The Oxford Handbook of Contemporary Phenomenology is a testament to how widespread and versatile studies in phenomenology are today. Phenomenology originated with Edmund Husserl (1859-1938) and was elaborated on by thinkers throughout France and Germany in the 20th century. Because it inspired theories like existentialism, hermeneutics, deconstructionism, and post-structuralism, phenomenology is often considered to be the foundation of much of the contemporary Continental Philosophy. Phenomenology has also made important contributions to the fields of sociology, anthropology, psychology, and psychiatry.
The volume is organized and introduced by Dan Zahavi (Professor of Philosophy at the University of Copenhagen, Director of the Center for Subjectivity Research, and co-editor-in-chief of the journal Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences). Phenomenology is a way of doing philosophy; therefore, the articles are not unified by their subject matter, but rather by their methodological approach. As such, the Handbook deals with a number of topics from different philosophical fields such as epistemology, philosophy of mind, action theory, aesthetics, and socio-political philosophy.
The Handbook is divided into seven parts, each of which contains between three and seven essays. The topics of these parts are: “Subjectivity and Nature,” “Intentionality, Perception, and Embodiment,” “Self and Consciousness,” “Language, Thinking, and Knowledge,” “Ethics, Politics, and Sociality,” “Time and History,” and “Art and Religion.” All essays are uniform in length, well-organized, clearly written, and accessible to non-specialists.
Some of the issues the Handbook takes up are: the kind of contributions phenomenology can make to scientific fields such as neuroscience, cognitive science, and psychology; phenomenological accounts of embodiment as fundamental to our experience of sex and gender; the importance of hermeneutics in phenomenology; whether our perceptual experiences can function as empirical facts on the basis of which we can come to know things; a phenomenological approach to history and the experience of time; a phenomenological approach to aesthetic experience. Zahavi himself contributed an article on the nature of shame as a “a self-other-conscious emotion,” by which he means that shame makes us conscious of the attitude of others towards oneself which, as he points out, contributes to the formation and development of one’s sense of self.
The broad selection of contributors will allow readers to acquaint themselves with some of the important voices of phenomenology today. In the introduction, Zahavi stresses the importance of including prominent phenomenologists from Germany, Brussels, and France who greatly contributed to the field in the past decade but who are less known in the Anglophone world. Other contributors are also established scholars from several countries in Europe, as well as Japan, and the USA. I was surprised to find a considerable number of analytical contributions, since phenomenology is most commonly associated with thinkers who write within the tradition of Continental Philosophy.
As its title indicates, the Handbook deals with contemporary phenomenology. In the introduction, Zahavi emphasizes that the goal of the anthology is not to focus in depth on the historical figures of phenomenology, but to include current authors who develop their own theoretical perspectives. But, appropriately, most of the articles still reference classical works in the tradition, citing such thinkers as Merleau-Ponty, Sartre, Heidegger, and especially Husserl. Those interested in the passages with historical references specifically will find the index of the handbook especially useful.
Each article strikes a good balance between being informative and offering original contributions to phenomenology. Since most contributors reference historical figures and offer a preliminary discussion of phenomenology, the Handbook is a good survey account of the field for beginners. On the other hand, the fact that the contributors focus on the current issues in phenomenology will appeal to those who are already actively engaged in research in this area.
Each contributor gives a detailed and accessible overview of the area of philosophy on which he or she is writing, so the Handbook offers a lot of insight into issues in different philosophical fields. The overarching theme is, of course, the importance of the phenomenological approach to philosophical questions and the contributors show the prevalence of phenomenology in their respective areas. Readers will learn a lot about phenomenology as well as about issues in different areas of philosophy. The Handbook is a good reference book, because readers can search for contributions based on the subject area.
I would recommend this book to anyone looking for references to phenomenology, regardless of philosophical field in which they are writing—be it philosophy of religion, aesthetics, gender studies, philosophy of mind, or epistemology. The Handbook does not have to be read in its entirety—the grouping of the articles under topics makes it easy to find the contributions in which the reader is interested. The bibliography and references are also very useful, especially for those who are interested in current debates.
The handbook is rather expensive, which is not something most students can afford. However, this is definitely a book to pick up at the library because it provides a wealth of resources for any research project in phenomenology for both students and seasoned researches alike.
