Alexander Gerschenkron was a man of many talents, and eclectic interests. He was one of our profession's most venerable scholars, but also, as the statistics on graduate education published in the most recent Clio Society newsletter attest, one of our profession's most venerable educators as well. What more fitting combination could there be in the named honoree for a dissertation prize, an academic exercise that serves as both the introduction to one's scholarly career in research, as well as the culmination of one's formal education. I hope that for the three nominees for this prize brought together today, this occasion marks as much a beginning in our profession as it does closure of their graduate educations.
Any prize whose geographical scope includes the phrase “everywhere else” is bound to see a wide assortment of submissions. In the end, I read nine manuscripts; but if I had been more multilingual than I am (or willing to discriminate on the random basis of my linguistic capabilities) I could have read half again as many more. These dissertations ranged in theme from company mergers during globalization to the spread of the Great Depression across colonial empires, to social welfare policy, to the mass movement of people across oceans, to the trade journals that taught home-grown engineers how to build steam engines. Reading them all was an exercise not just in comparing apples to oranges, but to grapes and bananas as well.
In the face of such diversity I selected a few criteria to be my guide. I looked for the creative and original use of source materials to answer questions important to the enterprise of economic history; for evidence of modes of thinking that reflect interdisciplinary perspectives; and for clear, indeed beautiful, prose allowing for the easy comprehension of complex arguments and ideas.
The first dissertation presented to you today is by Camila Alejandra Arza, titled, “Distributional Impacts of Social Policy: Pension Regimes in Argentina since c.~1944.” It was completed at the London School of Economics, under the direction of Dr. Colin Lewis and Prof. Paul Johnson. This study examines the emergence, expansion, and reform of old-age pension programs in Argentina across the twentieth century with a particular emphasis on the latter half of that period. The course of the study reveals the tenacity of the historian in the archives, the deft hand of the econometrician, and the instinct for social modeling of the sociologist. Arza utilizes both qualitative and quantitative source materials of a most copious variety to assess both the policy objectives and the de facto distributional impacts of these pension programs.
She documents three fundamental policy regimes. The earliest, dating to early in the century, was a status-based one with eligibility earmarked only for certain categories of workers, but among them providing for some progressive redistribution of resources. The second, emerging out the early Peronist period, saw a shift towards much more open rules of eligibility and towards benefits based on earnings, which were not deliberately redistributive in nature but also not entirely proportional to life-time contributions. Finally, the reforms of the last decade of the century saw a strengthening of the trend towards contribution-based access, with benefits defined primarily on an insurance or quid pro quo basis—that is, one withdraws only in relation to what one has paid in.
Arza then asks who benefited most from these different policy regimes governing the rules of pension allocations? To answer this, she begins with a standard cross-sectional analysis of payers and payees, which picks up evidence of intergenerational redistributions but not much else. To her credit, she does not stop there, but rather adds a much more sophisticated lifecycle analysis, which tracks relative payments and benefits over the course of a lifetime using a sequence of household surveys linked over time. Perhaps not surprisingly, the earliest cohorts to contribute to the program, that is, those born before 1920, were the biggest net gainers with the highest returns relative to their contributions. They began paying in relatively late in their working lives to a system that was initially much more generous in its payouts than was to be the case in later years. Younger cohorts faced tougher requirements and longer periods of payments before receiving any benefits. Indeed, the cohort born between 1920 and 1940, which experienced the pension crisis and reform of the late twentieth century towards the close of their working lives, were often, in fact, actual net losers from the system. The lifecycle model suggests, however, that the returns for cohorts retiring in the future should be higher than for this transitional generation.
There have been intragenerational redistribution patterns as well. Most importantly, the early pension schemes of the Peronist period were mildly progressive, with lower income groups provided with higher returns on their payments than for higher income groups. This element had fully disappeared under the provisions of the late-twentieth-century reforms, as the system now pays benefits that more or less replicate the distribution of contributions over the lifetime.
These findings raise a number of interesting questions, which Arza does not address. Most importantly, what are the political ramifications of a pension scheme that for a significant cohort of people actually depletes individual's access to lifetime earnings? That is, we have here a pension scheme that not only fails to ameliorate risk, but actually adds to it! Nor is there a full discussion of the welfare efficiency implications of either the inter- or intragenerational redistribution patterns. As she herself notes, such a study would be an undertaking worthy of its own separate project. Nonetheless, we can only hope that she, or one of her colleagues in Argentinean economic history, has that on their agenda for the near future.
The second dissertation under consideration was written by Drew Keeling at the University of California at Berkeley. It is titled “The Business of Transatlantic Migration between Europe and the USA, 1900–1914” and was completed under the direction of Gerald Feldman, Jan de Vries, Richard Sutch, and Jon Gjerde. Here we find an old and much traversed topic of economic history, but examined with a totally new approach to the subject.
