P.M. Harman is best known for his books on nineteenth-century physics, but in The Culture of Nature in Britain 1680–1860 he has moved backwards in time and outwards in scope to identify a long eighteenth century that is unfamiliar to historians of science. Although Isaac Newton provides a conventional enough starting point, Harman terminates his period not only with The Origin of Species but also with John Ruskin's Modern Painters; moreover, his index runs from Abelard to Xenophon, and unexpectedly contains multiple entries on John Constable, Erasmus Darwin and J.M.W. Turner – but none for mathematics, physics or biology.
This is a commendably interdisciplinary study that ignores subsequently imposed boundaries by exploring simultaneously a range of interacting artistic, poetic, scientific, religious and philosophical responses to the natural world. Yet as the cover blurb proclaims, this is an ‘intellectual history’, and recent studies of politics, personalities and publications make only fleeting intrusions. Benefiting from an impressively broad range of sources, Harman sets out to provide various perspectives on what he sees as a Romantic shift in perception away from a harmonious universe designed for human habitation and towards a dynamic nature that transcends aesthetic description. According to Harman, his nominal closing date of 1860 (in fact, he discusses several later publications) represents a key transition point when natural theology was finally displaced and scientific professionalism came to dominate intellectual culture.
Although Harman helpfully summarizes his ideas in the preface and conclusion and at the end of each chapter, I remain unclear about his central argument. He claims to show ‘that Romanticism disrupted [the] links between natural theology and the aesthetic appreciation of nature’ (p. ix), although he does not ask whether Romanticism might be a symptom rather than a cause of change. Moreover, much of his book is not so much about how nature should be experienced or interpreted, but more about how it should be represented. Ruskin plays a leading role, appearing more often than either Charles Darwin or Newton. As Harman discusses, Ruskin insisted that when aiming to capture the fundamental truth of nature, artists and scientists alike should pay close attention to the specific details of the particular item in front of them. But although Ruskin enjoyed talking to Darwin, he despised the naturalist's techniques of illustration, ranking him with the ‘human bats … of semi-faculty or semi-education’ who used mechanistic imagery and were blind to nature's true beauty (pp. 32 and 230; not the only example of repeated quotations). Rejecting generalized, idealized versions of natural phenomena, Ruskin emphasized the importance of capturing truth by focusing on the particular. This might involve meticulous representation of surface appearances – as in John Gould's bird paintings – or a more imaginative rendition summoning up the impression produced in a spectator's mind. Thus Ruskin praised Turner's Romantic landscapes that aim to communicate ‘the far higher and deeper truth of mental vision, rather than of the physical facts’ (Ruskin quoted pp. 188–189).
Organizing his material into themes such as ‘Exploration’, ‘Design’ and ‘Vital Forces’, Harman proceeds loosely chronologically within each one. His book's central core comprises two chapters on landscape, the first focusing on earlier pastoral and picturesque depictions and the second on later portrayals complying with Ruskin's injunction that artists should ‘fully and accurately depict the brazen “real world of nature”’ (p. 93). The great advantage of this structure is that Harman can intermingle and present together information that would normally be separated into books about the histories of art, literature and science. Even so, it remains a descriptive rather than an explanatory analysis, unilluminatingly summarized as the emergence of ‘a new framework of argument, shaped by different social forces and intellectual assumptions within which interactions flourished, with new patterns changing the terms of cultural criticism and debate’ (p. xi).
Presumably, Yale University Press is hoping to attract the educated General Reader, this century's equivalent of Average Man, since Harman several times misleadingly explains that ‘natural philosophy’ is the old name for ‘science’. Unfortunately, although Yale is renowned for its high-quality art publications, here all the illustrations are in grainy black and white, which detracts from the great significance Harman places on visual arguments. For instance, the chapter called ‘Colour’ opens with a subtle exposition of William Holman Hunt's attempt to paint hues as they appear to a human observer, but words such as ‘polychromatic’ and ‘dazzling’ make little sense when the reader is confronted with what looks like a mediocre photograph of sheep. It would also have been helpful to produce a separate bibliography rather than having the full details of the references included within the endnotes.
Largely avoiding retrospective value judgements, Harman has produced an accessible yet scholarly example of long overview histories covering both science and the arts. Evidently the culmination of a lifelong project, this book makes manifest Harman's exceptionally wide range of interests and expertise.
