Are the durability, legitimacy, and worth of a democracy better reflected by faithfulness to liberal democratic procedures or by societal outcomes that are seen by most citizens as indicators of governing effectiveness? Larry Diamond and Leonardo Morlino blended these contrasting visions into a multidimensional conceptualization of what constitutes a good democracy (“The Quality of Democracy: An Overview,” Journal of Democracy, 15 [October 2004]: 20–31) when they wrote: “Such a regime will satisfy citizen expectation regarding governance (quality of results); it will allow citizens, associations and communities to enjoy extensive liberty and political equality (quality of content); and it will provide a context in which the whole citizenry can judge the government's performance through mechanisms such as elections, while government institutions hold one another legally and constitutionally accountable as well (procedural quality)” (p. 22).
Two recent edited volumes on Latin America tackle different dimensions of Diamond and Morlino's definition of a good democracy. Daniel Levine and José Molina's The Quality of Democracy in Latin America focuses on what Diamond and Morlino termed “quality of content” and “procedural quality,” while Scott Mainwaring and Timothy Scully's Democratic Governance in Latin America is principally concerned with the “quality of results.” In contrast to most edited volumes, in both of these the editors construct a detailed conceptual framework and then proceed to apply that framework by developing cross-national measures for countries across the entire region. As with most edited volumes, these contributors do not consistently adhere to the precise conceptual and empirical framework espoused by the editors.
Levine and Molina posit five criteria for democratic quality: electoral decision, participation, accountability, responsiveness, and sovereignty. The editors then present empirical metrics via indices in which each criterion's respective dimensions are weighed equally across a standardized 100-point scale. Employing these metrics via 2005 data (p. 33) reveals that Uruguay had the highest level of democratic quality while Guatemala had the lowest score. Costa Rica, Chile, Argentina, Mexico, and Panama had above-average scores while Honduras, Paraguay, El Salvador, Venezuela, Colombia, and Nicaragua had below-average scores.
Rather than focusing on comparative statics, the case studies tend to emphasize patterns of change (and stability) over time in the eight countries examined (Chile, Argentina, Mexico, Brazil, Bolivia, Nicaragua, Colombia, and Venezuela). Several of the country chapters omit one or two of the five criteria emphasized by the editors. In addition, the manner in which these five criteria are discussed varies considerably—both relative to the editors' treatment and in moving from country to country. Perhaps this divergence of perspectives is driven by the differing meaning and relevance of some of these five dimensions as one moves from country to country.
The most evident area of divergence involves the treatment of responsiveness. In the editors' framework, responsiveness is tied to political efficacy, as the editors assert “that those who consider that their vote is efficacious are implicitly recognizing that politicians are responsive to the popular will as expressed in elections” (p. 29). In stark contrast, Leticia M. Ruiz Rodríguez discusses responsiveness in Chile through the lenses of what she sees as the major public policy issues of the day—human rights, macroeconomic policy, and social welfare policy (pp. 52–53). Mark P. Jones and Juan Pablo Micozzi discuss responsiveness in Argentina via examination of expressed levels of satisfaction with democracy (p. 76), an approach that the editors had rejected as excessively linked to one's approval of the government of the day (pp. 29–30). Claudio Holzner details linkages among inequality, participation, and political attitudes as evidence of a still-unresolved debt of democratization in Mexico (pp. 92–105). Alfred Montero's essay on Brazil emphasizes the twin problems of inequality and crime in a similar vein (pp. 128–32). Martín Mendoza-Botelho chronicles how regional, ethnic, and social inequality framed the evolution of political crises, participation, and responsiveness in twenty-first-century Bolivia. Salvador Martí i Puig relates how socioeconomic inequality shaped and was reshaped by economic policy dynamics in Nicaragua (pp. 192–94). Erika Moreno's examination of Colombia emphasizes sovereignty challenges in a manner that makes responsiveness to violence from cartels, guerrillas, and paramilitary forces the highest priority facing the Colombian democracy (pp. 202–4). Valia Pereira Almao and Carmen Pérez Baralt assert that the Chávez government's decision to forge ahead with statutory economic reforms in Venezuela following its defeat in the 2007 constitutional referendum illustrated a lack of responsiveness to the popular will as expressed by that electoral process (pp. 237–38).
These competing visions of responsiveness evoke the evaluative standard used by Potter Stewart in his concurring opinion in Jacobellis v. Ohio [1964]: “I know it when I see it.” Levine and Molina try to devise an efficacy-based metric for responsiveness as a path toward tracking its presence or absence, irrespective of the prevailing issue(s) of the day in each country. Yet when push comes to shove, most of the contributors of the country case studies discuss responsiveness as a creature of one's handling of the issues of the day. Which approach should guide future research? These approaches need not be mutually exclusive. It should be possible to measure political efficacy cross-nationally in a consistent manner while leaving the door open to exploring how major public policy issues influence the course of political efficacy within each country.
