The Accademia del Cimento was founded in 1657 by the brothers Grand Duke Ferdinando II and Prince Leopoldo de’ Medici. For the best part of a decade the academy investigated a range of questions in natural philosophy, with frequent recourse to experimentation. It produced a single printed book with limited circulation, the 1667 Saggi, then immediately collapsed, through a combination of internal and external pressures. The Saggi, it has long been recognized, offers only a partial view of the academy's activities; the Galilean collection in the National Library in Florence contains a large number of the Cimento's documents, which are now all available online via the library's own site and the Digital Library of the Museo Galileo. Other material, such as the Leopoldo section of the Medici holdings of the Florentine State Archives, the Cimento manuscripts in the Bancroft Library at UC Berkeley, various Roman holdings, and the unrivalled collection of instruments housed in the Museo Galileo, has scarcely been noticed. Given these riches, the Academy's historiography has been strangely patchy, and these conference proceedings represent a welcome attempt to lay the groundwork for future research.
Much like the original members of the academy itself, the fifteen contributors here present very different approaches, interests and assumptions about their subject; unlike the academy, whose anonymous Saggi sought to portray an undisputed account of the production of experimental matters of fact, this volume lacks even a fiction of coherence. This is both a strength, in that we see the copiousness of contemporary historiographical positions in action, and, more obviously, a weakness, one which might have been easily rectified by a stronger editorial introduction. The two and a half pages they offer is promising, but inadequate, and a missed opportunity to describe the current state of research and suggest its future directions.
The volume is divided roughly down the middle into a series of thematic accounts detailing the academy's actual practices and interests, followed by a series of comparative studies repositioning the Cimento alongside its European brethren. Frustratingly, no attempt is made, in any article or the introduction, to describe either the history of the Cimento's archives or its historiography. A student seeking initial orientation should consult Luciano Boschiero's recent Experiment and Natural Philosophy in Seventeenth-Century Tuscany: The History of the Accademia del Cimento (2007). Neither is any attempt made to provide even a brief chronological account or biographical sketch: the result is the frequent duplication of basic information and a general sense of overspecialized interventions in opaque debates.
This does not mean that the volume lacks common talking points, but what emerges from the first half of the book is the scarcely suppressed desire that this were actually a conference on Giovanni Alfonso Borelli, rather than the Cimento. The reasons for Borelli's overshadowing of his peers remains, however, unanalysed. The editorial decision to move from ‘inside’ the academy to its ‘contexts’ also presupposes that such a distinction were historiographically tenable: in fact, what emerges is the urgent need to establish a dialogue between these two positions. Many of the contributors manage this, but their efforts are all but negated by the book's prosaic organization.
Despite these editorial shortcomings, several of the essays are excellent: Domenico Bertoloni Meli's imaginative juxtaposition of diverse experiments to uncover the origins of parallel trials should be singled out as a particularly valuable contribution both to the history of the Cimento and to the general history of the philosophy of science. Susana Gómez offers an illuminating discussion of post-Galileian light and the surprising experimental protocols devised around the Cimento to make sense of this troublesome phenomenon. Rob Iliffe's detailed discussion of Henry Oldenburg's complex and tireless attempts to engage Italian natural philosophers (even Jesuits) in conversation with the Royal Society elegantly shows the difficulties of constructing a reliable network in the real world, and works as an excellent case study from which to rethink many idealizing accounts of the Republic of Scientific Letters. Other essays provide valuable correctives to the standard view that the Saggi offered unhindered posthumous access to the Cimento: fields such as chemistry, botany and anatomy, we now know, were intimately connected to the work's better-publicized physics and mathematics. Maria Pia Donato nicely traces the issues plaguing the Cimento to later Roman academies, but this piece would have resonated more deeply alongside a contribution on the Cimento's sense of its own identity and place in the history of science or its full relations with other Italian academies. We get repeated glimpses of scientific activity in Bologna, Naples and Messina, but these are mostly visible when a contributor hunts down an individual academician's non-academic career. This general tendency to assume that the academy's real identity includes the activities of its members before, after and outside the academy not only confuses institutional history with prosopography, but also unfocuses our understanding of the academy.
The volume ends with a spirited contribution by Mordechai Feingold arguing against the applicability of patronage studies to the Cimento, hitherto the paradigmatic example of a patron-centred scientific academy. Ever since Paolo Galluzzi's seminal 1981 essay in Quaderni Storici, Feingold argues, the essential scientific impetus has been wrongly removed from accounts of early modern scientific academies. This seems to misrepresent the valuable contributions of Galluzzi, Findlen, Tribby and Biagioli on the Cimento, none of whom actually occupies the sterile position here ascribed to them, of rendering the academy ‘purely decorative’ (p. 231). Feingold would have us understand the true nature of the Cimento by comparing it to scientific groups in England before their incorporation into the Royal Society, as a way of supposedly removing the issue of patronage from picture. It is true that the early scholarship may have been prematurely reductive in equating Cimento science with Medici courtiership, but the relationship between science and patronage cannot simply be ignored: the Bancroft manuscripts, for example, include two drafts of a list of instruments sent to Pope Alexander VII, ‘because our senses, due to their imperfections, are extremely subject to deception’. Federica Favino's thorough analysis of newly discovered Oliva-Redi material in the Vatican Library shows that the next stage in Cimento studies may well lie in understanding its relationship with power sources outside Florence. The field seems wide open for exciting experimental work on this protean and ephemeral institution and its rather more durable science.
