The literature on genocide, mass atrocities, and mass killing has vastly expanded in the past two decades to integrate new methodologies, regions, and histories of violence. Mass killing has become the subject of world-systems theory, ethnographic interview, psychological and behaviorist intervention; it has been analyzed as a product of natural drives, strategic and rational choices, and complex historical contingencies. Edward Weisband's The Macabresque contributes to the growth of this literature by highlighting the persistent failure to theorize the dramaturgy and theatricality of mass violence. Put differently, Weisband theorizes the distinctive aesthetics and performativity of sadistic cruelty as a genre of the practice within episodes of mass violence. He approaches this problem through the titular term of “the macabresque,” which describes the spectacular or dramaturgical elements that consistently reappear in cases of intense mass violence. For Weisband, sadism is problematic not solely because it produces pain or death, but also because it creates a place for the perpetrator of violence to experiment with processes of performative self-creation, and find a place within a broader symbolic or political order.
Weisband's book is vast, even tome-like on this point, surveying literature from political science, psychology, history, and cultural studies on the instincts, motives, and mechanisms that incite perpetrators to commit violence. His work highlights the limits and omissions of many of these accounts primarily in relation to the desire that causes perpetrators to engage in human violation. Weisband models his description of this process in conversation with the psychoanalytic tradition. He notes that many participants in mass violence were previously “ordinary people” that were triggered or incited to sadism through their engagement in violent social movements. Weisband also notes that practices of mass violence such as torture and cruelty go far beyond any legible claim regarding the supposed “necessity” of violence. Rather, violence operates as a transgressive and theatrical domain, which contains the possibility of making perpetrators out of otherwise ordinary persons.
For Weisband, this process begins because of a particular confrontation with the desire of the Other. Following the writings of French analyst Jacques Lacan, Weisband contends that the macabresque involves performances for what he terms the big Other. These performances are attempts by the participants to seek after a form of jouissance only possible by performing acts of violence in which the subject carries out the implicit demands of the Other and, by doing so, achieves a measure of symbolic stability. For Weisband, these acts of violence explain the dissonance often experienced that enables paramilitaries and fascist organizations to recruit “ordinary” individuals into participating in violence. Indeed, the excitement and intensity of violence that Weisband describes are indications of the theatrical quality of the macabresque. In Weisband's account violence is thus less instrumental than expressive, defined less by the preexistence of evil intentions than by the exigencies and pressures of an individual's participation in a symbolic or political order. Moreover, perpetrators participating in these processes rarely sense themselves to be the “same” political actors; rather, as Weisband points out, they frequently articulate a sense of disjunction, of acting on behalf of another, that partitions the “ordinary” self from their role in mass violence.
Weisband follows the theme of the macabresque across historical contexts including the tortures of the Khmer Rouge, the violence of the Cultural Revolution, the ideological purges of Stalin, the sadism of Nazi genocide, the intensity of Hutu Nationalism, and the spectacle of violation in the concentration camps of Bosnia. In rich detail, he shows how each setting reproduces the conditions of possibility for the macabresque such that rituals of violation and enemy creation also enable the subject to find a place in the social order. Weisband's study is too historically detailed, too intricately positioned within the history of psychological and psychoanalytical theories, and too precise on the limits of other theories of mass violence, to do justice to these arguments in brief. At times, the sheer volume overwhelms the reader's capacity to cogently track the thesis. Nonetheless, the book offers major insights to scholars of mass violence by illustrating not just how “victims and perpetrators” are identified through social construction, but how performances of violence play a distinctive role in inciting genocide. Weisband's work thus reveals how easy it is for an “ordinary person” to become an agent of mass violence while stressing the limitation of broad historical, structural, comparative, strategic, and rationale explanations to account for the intricate procedures of human violation. Weisband's argument is able to explain how mass violence operates as a kind of laboratory for self and political identification or, put differently, that the act of violation serves as a mechanism for binding violent political organizations together in a way perhaps more powerful than a focus on ideology, strategic choices, or social construction alone can provide.
As with all works that rely heavily on specific theoretical tools, Weisband's remains open to question. The structural dimensions of Lacanian psychoanalysis sometimes overburden the argument and diminish the historical specificities of performances of mass violence. Put differently, are there other means of assembling the desire to participate in the macabresque, which Weisband's psychoanalytic reading neglects? At times, Weisband's argument appears to make assumptions about the deep psycho-symbolic motives behind acts of violation that downplay historical variation across time, culture, and geography. This raises the question whether there are limitations to the explanation of the mechanisms behind mass violence that come from a Eurocentric framework. Interestingly, this problem reappears in the context of the case studies. While Weisband treats many of the most famous cases of mass human violation, there is a curious absence of anti-indigenous violence in the Americas, Australia, and Africa. On the one hand, this may reflect archival challenges that often accompany the study of mass violence. On the other hand, the explanatory power of Weisband's psychoanalytic approach may encounter difficulties when placed outside of a modernist or Western context. Scholars of mass violence also may find Weisband's conclusions difficult to integrate into existing literature that spotlights the emergence and prevention of mass atrocity. Part of the novelty of Weisband's argument is that participation in mass atrocity often, paradoxically, does not preexist the rise of practices of human violation. This offers a major obstacle to the effort to predict and forecast mass violence because many separate theaters of human violation suddenly contain the propensity for the macabresque.
Regardless, Weisband's work offers an exquisitely detailed and thorough engagement with the problem of the motive forces behind the perpetration of mass violence. It brilliantly illustrates how many theories of genocide and mass atrocities omit the performative dimension of these events in favor of leaning on thin explanations of the mechanisms and incentives that allegedly lead perpetrators to their violence. With its expansive treatment of the literature and novel insights into the production of desire in theaters and rituals of violation, The Macabresque is an important work for any scholar of mass violence, torture, and armed conflict.
