In his poems honouring the Western emperor Honorius, his general and regent Stilicho, and their allies, Claudian was an author who spoke glittering fiction to power. By their nature, the poems demanded ceremonial inflation of virtues and achievements, just as their counterpart, verse invectives against the enemies of the Western court, required Claudian to make his targets caricatures of wickedness, men who were pessimis peiores. Critics have shown that in this court poetry, Claudian followed guidelines for panegyric and invective established by the rhetorical tradition. But in her stimulating study, Catherine Ware demonstrates that the texts should be considered epic poems above all else. In them, she argues, Claudian recast language and themes found especially in Virgil and first-century c.e. epic poets to heroize his imperial patrons and to give epic shape to contemporary politics and history. As W. observes, Claudian crafted a poetic persona that was ‘invariably and insistently epic’ (1); as she reveals, his political poetry at Honorius’ court bears out that self-definition.
In order to make her argument, W. must answer two fundamental questions that she herself poses (32): ‘What defines Roman epic and how does Claudian's work qualify?’ The answers she gives are thorough and cogent. First, she notes that praise was inherent to Roman epic, and she suggests that Claudian, like the late antique Servius and Tiberius Claudius Donatus, would have viewed epic as a genus laudativum (27–9). This allows her to dispense with the category ‘panegyric-epic’, a hybrid title unknown in Claudian's time that would have presumably seemed redundant to him, and to characterize his court encomia simply as epics. While W. is careful to note how Claudian's poems differed from (Virgilian and post-Virgilian) epic norms in their length, episodic character, strong mannerism and occasional status, she is convincing in her contention that praise constituted an ‘essence’ of the epic genre, which Claudian activated in his encomiastic poems.
Further answers appear when, in ch. 2, W. discusses thematic markers of epic and Claudian's treatment of them (42–58). Of particular interest to her are the ways in which Claudian adapted traditional epic material to celebrate the Roman virtues of his subjects and their preservation of Rome's imperium. As she perceptively argues in those pages and in later chapters of the book, Claudian reworked the ideological substance of earlier epic particularly in order to present Theodosius, Honorius, Stilicho and (to a lesser extent) Mallius Theodorus as civic ideals who overcame obstacles and enemies and enabled Rome to continue to fulfill its historic destiny to rule. W. is sensitive to how Roman epic was a constantly evolving genre: while Virgil was an unavoidable standard and model for his successors, they were able to carve out space for themselves by updating and, at times, departing from the received tradition. Yet as she recognizes, amid the innovation, the concern with Roman power and politics endured. Although Claudian's political world was very different from that of Virgil, Ovid, Lucan and Statius, he joined with them in dealing with ‘the rulers of the Roman empire, the wars fought to protect it, and the struggle for power’ between those who ‘uph[e]ld the mos maiorum and those who reject[ed] it’ (57).
Where W. might overreach is in her insistence that the poems of Claudian she examines form a carmen perpetuum, a single, ‘ongoing epic with no conclusion other than the preservation of Roman imperium sine fine’ (5). Even if one accepts, as I do, her claims about the epic character of the relevant texts, it seems excessive to contend that they make up one continuous epic poem. It is also the case that W. sometimes strays from her main argument about Claudian the epic poet and focuses on his treatment of non-epic material — for example, in her final two chapters on the golden age, which deal significantly with the fourth Eclogue and with Georgics 1 and 2. This makes the book at times feel centrifugal. A conclusion would have surely helped to counteract that, but W. ends her study abruptly without one.
The strengths of W.'s book, however, far outweigh these weaknesses. Where she particularly excels is in her close readings of Claudian's poems. These display her command of his poetic techniques, her knowledge of late fourth- and early fifth-century politics, her deep familiarity with the authors whom Claudian took as models to imitate, and her ability to interpret instances of imitation in a methodologically sound but creative manner. W.'s analysis of Claudianic imitatio brings out in detail how he used the literary past to create epic versions and visions of the present. Along the way, W. addresses many aspects of Claudian's texts, including how he handled the epic hero, historical time, and themes like concordia/discordia and the Battle of the Giants.
W. has written an excellent book that, instead of trying to look through the literary to the historical, focuses on the literary and on how a poet represents the historical. Those interested in Claudian, the period in which he wrote, and epic poetry will find much of value in it.
