out.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Maps of the net power saving S$\mathcal{S}$ in the ω−kx$\omega -k_x$ plane for A+=14.5$A^+ = 14.5$. Present results (a) are compared with plane channel flow data (b), extrapolated from Reτ=200$\textit{Re}_\tau =200$ to Reτ=170$\textit{Re}_\tau =170$. Contours are spaced by unit intervals; the thick line indicates the zero level. Panel (c) shows the difference ΔS$\Delta \mathcal{S}$ between pipe and channel.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Local wall friction ⟨R+⟩θ$\langle R^+\rangle _\theta$ for different control parameters resulting in a full laminarisation of the flow. The dotted line indicates the friction level for the unforced laminar flow.

Figure 3

Table 1.Characteristics of the turbulent puffs for cases with localised turbulence: the set control parameters kx+$k_x^+$ and ω+$\omega ^+$, and the resulting drag-reduction rate R$\mathcal{R}$, number of puffs n$n$ in the domain, length of the puffs L/D$L/D$, cross-plane turbulent kinetic energy ⟨q⟩p$\langle {q} \rangle _{\!p} $ and Kármán number ⟨R+⟩p$ \langle {R^+} \rangle _{\!p} $ averaged within the puff volume, velocities of the upstream and downstream fronts Uu$U_u$ and Ud$U_d$.Table 1 long description.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Instantaneous visualisation of localised turbulence along the pipe. The control parameters k+=0.0126$k^+=0.0126$ and ω+=0.08$\omega ^+=0.08$ (case I of table 1) correspond to a large drag reduction of R=31%$\mathcal{R}=31\,\%$. (a) instantaneous configuration of the control (represented by the background colour, which indicates the azimuthal velocity of the wall) along with turbulence structures, visualised as isosurfaces of λ2+=−0.06$\lambda _2^+=-0.06$. (b) evolution of q$q$ along the axial direction.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Map of the intermittency indicator I$\mathcal{I}$ in the ω−kx$\omega -k_x$ plane for A+=14.5$A^+ = 14.5$. Contours of R$\mathcal{R}$, spaced by 10%$10\,\%$ intervals, are overlaid to visualise the relation between I$\mathcal{I}$ and drag reduction. The colour scale is saturated above I=0.005$\mathcal{I}=0.005$. The coloured dots indicate where localised turbulence is observed, with the number n$n$ of turbulent regions encoded by colour: n=1$n=1$ blue, n=2$n=2$ green and n=3$n=3$ red.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Space–time evolution of q(x,t)$q(x,t)$ for (a) REF, (b) P1, (c) P2 (d) and P3. Data are represented in the convecting reference frame at a speed U$\mathcal{U}$: U=Ub$\mathcal{U}=U_b$ for REF and P2, U=1.12Ub$\mathcal{U}=1.12U_b$ for P1 and U=1.4Ub$\mathcal{U}=1.4U_b$ for P3.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Streamwise distribution of (a) q(x)$q(x)$ and of (b) the azimuthally averaged wall friction for an instantaneous flow field far from the initial transient, for cases REF, P1, P2 and P3. The dotted line on panel (b) is R+$R^+$ for the laminar flow at Reb=4900$\textit{Re}_b=4900$.

Figure 8

Figure 8.(a) Cumulative distribution function (CDF) of the puff length for cases listed in table 1. Continuous lines are the exponential distribution given by (4.3). The inset shows the positions of the different cases within the control parameter space, using the same symbols as in figure 4. (b,c) Space–time evolution of q(x,t)$q(x,t)$ for cases B (b) and I (c). The contour q=qt$q=q_t$ marks the spatial extension of the events. Here U=Ub$\mathcal{U}=U_b$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Comparison between uncontrolled (case O; panels a,c) and controlled (case A; panels b,d) puffs. For a single flow field, panels (a,b) show plots of ⟨R+⟩θ$\langle {R^+} \rangle _\theta $ and q$q$ along the pipe at fixed time, and panels (c,d) show plots of the quantity ⟨|ωx|(u−Ub)⟩A$ \! \langle {|\omega _x|(u-U_b)} \rangle \!_A$.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Figure 10 long description.Relation between drag-reduction rate R$\mathcal{R}$ and various quantitative features of the puffs, taken from table 1. The panels plot: (a)$(a)$ number of puffs in the computational domain; (b)$(b)$ average Kármán number within the puffs; (c)$(c)$ cross-plane turbulent kinetic energy ⟨q⟩p$ \langle {q} \rangle _{\!p} $ within the puffs, with inner/outer scaling; (d)$(d)$ puff length; (e,f)$(e,f)$ upstream and downstream front speed. The horizontal solid line indicates the mean value and the two dashed lines visualise the range of ±$\pm$ the r.m.s. value.

