No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 April 2005
The Haram al-Sharif (Noble Sanctuary) is the architectural and visual focus of the Old City of Jerusalem. The sacred precinct, with its magnificent gem-like monument—the Dome of the Rock—and the al-Aqsa Mosque, as well as dozens of other domed structures, arcades, light, and serenity, comes near to being one of the glories of the world. It has symbolic and religious implications for the three great monotheistic religions, which add to its undoubted impact on the visitor.
Numerous studies have focused on the architecture and history of art of the monuments on the Haram. However, few studies have attempted to examine the various conceptions regarding this holy site. In that respect, Andreas Kaplony's book represents a breakthrough. Covering the period from Byzantine rule in 324 until the Frankish conquest of Jerusalem in 1099, he traces the emergence of conceptions with which the major religions share the Holy City. He also examines their interactions as well as the political circumstances and religious axioms that give each conception its specific form. His analysis is based on a thorough description of the Haram—focusing on topics such as names and traditions, architecture, rituals and customs, visions and dreams—and on the establishment of as many parallels as possible.
The book is divided into two major parts. The first part is devoted to conceptions related to Jerusalem. It shows how Jerusalem has developed from a city of one religion into a holy place shared by three religions. This shared holiness has been one of Jerusalem's exceptional and most constant features ever since. To comprehend the emergence of the Muslim city in the period 635–1099, the author examines the preceding Christian/Byzantine period. He claims that both Christian and Muslim conceptions are closely linked; the latter are mostly reactions to conceptions of the earlier period. An analysis of the changes yields four periods, each showing a distinctive profile of sources.
During the pre-Marwanid period (324–685), Christians, Jews, and Muslims regard the area unanimously as the place of the former Temple, which leads to three conceptions. In the Christian conception, the Temple is replaced by the Church of the Holy Sepulchre; the Jewish conception relates to the Temple's ruinous state as temporary and believes it should be rebuilt. The Muslim conception, which prevailed for nearly a half century, regards the former Temple, which has been replaced by the Ka

ba, as a place that lost its importance. The Muslims build a mosque in the area and orientate it toward the Ka

ba.
The Marwanid period (685–813) witnesses an extensive building scheme that equates the Muslim mosque with the Temple precinct. At the same time, the south building (i.e., the Aqsa Mosque) is recognized as the Muslim Friday congregational prayer mosque. This grandiose architectural project, comparable to the Friday mosques of Damascus, Medina, and Mecca, competes with the monumental Byzantine churches and demonstrates the political supremacy of Islam. The mosque of Jerusalem is seen as a place of extraordinary spiritual power, of distinct holiness. Traditions charge the whole area with special holiness, the scene of eschatological events such as the Prophet Muhammad's Night Journey. Architectural activity declares this sanctified landscape with a number of holy spots, of which the Rock is the holiest.
In the High Abbasid period (813–969) a new conception emerges in which ritual deals more and more with the area's reputation as a place of immense spiritual power. Not only has the conception of the Muslim Temple become weaker, but its respective political goals are slowly forgotten. Christian traditions identify the area with the Temple of Solomon, while Jewish sources and traditions resume the concept of the former and future Temple.
The Fatimid period (969–1099) develops out of the double conception of two mosques inside each other—the whole precinct and the south building. The Fatimids rebuild the mosque after it is devastated by a series of earthquakes and provide it with all the elements characteristic of the great Fatimid mosques. They also enhance its status vis-à-vis the Dome of the Rock and begin calling the south building the al-Aqsa Mosque. Christians and Jews continue to identify this area with the Temple but also call it the mosque of the city.
The second part of the book contains a catalogue of the places (numbering 209) arranged according to the four periods. Each place is dealt with in terms of name, position, physical shape, traditions, rituals and customs, and visions and dreams.
Kaplony's research is based on broad and extensive primary and secondary sources in several languages. What is most impressive is his use of the primary sources to elucidate his thesis, ranging from reports of Christian pilgrims such as Etheria (c. 400), Theodosius (c. 518–30), and Arculfus (680) to Muslim traditions in praise of Jerusalem (Fada

il Bayt al-Maqdis) as quoted by many chroniclers, including al-Wasiti and Ibn al-Murajja (first half of the 11th century); Muslim geographers such as al-Istakhri (9th century), Ibn al-Faqih (902), al-Muqaddasi (985), Ibn Hawqal (c. 988), and Nasir-i Khusrau (1047); and the Jewish Arabic letters from the Cairo Geniza (first half of the 11th century). He also relies on the many inscriptions that are associated with the buildings and places in question, which have been meticulously published by the Swiss epigraphist Max van Berchem. In addition, he makes use of the abundant modern archaeological and architectural research that deals with existing monuments and remains of other buildings.
The study is not only exhaustive in scope. It also offers a new perspective on the development of perceptions regarding the Holy City adopted by the believers of the three major religions. This book is an excellent contribution to the growing literature on Islamic Jerusalem, and it will indubitably be of interest to scholars and students of medieval Islamic history.