Anorexia nervosa has the highest rate of mortality of any psychiatric disorder with 5.1 deaths per 1000 person years.Reference Arcelus, Mitchell, Wales and Nielson 1 With up to 80% of patients with anorexia nervosa suffering from cardiovascular complications,Reference De Simeone, Scalfi and Galderisi 2 – Reference Goldberg, Comerci and Feldman 5 which in turn cause up to 30% of the mortality in anorexia nervosa,Reference Isner, Roberts, Heymsfield and Yager 6 , Reference Neumarker 7 a review of the current knowledge base of cardiac manifestations in anorexia nervosa is warranted and presented below.
Diagnostic criteria for anorexia nervosa include restriction of energy intake leading to significantly low body weight, failure to meet the expected weight gain or maintain normal developmental trajectory, in children and adolescents, intense fear of weight gain and disturbance in the experience of one’s body weight or shape with undue influence of body weight or shape on self-evaluation, and persistent lack of recognition of the seriousness of current low body weight. 8 An individual’s concern with his or her body or weight as well as changes in eating or exercise behaviours may precede meeting full diagnostic criteria by 6–12 months.Reference Pinhas, Morris, Crosby and Katzman 9 In addition, very young individuals may initially deny drive for thinness and fear of gaining weight,Reference Couturier, Lock, Forsberg, Vanderheyden and Yen 10 , 11 clouding the diagnostic picture.
Anorexia nervosa commonly begins during adolescence or young adulthood; retrospective data support a median age of onset of 18 yearsReference Hudson, Hiripi, Pope and Kessler 12 with a lifetime prevalence of 0.5–2%.Reference Sigel 13 The course of anorexia nervosa is highly variable. Many individuals will experience remission within 5 years, but about half will develop a chronic, relapsing course.Reference Kaye, Wierenga and Knatz 14
Structural and functional cardiac alterations
Changes in cardiac mass and chamber dimensions present early in anorexia nervosaReference Lesinskiene, Barkus, Ranceva and Dembinskas 15 and have been well studied. Consistently, decreases in left ventricular massReference Silvetti, Magnani and Santilli 16 – Reference Oflaz, Yucel and Oz 33 and left ventricular end-diastolic and left ventricular end-systolic dimensionsReference De Simone, Scalfi and Galderisi 20 , Reference Galetta, Franzoni and Prattichizzo 23 , Reference Gottdiener, Gross, Henry, Borer and Ebert 25 , Reference Kastner, Salbach-Andrae and Renneberg 29 – Reference Olivares, Vazquez and Fleta 35 are found; however, some controversy remains regarding some other very specific dimension measures, with some authors finding changes in left ventricular wall thicknessReference Silvetti, Magnani and Santilli 16 – Reference Oflaz, Yucel and Oz 33 or left ventricular posterior wall thicknessReference De Simone, Scalfi and Galderisi 20 , Reference Galetta, Franzoni and Prattichizzo 23 , Reference Gottdiener, Gross, Henry, Borer and Ebert 25 , Reference Vazquez, Olivares and Fleta 32 – Reference Olivares, Vazquez and Fleta 35 and intraventricular septal wall thicknessReference Silvetti, Magnani and Santilli 16 , Reference Vazquez, Olivares and Fleta 32 while others refute these findings.Reference Kastner, Salbach-Andrae and Renneberg 29
A postulated mechanism for the cardiac structural remodelling observed is vagal hyperactivity, seen as an attempt to conserve energy, leading to changes in both contractility and decreased pre-load, which then result in cardiac atrophy in compensation for the volume depletion.Reference Casiero and Frishman 30 , Reference Romano, Chinali and Pasanisi 31 , Reference Petretta, Banaduce and Scalfi 36 On the other hand, De Simone et alReference De Simone, Scalfi and Galderisi 20 found that the loss of left ventricular mass in women with anorexia nervosa was not the same as that seen in underweight women without starvation. Moreover, Galetta et alReference Galetta, Franzoni and Cupisti 37 observed that decreased left ventricular mass has been associated with prolonged QT interval in women with anorexia nervosa but not in underweight women without starvation. Thus, the specific mechanisms of remodelling seen in anorexia nervosa are not yet fully understood.
