Poughkeepsie, a county seat, lies halfway between New York City and Albany on the east bank of the Hudson River. Its population topped out at close to 40,000 in 1950 and has recently struggled to regain the 30,000 mark. Data such as these can be gleaned, though with some effort, from the book under review. But to make sense of the numbers, and of the city's history generally, one must realize, as the book notes, that a distinct entity, the town of Poughkeepsie, surrounds the city on three sides. Despite earlier efforts at annexation, the two have remained separate, even as the town overtook the city in size and wealth. Interestingly, all three of the area's institutions of higher education are located in the town, not the city. The latter is the subject of the book.
The early history of Poughkeepsie is not very different from that of a hundred small American cities. It was somewhat distinctive in lying along a major river and on the fringe of the largest metro area in the nation, with the result that a surprising number and variety of immigrants moved and resided there. Those who see immigration and minority migration chiefly as issues for big cities can take note. Even today, Poughkeepsie has a larger minority share than New York City and by one account as many as 25 percent Latinos (mainly Mexican). Of course, undocumented migrants keep the official tally for the latter at only 11 percent in 2000.
Another trait that may make the city an outlier is its long-standing and steadfast conservatism. It always proved difficult for outsiders to gain a footing, be they minorities, immigrants, labor unions, or women seeking a voice in public affairs. Nor did the city and county ever support their favorite son, despite FDR's efforts as state legislator, governor, and president to shower favors on them.
Although the book is full of concrete detail and human stories, it rightly centers on the principal local economic episode of the twentieth century, the arrival—and then near-departure—of a dominant employer. Ironically, IBM never located to any significant degree within the city limits. From the start in the 1940s, it favored suburban and exurban sites. Thus, while giving the region a considerable impetus, IBM accelerated and reinforced the near-universal centrifugal forces already acting on urban areas. The shift of business and middle-class housing from the center and south side of the city to the southern suburbs was radical. Again in contrast to the Rust Belt pattern, in which dominant employers and industries brought prosperity and took it away when they left, the strong downsizing of IBM's presence in the 1990s proved a sharp but relatively short-lived shock. The region recovered, and even the city began a turnaround.
This is social rather than economic history, so that one does not expect models and rigorous hypothesis testing. However, the book might have gained from drawing on such framing concepts as the economic base—exports that pay for necessary imports—and central place theory to track the city's evolution. In particular, the post-IBM recovery is dealt with rather sketchily. What remained of the company became less self-sufficient and bought from local firms, even as skilled and educated ex-staffers began other technically oriented businesses. The region also turned to tourism for revenue, while more “downstaters” established principal or alternate residence there. Nonetheless, the effects seem greater than is accounted for here.
Another theme that receives considerable emphasis, of course, is the continuing effort to solve urban problems, first associated with growth and then with decay. An alphabet soup of organizations and schemes makes for dull reading and testifies to the futility of most such attempts. In the years of decline, especially, the solutions that were implemented proved almost invariably unfortunate, if not worse than the ills themselves. Arterial roads cut through the urban fabric; the malling of Main Street substituted insecurity and inactivity for the congestion it was meant to cure; and the messy vitality of ethnic neighborhoods was “renewed” out of existence. In short, Poughkeepsie's problems did not stem from inattention or even inadequate resources in the public sphere, but rather from the pull of the emerging fringe with its workplaces, shopping centers, and neat housing developments. On the other hand, the larger Mid-Hudson Valley region has continued to prosper despite little success in planning and inherently difficult connections. Certainly, the city of Poughkeepsie has not emerged as a capital that might serve to integrate the region.
Finally, while I welcome an emphasis on space that is all too rare in American social science, it should have been supported by more and better maps than are offered here. Is the fine old practice of endpaper maps beyond the capacity of today's publishers?
