No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 September 2005
This book is an attempt to fill the gap in the study of foreign policy of Muslim states in general and of the Organization of Islamic Conference (OIC) in particular. The understudied nature of the OIC, especially by Western social scientists, is hard to explain given the organization's symbolic importance in the Muslim world and the potential theoretical and practical implications for social sciences and international relations theory. Naveed Sheikh's book is a study of the OIC based on case studies of Saudi Arabia, Iran, and Pakistan. In its five chapters, the author seeks to bridge the ideational–material dialectic by integrating the factuality of the post–Westphalian nation-state system with Islam's normative and ideational content (pp. 1–2). Sheikh's overriding argument is that Islam informs the foreign policy of Muslim nation-states, but these states also use Islam to justify and rationalize their own policymaking.
Sheikh states two goals for his book: (1) to undo the semantics of civilizational categories and (2) to think and ponder on the praxis of Islamic nation-states. To achieve these goals, the author embarkes on a critique of Orientalism as a research program in chapter 1 and undertakes the three case studies in chapter 3. In documented and intellectually powerful ways, Sheikh exposes Western modernity for its self-centeredness and its love of centralization of power. Modernity's self-legitimizing arguments that everything that is not Western and not secular is not modern are rendered impoverished and haughty.
Starting from the premise that understanding classical Islamic political thought is necessary, but not sufficient, to understand and explain contemporary politics in Muslim states, the second chapter examines Muslim responses to the dissolution of the caliphate, both in classical (post-Abbasid) and modern (post-Ottoman) times. Sheikh analyzes the ideational imperative of Islamic unity as embodied in the concepts of tawhdotuīd and umma against the contextual and situational constraints. He rightly distinguishes between the concept of theological unity and the plurality of manifestations in the phenomenal world, something that is frequently lost on contemporary Islamists. Sheikh criticizes the pan-Islamism of al-Afghani and Abduh for the lack of political structure, in spite of their affirmation of the ideational (unity) structure. Struggle for liberation from the colonial yoke has, paradoxically, turned the state into an Islamic category: “for contemporary Islam, an (ex post facto) ‘Islamized’ territorial world order coexists with the ideological transnationalism of classical siyar” (p. 32). The result is the institutionalization of nationalism and secularism as embodied in the concepts of qawm and dawla, which superseded the notions of umma and dīn.
The OIC—or, as it is known among some Muslims for its habitual ineffectiveness in solving problems, “Oh, I see!”—came as the final nail in the coffin of pan-Arab secularism, as Saudi Arabia sought to restore its role in the Arab world, aided by Pakistan, Iran, and Morocco. The coffin was, of course, provided earlier by the crushing Israeli victory in the Six Day War in 1967. Another impetus for the creation of the OIC came in the wake of an attempt by an Australian messianic Christian to burn al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem in August 1969. The normative ideals of Islamic unity also served as a counterbalance to Gamal Abdel Nasser's revolutionary pan-Arabism and Ba

athist nationalist radicalism. Yet in spite of the rhetorical adherence to the ideational imperative of unity, the OIC accepted state-centric realism as an operative principle. This is further augmented by the fact that the charter of the OIC does not contain the word “unity” but, instead, talks about “consolidat[ing] cooperation” and “solidarity” (p. 38). Yet cooperation does not seem to include a political dimension, a glaring and telling omission indeed. Once again, the ideals of unity and the reality of étatism found their interesting synthesis in the OIC.
Sheikh's selection of case studies within the OIC is well justified. Major findings in chapter 3 include the exposition of the OIC's Janus-like policies—pious normative language and interest-based nation-state considerations—and what Sheikh calls a “triangle of neutralization.” This refers to “a tripartite relationship which is aimed at counterpoising the interest-expansion of other states while still upholding the masquerade of Islamic internationalism within the OIC” (p. 100). The Saudis adopt a reactive strategy and focus on economic transnational Islamic community; the Iranians espouse activism based on an understanding of umma as a political community; and the Pakistanis assume a defensive stance and primarily look at the international Islamic community as security-oriented. Each state thus infuses its own national interest into the OIC's body, which amounts to neutralization of the other two states. End results are often the paralysis and ineffectiveness that is habitually associated with the OIC.
Chapters 4 and 5 are a discussion of what the study means for international relations theory, social science, and humanities by focusing on self-identity in foreign policy. Sheikh discusses international relations theories—different variants of realism, rationalism/liberalism, constructivism, the English school—in a masterly way, but he does not commit himself to any single approach. This is due to these theories' partial inapplicability to Sheikh's subject matter and not because of the author's hesitancy. His conclusion is that pan-Islamism, of which the OIC is a contemporary embodiment, is better understood as a role in international relations than as an operative rule of international politics.
The book is well researched. The author is at ease with both classical and modern Islamic thought and shows a command of international relations theories. Some may find Sheikh's language bombastic at times. I find it often humorous. The chapter with case studies can be used in undergraduate classes on international organizations, while the theoretical chapters will definitely make for an interesting debate in graduate seminars on international relations. In short, this is an extremely intelligent and timely book.