Several associations have been found between starvation and cardiac remodelling, but conflict remains. Silvetti et alReference Silvetti, Magnani and Santilli 16 found decreased left ventricular mass and cardiac chamber dimension to be associated with low body mass index, low caloric intake, low free triiodothyronine, and low sodium; however, Carlomagno et al more recently found elevated growth hormone levels and decreased insulin-like growth factor-1, in addition to the decreased free triiodothyronine, to be potential markers. After adjusting for the reduced haemodynamic load, they found that body mass index, amount of weight loss, afterload, and other routine laboratory markers of malnutrition did not predict the loss of left ventricular mass.Reference Carlomagno, Mercurio and Ruvolo 38
Biological plausibility exists for these endocrine markers being associated with starvation-induced cardiovascular disease as elevated growth hormone levels, low insulin-like growth factor-1, and low free triiodothyronine are known predictors of short-term risk of organic complications in anorexia nervosa,Reference Estour, Germain and Diconne 39 and improvement in left ventricular mass and normalisation of insulin-like growth factor-1 levels have been observed with weight restoration of adolescents with anorexia nervosa;Reference Mont, Castro and Herreros 40 however, studies of supplementation with growth hormones and/or insulin-like growth factor-1 to stimulate appetite and muscle metabolism – instead of catabolism – have proved to be inconsistent.Reference Hill, Bucuvalas and McClaine 41 – Reference Grinspoon, Miller, Herzog, Clemmons and Klibanski 43 Overall, cardiac remodelling is not predictable, not just associated with loss of weight or weight nadir, and not always seen along with standard malnutrition labs.Reference Mont, Castro and Herreros 40
The exact link between structural alterations and decreased cardiac function found in anorexia nervosa is not clear. Specific electrolyte, mineral, and other chemical deficiencies are known to impact contractility including hypomagnesaemia, hypophosphataemia, thiamine or selenium deficiency,Reference Brady, Rock and Horneffer 44 – Reference Georges, Thissen and Lambert 51 direct cardiac toxicity from syrup of ipecac,Reference Friedman 52 – Reference Silber 59 thyrotoxicosis, alcohol abuse,Reference Birmingham and Gritzner 60 and potentially hypoglycaemiaReference Ohwada, Hotta and Kimura 61 and catecholamine overload.Reference Birmingham and Gritzner 60 , Reference Bonnemeier, Mall and Wiedang 62 Many of these same deficiencies and complications exist in patients struggling with restricting and/or purging subtypes of anorexia nervosa.
Reductions in cardiac output are due to decreases in stroke volume or heart rate reflected in the relationship expressed by the classic cardiac equation “cardiac output=stroke volume×heart rate”. Cardiac output is lower in patients with anorexia nervosaReference Kastner, Salbach-Andrae and Renneberg 29 – Reference Romano, Chinali and Pasanisi 31 as is heart rate; however, debate remains regarding changes in stroke volume.
Some studies have used ejection fraction or fractional shortening to evaluate contractility and stroke volume and have shown decreases in patients with anorexia nervosa;Reference Casiero and Frishman 30 , Reference Romano, Chinali and Pasanisi 31 but, most data, and more recent studies in particular, refute this and have shown normal ejection fraction and fractional shortening,Reference Vazquez, Olivares and Fleta 32 , Reference Olivares, Vazquez and Fleta 35 suggesting that decreases in cardiac output may be more specifically related to differential reductions in heart rate in the starved patient as opposed to those who are just underweight. This is supported by a recent evaluation of the effect of starvation on rat contractility. Stroke volume in the starved rats was not lower than that in underweight rats that were not starved; however, bradycardia was more severe in the starved rats. This explained the difference seen in cardiac output between the groups in their study.Reference Lee, Ko and Kim 63 Atrial function in anorexia nervosa unfortunately has not been studied enough for adequate comments.
In summary, decreases in left ventricular mass and remodelling of the myocardium resulting in dimensional changes occur in anorexia nervosa, but it is unclear about the mechanisms leading to these changes. Furthermore, these structural changes are not directly related to cardiac dysfunction. Contractility can be impacted by starvation and nutrient insufficiency as well as toxicity and other co-morbid conditions, but without these insults decreases in cardiac output seem to be most dependent upon the bradycardia seen along with the starvation associated with anorexia nervosa. Refeeding, or correction of nutritional deficiencies, leads to normalisation of reduced left ventricular mass, regional wall movement abnormalities, and decreased cardiac output.Reference Roche, Barthelemy and Garet 64 – Reference Ulger, Gurses, Ozyurek, Arikan, Levent and Aydogdu 68
Valve abnormalities
Mitral valve prolapse is a known, common cardiac complication of anorexia nervosa. Prevalence rates vary from 33 to 66%,Reference Johnson, Humphries, Shirley, Mazzoleni and Noonan 69 compared with only 0.6 to 2.4% in the general populationReference Avierinos, Gersh and Dphil 70 and up to 5% in children.Reference Park 71 Usually, only mild regurgitation is found; however, it is a potential cause of chest pain and palpitations, which if symptomatic may be treated with beta blockers.Reference Mehler and Andersen 72 Mitral valve prolapse is reversible with nutritional rehabilitation.Reference Olivares, Vazquez and Fleta 35 , Reference Mont, Castro and Herreros 40 , Reference Roche, Barthelemy and Garet 64
