Contributing to an emerging discussion on the value of disability studies in theatre, Kirsty Johnston's Disability Theatre and Modern Drama: Recasting Modernism provides a concise overview of the ways in which disability studies can and should fit into new adaptations and analyses of modern drama, in addition to its effects on theatrical practices. Engaging directly with disability history and with the work of prominent scholars in the field of disability studies as well as recent disability-centric theatrical productions, Johnston posits disability studies as a new framework with which readers can approach theatrical works wherein “othered” bodies may or may not already exist, such as The Threepenny Opera, Endgame, and The Glass Menagerie.
Organized into two parts, the book begins with four chapters—written by Johnston herself—that offer an overview of the history, practices, and current concerns and goals of disability theatre, primarily in the United Kingdom, Canada, and the United States. Chapter 1 encapsulates the overall development of disability theatre, acknowledging that its definition is in fact largely unstable, dependent upon the theatre companies themselves as well as the venues, populations, and communities served and also the localities in which the theatres exist. Although fraught with social stigmas and often obstructed by the damaging rhetoric that has traditionally oppressed people with disabilities, what is sure about disability theatre is that it continues to evolve rapidly as it attempts to reclaim its presence and power via the stage.
Chapters 2 and 3 present different considerations of disability theatre's success in the future. Chapter 2 examines how Western casting practices and actor-training programs have, in fact, been influential in marginalizing people with disabilities. Noting Western society's privileging of abled bodies and of realist aesthetics, Johnston argues that acting programs have primarily focused on the neutral, “normate” (Rosemarie Garland-Thomson's term) body as the end goal of training. As a result, nondisabled actors often conflate characters with the disability that a character has, thereby perpetuating stereotypes of disabled bodies. Instead, Johnston suggests “indexing disability but not reducing character or actor to its fact” (56), which would allow for increased opportunities for both actors and characters with disabilities. Chapter 3 poses technical and architectural considerations that disability-theatre venues must take into account. Aesthetic changes in venues have begun to mirror the push for universal design, creating greater accessibility both backstage and in the front of house. Johnston describes various venues that have challenged ableist environments by adding elements such as open captions, audio descriptions, and even preshow access to production materials for a range of differences that can often prevent patrons with disabilities from attending performances.
In her final chapter, Johnston explores shows recently produced by the UK's Graeae Theatre Company (Blood Wedding and The Threepenny Opera) and Theatre Workshop Scotland (Endgame), all of which prominently featured actors with disabilities in leading roles. Through a critical engagement with Bertolt Brecht's notion of defamiliarization and extensive inclusion of critics’ responses to the performances, Johnston notes not only the presence of disability within the original source materials but also the dynamic interventions being made by theatre companies to create additional layers of meaning otherwise absent in conventional analyses and stagings of the texts.
To engage more fully with the concerns of disability theatre presented in the first half of the book and in accordance with the convention of the Critical Companions series, Johnston offers four additional works by other authors (two essays, an interview, and a play), which engage with disability literature in different ways. The two essays included use the framework of disability studies to (re)read well-known texts by Samuel Beckett and Tennessee Williams. In the first essay, “‘Every Man His Specialty’: Beckett, Disability, and Dependence,” Michael Davidson considers several of Beckett's characters as functioning within ableist society, which paradoxically sees disability as weak and feminine; however, the characters, who have disabilities themselves, challenge the ideology of individualism through their interdependence—or “abject dependency” (111) in Davidson's terms—indicating that the telos of civilization is not actually independence but interdependence, particularly for disabled bodies. Whereas Davidson explores several texts, Ann M. Fox examines a single text in her essay, “Reclaiming the Ordinary Extraordinary Body: Or, the Importance of The Glass Menagerie for Literary Disability Studies.” In light of Laura Wingfield's subject position with regard to the character's disabilities, Fox argues that the treatment of and rhetoric concerning Laura by others in the play only further render her as disabled. Fox asserts that nonnormate casting in Menagerie allows for a more critical, disability-focused understanding of the Wingfield family and of American culture—underscoring yet again the importance of disability studies to the established dramatic canon.
The last two chapters of the book anticipate the future of disability theatre for both practitioners and scholars alike. “Access Aesthetics and Modern Drama” is an interview by Johnston with the artistic director of Graeae Theatre Company, Jenny Sealey. In it, Sealey discusses the company's recent productions of The Threepenny Opera and Blood Wedding in terms of disability and casting practices, in addition to elaborating on the company's upcoming plans and goals. The final chapter of the book comprises the “multi-media performance art piece” (163) Shattering the Glass Menagerie, which was presented at an Association for Theatre in Higher Education conference in 2003 and at a conference at SUNY Buffalo in 2011. Performed by the authors, who are disability scholars themselves—Carrie Sandahl, Terry Galloway, Ben Gunter, and M. Shane Grant—and informed by their own diverse experiences with Menagerie, the play intersperses scenes from Williams's text with metacognitive discussions among the authors, questioning and challenging Menagerie in light of disability activism and queer–crip identity alliances.
Johnston's cultural and historical knowledge about disability history and activism provides readers with noteworthy examples from scholarship and theatre companies that currently engage with the intersection of modern drama and disability studies. In light of growing involvement and interest in disability theatre today, Johnston's book is a crucial resource for theatre scholars and practitioners, both those new to disability studies and those already familiar with its applications, who wish to take part in the complex but promising future that disability theatre has to offer.