Figure 11

Figure 11.(a–c) Local friction Reynolds number and (d–f) azimuthally averaged axial velocity profile for case A with n=1$n=1$ (a,d), case I with n=3$n=3$ (b,e) and the uncontrolled case at Reb=2200$\textit{Re}_{b}=2200$ (c,f). In panels (a–c) the horizontal dotted line indicates the laminar value. The profiles in panels (d–f) are extracted at axial positions marked by vertical dashed lines with matching colours in (a–c). The black solid lines represent the velocity profile for laminar Hagen–Poiseuille flow, while the dashed lines for cases A and I represent the mean velocity profile in the uncontrolled case.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Mean velocity profiles in the (a,c) outer and (b,d) actual inner scaling. (a,b) Global mean profile ⟨u⟩(r)$ \! \langle {u} \rangle (r)$. (c,d) Mean profile ⟨u⟩p(r)$\langle {u} \rangle _{\!p} (r)$ averaged only over the puffs. The dashed lines represent the mean velocity profile for the uncontrolled case at Reb=4900$\textit{Re}_b=4900$.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Figure 13 long description.Radial distribution of the puff-averaged turbulent kinetic energy ⟨k⟩p$\langle {k} \rangle _{\!p} $, scaled in (a) external and (b) actual viscous units. The dashed lines represent the turbulent kinetic energy profile for the uncontrolled case at Reb=4900$\textit{Re}_b=4900$.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Space–time evolution of q(x,t)$q(x,t)$ (for the case with kx+=0.0129$k_x^+=0.0129$ and ω+=0.086$\omega ^+=0.086$) for different Lx$L_x$: (a) 8.5D$8.5D$, 15D$15D$, 24.5D$24.5D$, 32D$32D$, (b) 39D$39D$, 47.5D$47.5D$ (b) and (c) 122.5D$122.5D$.

Figure 15

Table 2.Dependence of R$\mathcal{R}$, its uncertainty δR$\delta \mathcal{R}$ and characteristics of the turbulent regions (number n$n$, length L$L$, cross-plane turbulent kinetic energy ⟨q⟩p$ \! \langle {q} \rangle _{\!p} $, mean puff velocity Um$U_m$ and number of puffs per unit length nD/Lx$nD/L_x$) with the domain length for the localised turbulence case with control parameters kx+=0.0129$k_x^+=0.0129$ and ω+=0.086$\omega ^+=0.086$.Table 2 long description.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Space–time evolution of q(x,t)$q(x,t)$ (for the case with kx+=0.0129$k_x^+=0.0129$ and ω+=0.086$\omega ^+=0.086$) and Lx=16D$L_x= 16D$ with an initial condition originating from Lx=24.5D$L_x= 24.5D$ (a) and Lx=32D$L_x= 32D$ (b).

Figure 17

Table 3.Quantitative characteristics of the localised turbulent regions for various threshold values qt$q_t$ for the cross-plane turbulent kinetic energy. Left (columns 1–6): qt=7×10−3Ub2$q_t=7 \times 10^{-3}U_b^2$. Right (columns 7–12): qt=0.1qmax$q_t=0.1q_{max}$.Table 3 long description.

Figure 18

Table 4.Quantitative characteristics of the localised turbulent regions in case O for a threshold value of qt=2×10−3Ub2$q_t=2 \times 10^{-3}U_b^2$.Table 4 long description.