As there are no definitive associated electrocardiogram changes, it is usually diagnosed by the characteristic mid-systolic click, perhaps associated with a late-systolic murmur, best heard at the apex of the heart. In anorexia nervosa, mitral valve prolapse has been postulated to be associated with loss of ventricular mass found with low weight combined with sparing of the valvular support tissues, resulting in a relative redundancy of the valve itself;Reference Johnson, Humphries, Shirley, Mazzoleni and Noonan 69 however, Oflaz et al, evaluated the impact of body mass index and duration of illness on rates of mitral valve prolapse in their cohort of 40 young adult females with anorexia nervosa and found no association. This suggests that more than just low body weight may be necessary to develop mitral valve prolapse in this population.Reference Oflaz, Yucel and Oz 33
Pericardial effusion
Pericardial effusion is an area of increased interest within anorexia nervosa. Pericardial effusion has turned out to be a relatively common finding with prevalence rates varying widely from 15 to 71%;Reference Silvetti, Magnani and Santilli 16 , Reference Frolich, von Gontard and Lehmkuhl 73 – Reference Docx, Gewillig and Simons 75 newer studies suggest that approximately one-third may be the expected rate.Reference Kastner, Salbach-Andrae and Renneberg 29 , Reference Oflaz, Yucel and Oz 33 It is almost always silent, and refeeding leads to remission, but the temporal course has not yet been elucidated.Reference Kastner, Salbach-Andrae and Renneberg 29 , Reference Frolich, von Gontard and Lehmkuhl 73 There have been two cases reported in the literature of cardiac tamponade in anorexia nervosa requiring surgical intervention by pericardiocentesisReference Polli, Blengino and Moro 76 or creation of a surgical windowReference Kircher, Park and Cheezum 77 and two other cases where pericardiocentesis was performed pre-emptively because of the risk of imminent tamponade.Reference Cho, Yang and Ma 78
Predicting patients with anorexia nervosa who are most at risk for pericardial effusion has proven to be difficult. In the only study to examine the subtypes of anorexia nervosa, no differences in prevalence were noted based on restricting compared with binge/purge subtype.Reference Kastner, Salbach-Andrae and Renneberg 29 Most studies have suggested a relation to low body mass index,Reference Silvetti, Magnani and Santilli 16 , Reference Kastner, Salbach-Andrae and Renneberg 29 , Reference Frolich, von Gontard and Lehmkuhl 73 , Reference Docx, Gewillig and Simons 75 , Reference Slivka, Buckelew, Shafer, Mosicki and Garber 79 significant weight loss,Reference Docx, Gewillig and Simons 75 and duration of illness,Reference Ramaciotti, Coli and Biadi 74 but recent studies have not been as consistent.Reference Kastner, Salbach-Andrae and Renneberg 29 , Reference Oflaz, Yucel and Oz 33 In a recent study of 173 adolescents with anorexia nervosa, Kastner et alReference Kastner, Salbach-Andrae and Renneberg 29 showed an association with low body mass index, but this was a small effect size (n2=0.034), and Oflaz et al,Reference Oflaz, Yucel and Oz 33 in a cross-sectional study of 40 female patients with anorexia nervosa, found no relation to body mass index at all. Absolute amount of weight loss of >25 lbs was linked to the presence of pericardial effusion by Docx et alReference Docx, Gewillig and Simons 75 in a large study of 128 patients, but this has not consistently been found.
Other associations between pericardial effusion and anorexia nervosa noted in the literature also have either conflicting data or have not been replicated in other studies but have included increased length of hospitalisationReference Kastner, Salbach-Andrae and Renneberg 29 and relation to specific lab abnormalities such as decreased levels of free triiodothyronine, sodium,Reference Silvetti, Magnani and Santilli 16 and insulin-like growth factor-1Reference Docx, Gewillig and Simons 75 or increased levels of plasma-derived brain natriuretic peptide.Reference Polli, Blengino and Moro 76 , Reference Inagaki, Yamamoto and Tsubouchi 80
Electrocardiogram changes and rhythm complications
Sinus bradycardia is the most common arrhythmia found in anorexia nervosa.Reference Grover, Robin and Gharahbaghian 81 It is caused by an increased degree of vagal tone and a concomitant decrease in sympathetic modulation.Reference Casiero and Frishman 30 Although the exact reason for the transition to heightened vagal tone is not known, the presumption is that it can be ascribed to a physiological adaptation to a lowering of the metabolic rate as a consequence of malnutrition and caloric restriction.Reference Kollai, Bonyhay, Jokkel and Szonyi 82 Indeed, sympathetic tone is known to increase, with a concomitant reduction in vagal tone, as weight restoration occurs.Reference Bar, Boettger and Wagner 83 Sinus bradycardia becomes more pronounced in concert with a lowering of the body mass index and with a longer duration of the disease.Reference Habil and Loke 84 As the bradycardia becomes more marked, a junctional escape rhythm may develop as well as a sinoatrial or atrioventricular block.Reference Kossaify 85 Of note, the junctional escape rhythm can be extinguished with mild amounts of exercise even when the escape rhythm is extremely slow.Reference Krantz, Gaudiani, Johnson and Mehler 86
Thus, the typical resting vital signs of a patient with anorexia nervosa include a low heart rate, hypothermia, and hypotension with systolic blood pressure values of 70 and 80 mmHg commonly noted. Therefore, the finding of a “normal” resting heart rate of 80 or 90 mmHg is indeed abnormal for this population, especially for the more severe segment of patients with anorexia nervosa who have body mass indices <14. Consideration of secondary concerning aetiologies for this relative “tachycardia” might include incipient heart failure, refeeding syndrome, anaemia or another concomitant acute medical illness,Reference Krantz and Mehler 87 or heightened anxiety related to refeeding. This concern is of greatest importance early on in the weight restoration process because that is when these patients are at the highest risk for the dangerous refeeding syndrome to occur.
