No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 September 2004
Robert Gudmestad draws upon a rich archival collection of newspapers, speeches, letters, journals, account books, land records, sermons, minutes of municipal meetings, and the like to put together an engaging, well-written account of Southern attitudes toward the interstate slave trade and the entrepreneurs engaged in it. The book contains careful scholarship and truly riveting introductions to each chapter. One terrific example (chapter 4) recounts the actions of well-known trader Isaac Franklin when several of his slaves caught cholera while traveling up the Mississippi River from New Orleans. When the slaves died, Franklin secretly buried most of them in ravines surrounding Natchez. Unfortunately for him, a rainstorm washed out the shallow graves. Not surprisingly, the citizens of Natchez were incensed—not because of the treatment of the slaves, but because they themselves were exposed to disease, stench, and unsightly corpses. Although Gudmestad's analysis is more likely to appeal to historians and political scientists than to economists, the descriptions and quotations from primary documents make the book worthwhile reading for anyone interested in the historiography of Southern slavery.
The book consists of eight chapters, divided roughly by region (or interest group) and time period. Chapters two through four focus upon, respectively, Washington, DC, the Upper South, and the Lower South. Chapter five centers on the role of religious leaders and churches. Chapters six and seven are more time-oriented, with the first devoted to what the author sees as a transformative period in Southern attitudes (roughly the first three decades of the 1800s) and the second to the period after that when, according to the author, Southerners largely accepted the slave trade as fundamental to their society.
Gudmestad's basic argument is that most Southerners initially distanced themselves from the slave trade for two reasons: They wanted to distinguish their benevolent, paternalistic motives (even as they bought and sold slaves) from the crass money-making objectives of speculators who engaged in interstate trading. They also recognized that the visible cruelties of the interstate trade—coffles of slaves moving through the national capital, weeping parents separated from their children—offered a large target to abolitionists. Naturally, the traders themselves reacted, working hard to place blame for abuses on a few lowly itinerants. They also changed their methods of moving slaves, going from overland coffles to ship transport. Gudmestad uses various documents to show that, when Northerners continued to attack, Southerners gradually closed ranks, first in the lower and then the upper South, resorting to arguments that the slave trade was an essential element of slavery itself. By the time of the Civil War, Southerners were united in their desire to protect the trade from federal interference, partly because they realized that the unfettered interstate movement of slaves helped expand slaveholders' sphere of influence.
Although the book is a little uneven in commanding the reader's attention, relies on anecdotes rather than statistics, and sometimes makes unsupported, sweeping statements, these are minor flaws. The book is also filled with fascinating details—how the editor of the Baltimore newspaper established a general register office that facilitated purchases and sales of slaves on consignment (p. 78ff), how national church structures disintegrated over the slave trade (p. 143ff), and how notorious traders (and partners) Franklin and Armfield both tried to leave legacies by funding educational institutions (p. 203ff). Armfield succeeded with the University of the South (Sewanee); Franklin's widow failed to carry out his dream of the Isaac Franklin Academy.
Michael Tadman's monumental work, Speculators and Slaves (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1989), still provides the account of the Southern slave trade that offers the best grounding in data and statistics. Gudmestad's book has a different focus, relying more upon rhetorical evidence to support his theories. The two complement each other nicely.