This too is a study of economic risk, first and foremost: risk on the part of migrants, but also on the part of the shipping companies that carried them, and the governments that authorized, or at least tacitly permitted, the free movement of labor. Only tangentially does this dissertation ask why it was that people migrated, or how they chose where they should migrate to, or whether those migration decisions paid off in material benefits, or how migrants affected labor markets in the places they left, or the places they arrived. In other words, all of the usual questions we tend to associate with studies of migration are not at the forefront here. Yet, this is squarely a study of migration—indeed the literal process of migration, and the business that made it possible.
This broad definition of the problem at hand allows Keeling to set straight the record on all sorts of things that historians of migration as conventionally understood have asserted without proof thus far. For example, it is often asserted that migration levels were particularly sensitive to changes in the transatlantic fare, but Keeling demonstrates that they were not. Rather they were very sensitive to changes in the American labor market, and for repeat voyages anyway, to the conditions of passage on the steamships themselves. Moreover, the specific timing of migration might be very sensitive to economic conditions for employment in the United States, while the overall demand for migration services was rather steadier. But for the shipping companies, timing was everything, given their very high fixed costs for capacity, schedule maintenance, fuel, and crew employment. The rise of second-class tickets and accommodations, and the differentiation in steerage between closed- and open-berth accommodations, both worked to diversify risk for the shipping companies. It gave them flexibility to switch their capacity (not between people and freight as is so commonly assumed but did not in fact happen as Keeling shows definitively). Instead companies could switch business between tourists and migrants, or between the westbound poor, huddled masses and eastbound returnees, either having made something of themselves, or fleeing employment recession. Finally, the improvements in conditions represented by these additions were not driven by government regulation, but by incentives on the part of the shipping companies themselves to induce repeat customers and to give themselves more flexibility to respond to times of revenue crises. Keeling's careful reconstruction of the direction and timing of migrant passages allows him to tease out nuances in the decision-making process that have been obscured until now. Moreover, he takes seriously for the first time, the actual business of moving people for its own sake.
Nonetheless, he could say more about the myriad ways that risk could be diversified. For example, he only touches briefly on how the migration chain of family/friend networks could mitigate risk. His econometric analysis of pricing schemes, particularly those permitted by class differentiation, could also have been more comprehensive. Perhaps the pricing structure had a somewhat accidental character to it (as in the undesirable fare wars, which emerged from time to time), but his analysis should not carry too much of that same sense of accidentalness. Finally, I wanted to know more about how the episode of the Titanic actually impacted pricing—not just safety regulations and advertising.
The final dissertation under consideration is that written by Alessandro Nuvolari, titled, “The Making of Steam Power Technology: A Study of Technical Change During the British Industrial Revolution.” It was written at the Eindhoven University of Technology, the Netherlands.
This project is somewhat unusual in its inclusion here with more standard works of economic history, both for coming out of a technical university and for its sophisticated eighteenth-century engineering content. (I for one have finally learned how a simple steam engine actually works.) But this project is much more than just a technical history of engineering development. Indeed, it is fundamentally about the economics of technical diffusion. And if one does not understand the technical differences between alternative engine types, it is not possible to properly understand the economic forces that spread those engine types in different directions and with different timings.
At its most basic formulation, Nuvolari argues that we cannot simply chart engine developments from lesser prototypes to better ones. Rather, different types of engines used more or less coal for the same power, were easier or harder to repair on site, were better for pumping or better for rotary movement, etc. There is no one process of the diffusion of improved technology then, but rather extensive regional and industrial variation of what constitutes best practice. The latter can thus only be assessed in its immediate context. Econometric “adoption” equations reveal that proximity to coal mines, the price of coal, the alternate availability of water power, and previous technical experience with steam engines all impacted significantly the timing, shape, and direction of the diffusion process.
Nuvolari also offers us an alternative reading of the inducements to technical innovation from the increasingly standard view that secure property rights were critical to this process. He argues instead for the inclusion of something he calls “collective invention settings,” which stress the historical significance of anonymous incremental technical advances. His close reading of the Cornish monthly publication Lean's Engine Reporter allows him to trace in quantitative detail the evolution of a particular technology, as well as the activities of the engineers responsible for it. There can be little doubt that “learning from others” was a critical part of the drive to technical advance.
This observation, while compelling on its own terms, is not ultimately reintegrated into a discussion of the by now very mature intellectual property rights literature. In particular, how might we understand the forces of “learning from others” and the desire to protect one's own ideas working together, or at least simultaneously? This is a question of endless timely import. We ask it all the time in our own universities and research centers. How can we benefit from collaboration and stimulate individual effort at the same time?
If these three young scholars of great promise put their minds to such fundamental questions, our profession, and indeed all intellectual endeavor, will be the richer for it.
