Scholarship addressing gender and racial politics in jazz studies expanded prolifically during the first decade of the twenty-first century. In addition to some significant biographies, a number of anthologies have debated how both gender and race have had an impact on who hears, plays, and writes about jazz. However, these conversations have largely been treated as sidebars or have been relegated to the category of special interest within jazz circles. But with the advancement of the theoretical construct of the “New Jazz Studies,” the conversation is becoming more inclusive. Big Ears: Listening for Gender in Jazz Studies reflects this development and will now be added to the list of important works advancing this interdisciplinary approach. That list includes, but is not limited to, Jazz Among the Discourses, Representing Jazz, and Uptown Conversation: The New Jazz Studies.Footnote 1 Whereas these works instigated broad conversations about jazz and how it intersects with issues of representation, Big Ears aspires to not only further the dialogue, but also focus it and challenge those involved and “listening in” to investigate how they have perceived the various representational narratives that jazz invokes and also how they respond to them.
Editors Nichole T. Rustin and Sherrie Tucker have drawn together an eclectic group of contributors whose areas of study stretch across the fields of musicology, popular music studies, American studies, media studies, English, and comparative literature. This combination helps make this an enjoyable and useful compendium that represents diverse theoretical approaches and “readings” of gender in jazz. The editors state in their introduction that the purpose of this book is to advocate for “ear training that can listen for gender in jazz” and to demonstrate how “gender analysis helps [one] to ‘listen differently’ to areas of jazz culture that are otherwise too easily dismissed as ‘outside’” (1–2). At first reading, this would seem like a very lofty purpose, but this collection achieves that goal and much more. One should not assume, however, that this anthology follows the typical “reclamation of the missing female musician” approach that defined the scope of many of the biographies and gender-focused jazz histories published at the turn of the twenty-first century. Although some essays in this volume reflect this type of historical contextualizing, overall Big Ears challenges the reader to interrogate the racialized and sometimes artificially constructed conceptions of femininity and masculinity that have framed jazz's performance history.
The anthology is divided into three major parts. The essays in the first section, “Rooting Gender in Jazz History,” range in topic from the gendered history of vocal performance in early jazz to the relationship between cultural imagination and constructions of masculinity via big band music. The second section, “Improvising Gender: Embodiment and Performance,” includes essays that explore the relationship between black female dancers and jazz and discuss the white female jazz fan's engagement with the music through an analysis of the 1947 film New Orleans, starring Billie Holiday and Louis Armstrong. The last section, “Reimagining Jazz Representations,” includes an interesting study of how racial and gender identity are defined in jam sessions at Leimert Park in Los Angeles, and an intriguing analysis of what the fiction of writers Toni Cade Bambara and Sherley Ann Williams reveal about black women's engagement with jazz as listeners and interpreters of the culture. The final essays of this section analyze representations of jazz and gender in Hollywood films such as That Man of Mine (1946), which featured the all-girl band The International Sweethearts of Rhythm, and the highly influential Young Man with A Horn (1950).
Although I found each of the essays in this book to be intellectually stimulating and engaging, here I highlight some of the analytical and theoretical issues raised in a few of the individual studies. Jeffrey Taylor's “With Lovie and Lil: Rediscovering Two Chicago Pianists of the 1920s” is a much-needed contribution to jazz scholarship. The roles of the pianist/arrangers Lil Hardin Armstrong and Lovie Austin have been ignored by many jazz scholars or relegated to minor references in relation to their work with notable male musicians. Taylor, however, situates these two musicians within the larger performance history of jazz in Chicago during the late 1920s and early 1930s, and does so through an analysis of their solos in selected recordings. His discussion reveals the diversity of performance contexts in which these women participated and the highly developed musical voice that each brought to their recording sessions. Most importantly, Taylor advocates for us to revisit our perceptions of their role in advancing the Chicago jazz and blues styles of the late 1920s and 1930s, to rethink the notion of Hardin and Austin as “interpreters” of the creative ideas of their male counterparts, and instead to “hear” them as “co-creators.”
Monica Hairston's “Gender, Jazz, and the Popular Front” explores the intersection of performance and politics that defined the milieu of the New York nightclub Café Society. Unlike others who have concentrated primarily on the cultural and political history of the nightclub, Hairston discusses how these aspects of the club's culture informed the performance aesthetic, repertory, and reception of pianists Hazel Scott and Mary Lou Williams.Footnote 2 Tracy McMullen's “Identity for Sale: Glenn Miller, Wynton Marsalis, and Cultural Replay in Music” analyzes how historical recreations of the repertory and the ethos of the big band era of the 1940s frame constructs of masculinity and racial identity in the modern jazz scene. McMullen's questioning of how gender, especially femininity, is read within the act of historical recreation is provocative and expands the historical understanding of cultural “passing” beyond the common racial context. Jayna Brown's “From the Point of View of the Pavement: A Geopolitics of Black Dance” is worth noting because of its deconstruction of black dance, especially the Charleston and Lindy Hop, as representative of the trope of modernity and self-actualization in Jazz Age America and Europe. Brown's interrogation of the mythology of democracy as expressed through the shared culture of dance between whites and blacks makes this essay a must read.
Within the existing context of jazz scholarship few works have sought to cross-examine the constructions of femininity, masculinity, and race in the way Big Ears does. One of the many things that this anthology exposes is just how U.S.-centered existing scholarship is on this subject. This anthology offers four strong essays deconstructing how gender and race have framed reception and the performance history of women musicians in Europe. As noted above, Brown's essay seeks to posit the bodies of black female dancers in the global context of pre–World War I and Jazz Age Europe, while Christina Baade, Julie Dawn Smith, and Ursel Schlicht examine how women musicians have negotiated gendered spaces in wartime and post–World War II Europe. I read the essays contained in this anthology with interest, sometimes more than once, and I began to realize how these discussions have informed my own thinking, listening, and teaching. The interdisciplinary nature of this anthology makes it usable in a number of different classroom contexts, and the material is not laden with theoretical jargon, which will make it accessible to undergraduate students and fans of jazz. Nichole Rustin and Sherrie Tucker have advanced the theoretical and musicological conversation about the interrelationship between race, gender, and jazz, and in doing so have made a significant contribution to jazz scholarship as well as to the field of cultural and gender studies. This anthology will undoubtedly influence not only the writing of jazz scholarship and criticism but also frame individual and collective “readings” of past, present, and future musical performances.
