In Patients of the State Javier Auyero fruitfully revisits some of his previous ethnographic studies of poor people's politics to reveal the role of ‘time, its veiling and its manipulation’ (p. 2) in the reproduction of political subordination. Auyero's willingness to rethink his past work in the light of a new insight, that ‘domination works, we contend, through yielding to the power of others; and it is experienced as waiting time: waiting hopefully and then frustratedly for others to make decisions’ (p. 4) enriches his earlier work and gives a new dimension, what he calls ‘tempography’, to their analysis. So that Patients of the State is a continuation of his research into political domination, as he states, he simultaneously provides an example of applying the benefits of hindsight to empirical material that yields new insights with new questions.
In the introduction he provides a succinct review of the literature on the variety of ways ‘the state’ has been theorised as relational practices and cultural processes that make visible what would otherwise be an abstraction (p. 5). Auyero focuses on what he calls the ‘level of state practice’ (p. 6), the micro-level institutions and interactions encountered by poor people that shape their expectations and place within the political process. He examines how the mundane nature of waiting at an office, being told to try elsewhere, to come back another time, can be ‘constructed as an extraordinary sociological object that places subjects’ experiences of rights and power at the center [sic] of inquiry’ (p. 8).
The empirical body of the book consists of three ethnographic chapters. In the first poor people wait to get identification documents; in the second we meet mostly women in a welfare office and in the third we follow the attempts at relocation of settlers in a toxic industrial hinterland, Flammable. In the introductory chapters and in the final ethnographic site Auyero is able to return and re-examine past fieldwork, incorporating the layer of time to his previous knowledge of the lives of residents. The effect is a welcome revelation of the partiality of what we observe and consider, and how looking again with new questions can add depth and heft to a study.
However, Auyero does more than provide vivid examples of poor people's waiting. The first chapter draws on literary works and social science writing to do a broad sweep of perspectives on waiting. He then goes on to sketch the social conditions present in Argentina and the ways in which poor people are regulated by state interventions. Here, and throughout the book, he combines diverse data on people waiting, taken from human rights reports, news stories and a variety of other sources to complement the interviews and observations presented.
The variety of sources do come together in spite of their disparity, in part because waiting is novel territory for sociology and all perspectives open up possible research questions. The reflexivity of the fieldwork, reviewing past ethnographic notes for references to waiting, are echoed in the search for theory, where the waiting of the urban poor is a starting point to ask how it is normalised and taken for granted, giving us new ways of seeing an all too familiar sight. The focus on the relational possibilities of the encounters between the urban poor and state representatives allows Auyero to show the effects of ‘just’ waiting, in contexts where outcomes are arbitrary and uncertain and where being made to wait shows the disregard that poor people are subjected to. Looking at behaviours brings to life the quality of citizenship that can be observed in the daily activities of waiting and underline the responses elicited from differing categories of citizen.
The title of the book is slightly misleading, even though Auyero takes pains to reveal the etymology of the word ‘patient’ as ‘to suffer, to endure’ (p. 9). His proposal that the ‘urban poor […] learn to be patients of the state’ (ibid.) makes an association with a medical setting that is not borne out in the book; although a similar study could easily be made in the public hospitals of Argentina. We are shown how the process of waiting for authority to give or withhold support produces power, but it is not clear why it would produce patients, rather than resigned and patient citizens. The mechanics of waiting shown by Auyero force people into stoical and submissive behaviours in order to achieve their goals; the term that came to mind reading the accounts of long lines and dirty waiting rooms was supplicants rather than patients. The state instances described do not offer a ‘cure’, or even to diagnose the problems people bring, but only to give a token of aid in response to citizens' meek perseverance.
Stretching the term ‘patient’ to describe the subjects of the book draws attention to the fact that we find out little about them beyond how they prove the theoretical point of the meanings of waiting. We are given only glimpses of how they themselves understand their waiting, and the choices they make to be patient and ‘wait wait wait’. The book would be enriched by more material from the fieldwork cases. How do informants contextualise their own waiting? How do they understand subordination and what does their action of waiting mean for them? What prompts them to be good ‘patients’? Can we know anything of the counterfactual of those who will not or cannot spend days in line in government offices?
The subtitle of the book, The Politics of Waiting in Argentina, best captures its originality and resonance. Auyero himself points to the dearth of social science writing on waiting, compared to the extensive literature on time and power. The references to literary works that have used waiting as a dramatic device and have exposed what can be held in the time of waiting when nothing seems to happen are interesting, and could have been more extensive. Patients of the State shines in providing empirical evidence in support of the importance of waiting for understanding the ways in which power and domination are played out in practice in the relations between the urban poor and the front-line bureaucrats of the state. The book provides a good summary of the canonical literature on regulating the poor, including both welfare and the punitive methods used by the state, as well as illuminating digressions into related subjects. As such it intertwines its original insights with the wider literature on domination and the daily construction of power, making it a useful text for scholars and students alike.
