In many ways, Zeynep Çelik's About Antiquities is a pendant piece to the ambitious Scramble for the Past: A Story of Archaeology in the Ottoman Empire, 1753–1914, the 2011 volume that she edited with Zainab Bahrani and Edhem Eldem. Through scopic essay entries, Scramble for the Past gave us a near-complete account of the European archaeological expeditions in the Ottoman domains. About Antiquities deepens our focus on the Ottoman engagement with archaeology in the field and strategies of display (in the context of the museum and in print media). Palpable threads weave together the two publications; for instance, the identity, work, and agency of previously lesser-known figures like Hormuzd Rassam, an Oxford-trained archaeologist from Iraq, or the revealing fact that archaeological sites, too, were formulated along the divisive lines of colonial dual-cities that Frantz Fanon had first described in the case of Algeria. Osman Hamdi, the ubiquitous and inimitable spokesperson for the Ottoman side of the story, of course, needs no mention. These publications adroitly expose the colonial/Orientalist politics and ideologies that undergirded the “scientific” expeditions and cast light on the many forgotten individuals and groups who labored to excavate, document, interpret, and determine the destination of objects and monuments. Along with the work that Wendy Shaw has done on the founding of Ottoman museums, these volumes not only provide us with a nifty archaeological history from the Ottoman perspective, but also offer us an almost encyclopedic array of previously overlooked archival sources, plays, paintings, drawings, novels, photographs, and periodicals.
Çelik's account begins with a comparative institutional history (between the Metropolitan Museum and Ottoman Imperial Museum of Antiquities), two ambitious museums that, although geographically and temporally peripheral to their European predecessors, were still eager to compete in the museological arena and stake a claim on civilizational narratives. The comparative global framework, though a Çelik trademark and often enlightening in the similarities that it reveals, here minimizes the local context, reliant upon fluctuations in state administration, in which the Imperial Museum of Antiquities was conceived. In fact, the museum comes at the tail-end of the conversion of the Topkapı Palace into an exhibitionary complex largely for a foreign audience. Furthermore, it was not merely unmediated personal rapport between Osman Hamdi and Sultan Abdülhamid II that made the museum's founding possible, but rather decades of ministerial machinations and prolific scholarly productions of high-level Tanzimat bureaucrats such as Abdüllatif Subhi Paşa, Ahmed Vefik Paşa, and other members of the Ministry of Endowments and Education. These individuals and institutions helped ignite and maintain museological processes in the empire including but not limited to the Museum of Antiquities. The yearbooks of these ministries to which Çelik occasionally refers provide ample coverage of state-run excavations for just this reason. Ahmed Vefik's short but revelatory historiographical collection of essays, titled Hikmet-i Tarih (Philosophy of History) and published in 1863, is seminal in its conception of archaeology as a scientific discipline aiding the study of history. This text and others precede the 1902 article on the “science of antique works” that starts the fourth chapter.
The second chapter of the book illustrates the various European and American scholarly appraisals of Osman Hamdi's Sidon excavation. How these recent discoveries were evaluated and categorized by Western scholarship is especially informative in the context of the discussions on polychromy and Jozef Strygowszki's “Oriental” pull away from the art historical origin story centered on Rome. The third chapter finds answers to what kind of visitor was envisioned for the Museum of Antiquities. The fact that Osman Hamdi targets a predominantly foreign audience is, again, not so surprising in the context of the larger transformations of the Topkapı grounds that were undertaken with international tourism in mind. The two highlights of this chapter are the solid overviews of the museum's own publications and its educational initiatives to allow for school visits. The fourth chapter locates archaeology's place in print media through an analysis of its coverage in periodicals, plays, travel accounts, and novels. It is in these sources that Çelik identifies the rise in proto-national claims to heritage and a deepened interest in “Islamic” antiquities.
A “history from below” (as About Antiquities, at times, purports to be) should perhaps begin with figures that inform its writing rather them end with them. Regrettably, it is only in the last two chapters of the book that we begin to read the “against the grain” history of archaeology that Çelik sets as one of her principal aims in the volume's introduction. Modeling her methodology on Stephen Quirke's Hidden Hands: Hidden Workforces in Petrie Excavation Archives, 1880-1924, she tackles previously overlooked and fraught subjects such as labor exploitation and the many quite jarring imbalances in the day-to-day living conditions between the workers and coordinators of digs.
This time around, Çelik is not overly generous in supplying basic background information on sites, their excavation dates, and their various claimants, which would have made this volume stand on its own. The reader would have also benefited from a map as a signpost showing all the many dig sites. The last two chapters of About Antiquities view the constituents of the disparate archaeological worlds in a spatial and temporal vacuum, perhaps to suppress the narrative centrality of the Western hegemonic excavators (who inevitably kept all the books), and, in turn, they emphasize the agency of the laborers. Moreover, the passages on Sidon and its much-publicized sarcophagi that would quickly become the centerpieces of the Imperial Museum of Antiquities rely too much on the reader's having extant knowledge of previous scholarship. But perhaps most importantly, the plan of the museum's later extensions cited from the periodical Servet-i Fünun, which also serves as the book's second figure, is not the correct museum plan but an unrealized project. A careful visitor to the site today would realize the asymmetry between the lengths of the two projections. Nevertheless, Çelik, in deceptively neat categories, opens up new avenues of research for the next generation of scholars writing against the grain of canonical archaeological works and approaches. Perhaps the most important challenge facing them will be how to write histories of Ottoman archaeology without the towering centrality of Osman Hamdi.
