No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 April 2005
Balancing Act is a timely contribution to understanding U.S. foreign policy toward the Arab–Israeli conflict. The book seeks to describe and explain U.S. attempts to be an evenhanded and balanced broker in one of the most protracted contemporary conflicts. From the outset, the author distinguishes between the claim of “neutrality” and actual policy. There is a palpable recurring pattern: “the US declares a ‘balanced’ approach, attempting to straddle Israeli and Arab sensitivities, only to end up taking the Israeli position in the end” (p. vii).
Vaughn Shannon suggests a level-of-analysis approach to look at various influences on U.S. foreign policy. The first level is the geostrategic influence, which focuses on the geo-politics and material factors, such as oil, and the shifting balance of power in the international system. The author's working hypothesis regarding the geostrategic effect is that the protection of Middle Eastern oil from external and internal threats is an overarching strategic goal to which other objectives are subordinate.
The second influence is domestic, concentrating on political forces that impinge on various American administrations with the threat and promise of votes and donations. The domestic sources of U.S. foreign policy emanate from congressional–executive relations, interest groups, and electoral politics. The main domestic hypothesis here is that the United States tends to be pro-Israel as a rule. This is due to the apathy of the general public regarding the Arab–Israeli conflict and the lack of a competitive coalition similar to the pro-Israel lobby. The domestic political influence (in Israel's favor, for the most part) may be at odds with strategic national interest (preserving the flow of “Arab” oil). The act of balancing Arab sensitivity due to strategic concerns against Israeli sensitivity for domestic reasons is the essence of U.S. foreign policy toward the Arab–Israeli conflict.
The final level of analysis is that of the individual decision makers. It is the way in which the perspective of the American presidents and their advisers affects their balancing of strategic and domestic influences. The key assumption of this level of analysis is that the decision makers' beliefs and perceptions may explain idiosyncratic developments rather than patterns. Employing this lens helps explain how certain presidents have felt on some issues, such as the disdain that George W. Bush consistently showed toward Yasir Arafat.
Shannon uses a historical approach to test the contending hypotheses about the relative weight of the different influences on U.S. policy. He traces U.S. decisions and actions toward the Arab–Israeli conflict since World War II. The purpose of this exercise is to describe and analyze U.S. behavior based on historical evidence so that patterns can be identified and explained by their international, domestic, and individual sources.
The book is divided into nine short chapters. In chapter 1, Shannon lays out the context and perspectives, emphasizing the importance of subjective views of the participants regarding the key issues of the conflict (i.e., the Palestinian state, refugees, settlements, and Jerusalem). Chapters 3–8 trace chronologically the international, domestic, and individual bearings on U.S. behavior in the quest for the appearance of balance. During each period, special attention is paid to the most salient influence. For instance, chapter 3 illustrates the emerging potency of the Cold War and the power of Jewish influence. Chapter 4 reveals the crystallization of the special relationship between the United States and the state of Israel. The final chapter concludes with an assessment of the balance sheet and its implications.
The author highlights some clear patterns that have emerged over time. The first pattern is the United States' attempt to maintain evenhandedness. Second, there is a fairly conspicuous bias in favor of Israel, both in the definition of situations and in policy. This is why some analysts believe that “the ‘balancing act’ is just that: an act” (p. 128). Third, presidents who have dared to challenge Israel have tended to be Republican more than Democrat. The book concludes with two recommendations: one in favor of continuity; the other urging change. For continuity, Shannon advocates continued aid and support to moderate regimes in the Middle East: Egypt, Jordan, and Israel. What needs to change in the pursuit of regional stability and winning the war on terror, according to the author, is the creation of a Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza. While Shannon acknowledges the obstacles to realizing this objective, he believes that the United States and the international community could unilaterally recognize such a state.
But the recommendation of unilateral recognition of a Palestinian state, while admirable, is unfeasible as long as Israel and its supporters remain opposed to it. The thorough historical analysis in this book illustrates how various U.S. administrations have followed rather than led when it has come to making unpopular choices regarding the Arab–Israeli conflict. Why should we expect any future U.S. administration to go against the dictate of the pro–Zionist lobby?
Another issue involves some minor factual mistakes, which could be easily corrected in future editions. The author states, in the context of describing negotiations on the “Syrian track,” that the United States hosted Hafiz al-Asad and Shimon Peres in Maryland in late 1995 (p. 96). The head of the Syrian delegation was the foreign minister, Farouq al-Shari

. Al-Asad never headed any delegation to public negotiations with Israel, nor did he ever pay any official visit to Washington. Another error is naming members of the Quartet (the international entity overseeing the implementation of the road-map agreement) as the United States, United Nations, United Kingdom, and Russia (p. 124); the European Union, not the United Kingdom, is the third member.
On balance, Balancing Act is well researched and analytically sound. It is recommended for policymakers, journalists, and upper-level undergraduate and graduate classes related to Middle East politics, U.S. foreign policy, and the Arab–Israeli conflict, especially after publication of an affordable paperback edition.