Keeping up with ‘introduction to Christianity’ literature is a pastime of mine on no megatrend list. Few ever read such a work; still fewer insist on reading another. One reason perhaps is that these works are de facto reintroductions, reaching people long after they have had pleasant or distressing brushes with Christianity and are therefore wary of spoiling or reliving the experience.
This literature endures nonetheless in two social locations: the academic textbook market for religious studies and Christian theological education as well as trade book expeditions into current public discussions of religion. Woodhead attends to both settings.
Let textbook considerations come first. The book's Sitz im Leben is the arena of inclusivist-orientated Protestantism at large and scholarly study of religions. Here, Lancaster University, where Woodhead is Professor of Sociology of Religion, has attained ‘Lancaster school’ repute for au courant yet substantive religious-theological studies. Continuing a trajectory first set in early modern times, the task of ‘introduction to Christianity’ in Christian Studies is to CAT-scan Christianity's length, breadth, depth and complexity in merely x-number words or less, and with malice toward none except in extremis the inexcusably malicious. Today the task also requires attention to postmodern living and thinking, varieties of which Woodhead discusses in mercifully pre-postmodern literary style. She juggles these multiple, often conflictive, demands with considerable aplomb.
The result is a survey of Christian history designed, as Woodhead herself bravely admits, in accord with conventional ecclesiastical history expectations insofar as intellectual integrity permits. She sets a semesterly pace. Part I, ‘The Christian revolution: ascent to power’ provides, in three lengthy chapters with bite-sized subsections, general overviews of early and medieval times. Part II, ‘The modern revolution: compromises with power’, contains four similarly formed chapters leading from the era of reformations to the present day.
Christian diversity is highlighted, as is its global scope, though page-counts in Part II drop from Protestant to Roman Catholic to Eastern churches. The consumer staples of individuals, groups and events are on display here as in quality competing texts. Woodhead writes with admirable clarity, turns a good many fine-tooled phrases, and never lapses into recitations of historical trivia.
What sets her introduction out from the pack is its focus on sociological cum social history concerns. I do not mean that introductory histories of any merit ignore social environs, involvements and effects. On the contrary, social history has long been prominent in advanced church history study and carry-over to introductory texts is commonplace. Yet Woodhead's work is noteworthy because of its quasi-cinematic reversal of conventional background and foreground. Christianity's social relations, namely, ‘how Christian institutions and individuals have understood, articulated and embodied power, and how they have related themselves to political economic, cultural and military power’ (p. 1), occupy the foreground set against a backdrop of standard ecclesiastical history's main movers and movements.
This reversal represents a genre-crossing gambit, from classroom text to ‘interpretative history’. It also takes Woodhead one giant step closer to ‘essence of Christianity’ studies – here, of Troeltsch ancestry – than textbook writers ordinarily venture. Such studies are, in my old-fashioned view, vital to Christianity's well-being. But setting the book in this line, if apt, raises the ante in evaluating it.
Woodhead frames the flux of Christian social relations over two millennia by constructing (or descrying) two competing models of power – ‘power from on high’ and ‘power from below’ – and monitoring ‘consequences of the churches’ tendency to favour the former over the latter' (p. 4). I found this framing of the narrative disconcerting at the outset. The simplicity of the models – ‘power from on high’, a sovereign, hierarchical control over others versus ‘power from below’, an empowerment of each person as a sovereign subject – seems too simplistic for heuristic comfort or windfall profit. And to emplot Christianity's entire history along these lines is a more apocalyptic dramaturgy than postcritical emphases on relationality commend.
Such concerns return now and again as the story unfolds. One need not be a certified rhetorical analyst to predict the Jesus of history to appear here as an exemplary ‘power from below’ person or that the most kindly, glowing words go to ‘radical’ individuals and groups, above all pious Christians of voluntarist, spiritualist temper.
That said, it must also be said – as the dialectic turns – that the Woodhead account is not to be shunted aside, even by those of us too humble or too wizened to thrill at the rhetoric of ‘radicality’. To her credit, Woodhead devotes greatest time and energy to gradations between the polarities. Her forte is dealing with compromised, mixed, muddled and – better still – unintended, even ironic, social relations that Christians form with worldly principalities and powers.
This approach makes hers a more refreshingly candid, nuanced handling of Christian history than most textbooks. The fitful development of orthodoxies and heresies and their polemics in early Christianity represents a case in point. Another is portraiture of so many Christian celebrities in naturalistic, ‘warts and all’ fashion. The entanglement of world missions, colonialism and postcolonialism is a third. Others could follow. Woodhead is never – well, hardly ever – nasty to anyone. She makes no historical claims other than those already in play in scholarly societies of Christian history. As a critical introduction, hers is a select choice.
Finally, this book is of immense practical benefit, even for teachers and graduate students in ‘Christian studies’. It is a welcome update – brief, yet rich and quite reliable – of the current state of social history scholarship in ecclesiastical history's early, medieval, Reformation and modern-postmodern subfields. Exceptional strengths are Woodhead's skill in (re)incorporating women's history into the overall story and her ability to sift through and sort out the last half-century of Christianity's history. I suggest that if ever the need or urge arises to read an ‘introduction to Christianity’, read two instead, making the Woodhead book one of them.
