Law in the Pursuit of Development is meant to be a beginning rather than a conclusion, and in that mission it is a success. The goal stated in the Foreword, that the book “will go some way towards supporting a network of scholars whose efforts can help to craft new solutions linking principles and practice in ways that facilitate law's ongoing pursuit of development” (p. xx), is well met by the varied subjects covered therein. It casts a broad net and seeks to make specialist topics “accessible to law and development generalists” (p. 1). The only downside to the editor's approach is that it may go too far in simplifying its content for a well-informed target audience.
The piece begins by presenting a theoretical general approach to political consumerism as an engine of positive activism; then, in the next chapter, it critiques the failing of the internationalization of Kenyan agriculture to empower women workers. This is the sink-or-swim aspect of the book that makes it interesting overall: the author's focus may stay steady within a chapter, but the perspective and scope of the whole changes with dizzying speed between each author's contribution. The next chapter goes on to assess the impact of the spread of Intellectual Property Law on the global poor and sick. It unsurprisingly shows that while law could be read more broadly to protect public health, there is still a large gap between companies’ assertion of rights and poorer people's ability to get waivers of copyrights that are costing them their lives. The authors’ brisk assessments of contemporary problems serve to showcase not only the specialist's knowledge, but also issues that readers across a broad base of cultures and legal training should appreciate.
Another positive aspect of this book is that the contributors include practitioners who see the development discourse from different angles, which seem to converge beyond the horizon of any of the individual chapters. In this way the pieces by Nanwani (on accountability mechanisms in multilateral development banks), Hammergren (on how it is wrong to blame multilateral development banks for all pro-business development woes, as the banks are not actually competent to do what they set out to do), and McAuslan (delivering a stinging rebuke of the Afghani government's attempt to administer a complicated and shabby land law while rebuilding the country in times of war) are very welcome; they serve to break up what could be an unbroken series of academic monologues divorced from applicability in the current day. They give the book the feeling of a dialogue rather than a series of isolated monologues.
But the book does fail to deliver on actual analysis at several key turns. At times it reads as if the authors got ahead of their editor. This is the case in the sixth chapter on environmental legislation in India. In what is a well-presented account of the negative roll-back of environmental protection over the years, the authors title a section “Solutions”, giving the already disheartened reader a chance to hope the chapter will pick up. No such luck: the section, despite its title, offers no solutions but continues its ad nauseum lists of despicable environmental harms occurring today under the gaze of indifferent regulators. This is one of several chapters that do not offer much analysis, though it covers considerable history and in some ways clarifies the complicated past of the law. The same can be said of a chapter given by the book's series editor, Faundez. His piece on the evolution of the World Bank's legal reform work is a collection of dozens of lists, bare of analysis, which serves as background to the more biting chapters in the book. While this may have been the intention of the editor—allowing accomplished authors to provide the backdrop for cutting-edge work by up-and-coming writers—it should have been forewarned somehow, because as presented one expects each writer to contribute something more than an under-cited rehashing of other people's now outdated opinions.
Finally, it bears repeating that the editor, Amanda Perry-Kessaris, noted at the beginning of her work that there is an “absence of a shared analytical framework, a set of reference points” (p. 3), for the law and development field. She edited this book cognizant of this failing and only sought to link the chapters of the piece around five general concepts in her opening chapter. This fell short of the goal of making the whole of the book available to generalists. That is to say, there are so many distinct voices going in so many different directions that whatever is tying them together is not easily perceived by anyone but the editor. This is why it is difficult to showcase the whole book here—it is really not one whole to be recommended or critiqued together.
It would be surprising if there is one legally trained reader out there who would avidly follow every chapter in this collection, but by the same token it is likely that any of us interested in law and development issues will find many useful resources and presentations in this timely and thought-provoking book. It is not a capstone piece for a field, not a place where divergent thoughts converge elegantly, but it is an excellent beginning for those who want to know more about law and development in current times.
