South Korea has been widely described as the “most wired nation on the planet,” with over 95 percent of its households having “high-speed” or broadband access. With more than 23,000 PC-bangs (Internet cafes) scattered across the peninsula to “Starcraft II” advertisements plastered on the sides of all Korean Airlines jumbo 747 planes, computer gaming has become a national obsession in the past decade and an industry worth billions of dollars. The popularity of MMORG (Massively Multiplayer Online Role-Playing Game) games such as “Lineage” and “Starcraft” have also given rise to a new youth culture and a rapidly growing pastime in eSports, a professional gaming league sponsored by major corporations and televised on two cable television channels, five Internet protocol (IP) television sites, and two web portals. NCsoft, the creator of “Lineage” and the nation's most successful developer and publisher has been at the forefront of the online gaming industry, making South Korea one of the largest and most viable gaming markets in the world today. These are remarkable statistics given that Korea was a latecomer to the Internet revolution with broadband services first being introduced only in 1998. Dal Yong Jin has written an engaging study that examines this cultural phenomenon. More specifically, Jin provides the first full exploration of the online game industry in Korea and how it became “a primary sociocultural force in changing Korean society and the communication sector” (p. 5).
The book is divided into three parts consisting of eight chapters, supplemented by a comprehensive bibliography. Part One examines the political economy of the online game industry. Part Two covers the gaming culture and the digital economy. The analysis in Part Three turns to globalization and the gaming empire. To understand the development of the gaming industry in Korea, Jin employs a critical political economy approach, which he argues will provide a more comprehensive picture. In contrast to the existing literature, which focuses primarily on cultural perspectives, the author examines both macro factors such as the interplay between the government and the media and “its ongoing reconfiguration” and emerging areas such as professional game players, online fandom, neoliberal globalization, broadcasting, and “audience commodities” (pp. 6–7).
In the second chapter, “Sociocultural Interpretations of Digital Korea,” Jin examines the shifting political economy of South Korea starting with the 1997 IMF-economic crisis and its move away from traditional heavy and chemical industries towards an IT-driven economy. Although government-led initiatives played a key role in reconfiguring the media landscape, the author shows that the explosive growth of broadband services could not have been possible without the active participation and acceptance of this new technology by Korean society, which is well-known for its impulsiveness and keen consciousness “of the need not to be left behind by others” (pp. 27–28).
Chapter 3, “Political Economy of the Korean Online Game Industry,” addresses the rapid growth of the online gaming industry. More specifically, the author examines government policies, ownership patterns, market structures, and other complex processes in creating a game. In particular, Jin pays special attention to NCsoft, the largest Korean online game developer and publisher, and how it was able to outperform other global companies like EA, Blizzard Entertainment, Sony, and Shanda (China). The author also reminds us that because of Japan's colonization of Korea and a fear of a “cultural invasion,” the government banned Japanese cultural products such as console games until 1998, which could explain the preference for RPG (role-play games) rather than first-person games.
Chapter 4,“eSports and Television Business in the Digital Economy,” addresses the emergence of eSports and how it became a cultural phenomenon in Korea. Here too, the author focuses on government nurturance of the software industry and the role of media, in particular broadcasting in the growth of eSports. It is through this “convergence” of culture, media, and sports across multiple media platforms that a “new business strategy” emerged as companies joined the eSports bandwagon to enhance their profits (p. 61).
Chapters 5 and 6, “Professional Online Game Players as New Media Workers” and “Online Game Fans: New Audience Commodities in the New Media Era?” offer an important reading of pro game players and fans, who are unique to Korea. The author effectively employs a political economy approach to examine the “demographical characteristics of pro gamers as a labor force” as well as the role of game fans as consumers. Unlike celebrities in the film and music industries, pro gamers “cannot read and think about what fans want in the midst of their games” and can only “work for corporate interests.” Likewise, fan club members invest serious amounts of their time updating websites and chat forums, which have been “turned into the commodification process, because corporations and advertising agencies utilize fans' efforts and time for profit” (p. 110).
In an insightful chapter on the local online games and the shifting trends of globalization, the author makes a number of interesting observations on “Lineage,” an MMORG game released in 1998–2003. Notably, Jin argues persuasively how NCsoft, a local online game industry, was able to produce a global phenomenon by identifying the conditions that had “rendered contra-flow in culture possible” (p. 124). As Jin aptly notes, there is more we can learn from the business motto of Viacom and Disney, “Think global, act local,” particularly in “Lineage,” which creatively combined a global RPG storyline “with a local mentality” (p. 131).
The final chapter, “From the Cottage Industry to Transnational Media Giants,” sheds new light on how Korea's local online game industry has become global. The author contends that while these emerging firms in non-Western countries like Korea have somewhat blurred the boundaries and perhaps put a dent in the West's dominance, “the end product and ultimate goal for transnationalization is the production of the game” that will be played in both East and West (p. 157). Despite this two-way transnationalization, the “convergence” of content, media, and capital with Western-based online game companies will continue to remain powerful, making markets and technological systems in the non-West even more dependent and integrated.
Among the book's strengths is the author's attentiveness to a political economy approach, which provides an excellent framework to understand the new economic and cultural policies initiated by the South Korean government in 1997, and how it helped develop a vibrant online gaming industry. In addition, Jin addresses a number of other important issues related to culture, especially the relationship between the Internet and Korean society. On the topic of “edutainment,” for example, the author shows how social factors such as the “Korean me-too culture” (e.g., the fear of being left behind by others) became “the drivers” in luring the masses to adopt broadband services. Other welcome aspects are the book's coverage of eSports and its gendered nature—the professional identities of pro gamers are mostly male while the fan base is predominantly female. Finally, anyone wishing to know more about history of “Lineage” and other MMORG games will not be disappointed. The author does provide his readers with a most generous abundance of information on the gaming industry, and the bibliography is quite detailed and useful.
If the book has any shortcomings, the first is that there is no discussion about the psychological effects of games. Despite the financial subsidies and legal incentives by the government, which has been critical in developing the online gaming industry, a recent study estimates that South Korea has more than two million web addicts. The government has attempted to enforce a “Cinderella” law that would ban children from playing games after midnight. The author may have wanted to delve deeper into these “unintended results” of online gaming, such as addiction. Second, it is puzzling that the author shies away from a discussion of the connection between escapist entertainment and the economic recession. This limitation is perhaps best illustrated in his discussion of the PC-bang as one of the main cogs in South Korea's Internet industry. While this fits perfectly into the political economy analysis, he neglects to discuss the PC-bang and the creation of the “p'yein” [rejects] who troll websites like “DC Inside” or play Starcraft all day. Perhaps if the author had also included an anthropological or sociological approach, the reader would also have gotten a more thorough description of these new social spaces and the people who inhabit them. Last but not least, the author could also have examined the role of nationalism and soft power in the post-IMF era in South Korea. Although there is some discussion about the banning of Japanese cultural products, a discussion on nationalism is quite limited. For example, when Microsoft tried to take over Ah Rae Ah Hangul, the backlash was quite intense as grassroots movements and private corporations joined forces to save the local industry out of fear that a “foreign” company would control the primary means for representing han'gŭl on computers. In other words, did the state utilize nationalist discourse in globalizing online gaming?
Notwithstanding these minor issues, this is an accessible and timely book. It is important to our understanding of how Koreans over a relatively short period of time became the most wired nation in the world as well as a pioneer in software development and eSports. It is carefully researched and presented and makes an important contribution to a growing body of scholarship on media studies, globalization, and transnationalism. It will also appeal to general readers and students alike who will appreciate its boldness and learn from its many insights.