Indeed, with policy efforts in mind, Mainwaring and Scully lead a different team of scholars in a consideration of governing effectiveness by democracies. They put forth nine dimensions of governance for examination: level of democracy, rule of law, control of corruption, economic growth, inflation, job creation, poverty, education, and citizen security (pp. 12–13). While the first two dimensions form part of democratic governance narrowly conceived, the other seven are portrayed as challenges faced by all regime types yet central to concerns of Latin American citizens as expressed in contemporary public opinion polls.
The first chapter provides a series of cross-national tables on Latin American outcomes that are ultimately scaled on a metric from 0 (the worst outcome observed worldwide) to 100 (the best outcome observed worldwide); these scales are then combined by the editors into a single, overall index (p. 39). On this index, Chile, Costa Rica, Uruguay, and Panama obtain scores ranging from 85 down to 76; Cuba obtains an 8; Haiti receives an index score of 32; and the other 14 countries in the region range from 44 (Guatemala) up to 69 (Argentina). The editors frame the various thematic chapters in the volume as efforts to understand the diversity of outcomes on several of these issue dimensions, while chapters on Chile, Costa Rica, and Brazil try to explain each country's respective progress on these issues.
José de Gregorio examines the dynamics of economic growth in Latin America from 1960 to 2000, arguing that subpar performance in most of the region is best understood by the greater prevalence of conditions that would be obstacles to growth anywhere—low investment, high fertility, weak institutions, macroeconomic instability, and high inequality. De Gregorio concludes that improvements in macroeconomic stability and institutions during the 1990s in many countries provided the foundation for better economic performance in the early 2000s, as well as grounds for future progress (pp. 80–84). Francisco Rodríguez's examination of research on the Washington Consensus set of reforms is worth the price of this (or any other) book. This examination of the methodological challenges of past research and his proposed solution to those problems deserve a wide audience. In brief, Rodríguez has issued a clarion call for greater attention to the empirical examination of within-country growth dynamics (p. 123). Alejandro Foxley's reflections on what he terms the contemporary “ill-fare state” (p. 136) call for a rejection of a market-driven versus state-driven dichotomy and its replacement by an innovation-centered hybrid set of policies.
Evelyne Huber and John Stephens conclude that Chile, Costa Rica, and Uruguay have the most successful social policy regimes in the region via greater sustained policy effort over time; they argue that this greater policy effort rests on a longer history with democratic politics, compared with that of most other countries in Latin America (pp. 177–79). Daniel Brinks's analysis of rights protection and the rule of law focuses on state sanctions on police violence in Argentina, Brazil, and Uruguay; he identifies a mix of informational and normative challenges that merit greater consideration in other countries in and out of Latin America (pp. 225–32). Patricio Navia and Ignacio Walker assert that populist political dynamics of economic reform emerged where political institutions were weaker (p. 254) and that path dependency thus framed the pursuit of procedural legitimacy, as well as the prospects for outcome-based legitimacy. The authors of the case studies (Alan Angell on Chile, Mitchell Seligson and Juliana Martínez Franzoni on Costa Rica, and Fernando Henrique Cardoso on Brazil) agree that national characteristics are so important that they limit the generalizability of a given country's success; yet each case study (in different ways) emphasizes the role of ideological convergence among political parties as a factor that improved the effectiveness of democratic governance over time.
In a concluding essay, Mainwaring and Scully similarly emphasize the diversity of country experiences, but they also highlight examples of potential for change over time that remind us that path dependence is not determinant in all matters.
Democratic Governance in Latin America is a stimulating, frustrating, and fruitful book. The stimulation surges from the importance of the questions raised and the earnest, detailed examinations provided by these collaborators. The frustrations emerge from the messiness of empirical realities and from the professional circumspection of the contributors. Their respective tendencies to shy away from generalizations often limit the ability of their contributions to delineate even scenario-specific, narrow policy recommendations. In some respects, the editors' concluding essay tries to correct for the caution of the contributors by putting forward several propositions that highlight the importance of state capacity, political parties, and political ingenuity for socioeconomic progress. The editors' useful selection of policy challenges and these contributors' detailed analyses make this a challenging, fruitful read.
In these two recent edited volumes, the editors' explicit multidimensional conceptualizations and cross-national measurements have advanced our understanding of democracy's dynamics in Latin America. Moreover, similar approaches could be usefully applied to the study of democracy elsewhere. The precise policy challenges would not be the same everywhere, but this emphasis on a mix of democratic procedures and socioeconomic concerns could—and should—be productively applied elsewhere.