There have been a number of case reports of postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome described in anorexia nervosa.Reference Benarroch 88 It is, however, not clear whether this is of any true causal relationship, because large swings in pulse rate can logically be expected due to the aforementioned reduction in left ventricular mass and stroke volume, which necessitates a major rise in the standing heart rate, and that associated with even minimal degrees of exertion. Therefore, at a minimum, resting bradycardia and hypotension should not be treated with medicines to raise the pulse or systolic blood pressure, as these are expected physiological adaptations to starvation and weight loss. Moreover, they both will progressively revert to normal as consistent adequate nutritional rehabilitation ensues, and hypothermia ceases to be found.
In a related manner, the electrocardiogram may demonstrate right-axis deviation in some patients with anorexia nervosa.Reference Carlomagno, Mercurio and Ruvolo 38 This also is attributable to the reduction in left ventricular mass.Reference Docx, Simons, Ramet, Weyler, Thues and Mertens 89 Low voltage may also be noted on the electrocardiogram, due to either a reduction in ventricular mass or due to the recently described incidence of pericardial effusions, which accompany the more severe cases of anorexia nervosa.
An additional finding on the electrocardiograms of patients with anorexia nervosa is that of QT dispersion. This is defined by the maximum inter-lead variability in the QT interval between the leads with the longest and shortest QT intervals. The abnormally increased QT dispersion is a maker of ventricular excitability and may be a root cause for the increased risk of sudden cardiac death in anorexia nervosa patients.Reference Galetta, Franzoni and Cupisti 37 Studies have demonstrated increased QT dispersion in patients with moderately severe anorexia nervosa versus controls as a repolarisation abnormality.Reference Lesinskiene, Barkus, Ranceva and Dembinskas 15 Interestingly, QT dispersion inversely correlates with resting metabolic rate and as refeeding progresses in anorexia nervosa, and as this metabolic rate increases QT dispersion reduces.Reference Krantz, Donahoo, Melanson and Mehler 90
In a related manner, another potential cause for the increased propensity towards sudden cardiac death in anorexia nervosa, notwithstanding the young age of these patients, is the issue of heart rate variability, a marker of autonomic function. There have been a number of studies that have attempted to look at this issue in anorexia nervosa. Although there are hints that these patients may have reduced heart rate variability, results are disparate making conclusions a bit tenuous.Reference Krantz, Sabel and Sagar 91 It does seem likely that there is an evolution from predominantly parasympathetic tone to sympathetic dominant, as the patient weight restores or progresses from acute to chronic.Reference Lamzabi, Syed, Reddy, Jain, Harbhajanka and Arunkumar 92 , Reference Melanson, Donahoo, Krantz, Poirier and Mehler 93
Nevertheless, what has become increasingly clear is that the long-held belief that QT prolongation is inherent to anorexia nervosa does not seem to be correct.Reference Vaurs, Rollin and Berard 94 Thus, when QT prolongation is detected in a patient with anorexia nervosa, it should not summarily be ascribed to anorexia nervosa, but rather an assiduous search for secondary causes should be pursued, including electrolyte aberrations and medication side effects.Reference Facchini, Sala, Malfatto, Bragato, Redaelli and Invitti 95 , Reference Drew, Ackerman and Funk 96 The causal association of QT interval prolongation in anorexia nervosa with an increased risk of sudden cardiac death is no longer supported in the literature.
Conclusion
In summary, anorexia nervosa is unfortunately associated with an excessive mortality rate, even though it typically affects the young population. There are a litany of medical complications of anorexia nervosa that likely contribute to this guarded prognosis. These complications related to the cardiovascular system have long been felt to be impactful in this regard as the aforementioned text has described. Increased awareness and enquiry in this regard will help achieve more successful treatment outcomes for patients afflicted by anorexia nervosa.
Acknowledgements
None.
Conflicts of Interest
None.