Robert D. Lee's book Religion and Politics in the Middle East is an ambitious project that establishes a broad comparative framework investigating the potentials and limits of the politics of religion in the contemporary Middle East. Beyond clichés and alarmist doomsday scenarios about irrational religious actors in Middle Eastern politics, Lee's pragmatic and convincing assessment stresses the contingencies and pragmatic requirements of day-to-day politics that have forced religious actors in Middle Eastern societies to adapt to the demands of the political arena.
The great quality of the book is its comprehensively comparative approach. The author goes through meticulous individual case studies of Egypt, Israel, Turkey, and Iran. It is obviously not Lee's fault that some of the assessments of this 2010 book are somewhat outdated in light of the transformations of the so-called “Arab Spring.” From a different perspective though, questions about the role of the Muslim Brotherhood in a future Egyptian system of government, for example, remain quite similar to what they were before Mubarak's fall.
Lee's central argument is that the integration of religion into politics has transformed the public role of religion more than religious movements—in spite of their growing influence since the 1970s—have transformed the way politics is done in Middle Eastern states. The liberalization of party politics in Turkey after World War II, for example, led to a stronger role for religion in the public sphere because individual liberties pushed religious values into the public arena. In fact, he argues, they had never ceased to be of central importance for citizens of modern Turkey in spite of Atatürk's efforts to ban all but state-sponsored religious institutions. The ban on Sufi practices only politicized the religious orders because it turned celebrations of communal spirituality into acts of dissidence. Liberalization then produced an initially volatile, but in the long run remarkably stable, balance between the state and religious institutions. In exchange for new possibilities of participation, religious organizations had to endorse the republic.
To a certain extent, developments in Egypt since Anwar Sadat's assumption of the presidency are comparable to the Turkish case—particularly the emergence of a religiously oriented political mainstream that has entered into a fragile coexistence with the state. Lee argues that the state has been trying to create a malleable form of Islam ever since the times of Mehmet Ali Pasha. The crucial difference in the Egyptian example when compared to Turkey, however, is that authoritarianism and the denial of official political participation to religious actors have created lingering instability that has produced periodical outbreaks of violence.
The Israeli case is complex because of the absence of clear constitutional rules regulating the relationship between the state and religious institutions. The author introduces Israel as not essentially different from other Middle Eastern states in struggling to balance religious and secular elements in the political system. For Lee, Israel is not simply an extension of the political West, the often-cited “only true democracy” of the Middle East, but a country with deep social rifts between moderate and radical groups characteristic of other countries such as Turkey and Egypt as well. As a case in point, Lee presents the mutual recognition of the secular Zionist political establishment on the one hand and the orthodox religious establishment on the other as a foundational principle of the state. Initially, this principle worked at the expense of reformed Jewish communities. The emergence of new religious parties in Israel during the 1970s challenged the stability of this deal, however, and participation in the political process has led once more to religious extremists’ tenuous acceptance of state institutions. What is missing in this equation, though, is the extremely volatile position of the Palestinians, as citizens or inhabitants of the Occupied Territories, who are exposed to various degrees of anti-Islamic hostility by the state.
With regard to Iran, Lee points to the contradiction between the religious ethos of the state and the secular constitutional order that regulates its internal affairs. The very fact that there is a constitution puts into question basic principles of Shiʿi jurisprudence. The precarious balance between the religious legitimacy and the worldly structures of the Islamic Republic initially largely depended on Ruhollah Khomeini's charisma. Ever since, political processes and the structures of the clerical state have been under the constant scrutiny of dissident factions of the clerical establishment, a fact that has the potential to delegitimize the regime. This criticism is all the more fundamental because the regime claims infallibility for the supreme leader and the top clerical institutions and thus refuses to share responsibility in the political sphere with the opposition. The vulnerability of the regime is a function of the need for pragmatic decision making in government affairs, which threatens the basic legitimacy of the state. Recent tensions and the flaring up of severe ideological conflict in Iran are at least partly due to this dilemma.
Although many of these assessments might not seem original to the reader, it is nevertheless useful to have them all next to each other in a rigid comparative framework. The downside of comprehensiveness is, however, superficiality. On several occasions, the author introduces major concepts in a mere couple of sentences without offering evidence and contextualization. There are very few illustrative accounts, stories, or anecdotes that would enhance the readability of the text. The rigorous structure of the case studies, testing the impact of religion in politics on identity, ideology, institutions, and political culture one by one, seems to force the author into repetitions and redundancies. This strict categorization is more a scaffold than a flexible reference system, and its added value is not always clear. The target audience for the book is, hence, hard to pinpoint. For an introductory textbook, there is too little basic information in the various case studies. A specialist readership, in contrast, would ask for more original information or assessments.
