Zahid Shahab Ahmed's book Regionalism and Regional Security in South Asia: The Role of SAARC is an attempt to study the contours of regionalism and the co-operative framework under SAARC (South Asian Association for Regional Co-operation) to address issues relating to “economic security, environmental security, human welfare, terrorism and transnational crime” (p. 7). The book is divided into nine chapters.
Chapters 1 and 2 trace the common colonial past and the cultural, ethnic, and linguistic similarities of the region, on the basis of which SAARC was established in 1985. Despite the similarities, Ahmed believes that “regional asymmetry is visible through various indicators, such as population, economic growth, area and even military strength of South Asian countries” (p. 14). These two chapters provide a bird's-eye view of the challenges facing the region, namely “intrastate security challenges” and “bilateral conflicts”, which in more ways than one have contributed to the lack of political will in strengthening regional co-operation
Chapter 3 offers an overview of SAARC, especially its development as an organization committed to the all-round welfare of the region. The founding fathers of SAARC rallied around President Zia-ur-Rahman of Bangladesh when they realized that it would not only be a forum to engage the world at large, but also serve as a platform for building stronger co-operation in the region. King Birendra of Nepal shared these views when he commented that the “weakening of the global economic interdependence and the disillusionment with the continuing deadlock in restructuring the international economic order” had “thrust upon us greater responsibilities for collective self-reliance and South-South cooperation on a much larger scale” (p. 33). To this end, SAARC has provided an elaborate legal and institutional framework to implement its mandate in a number of areas of co-operation. However, as Ahmed believes, the organization is hamstrung by severe political, institutional, and economic challenges (pp. 55–60).
In Chapter 4, Ahmed highlights the importance of strengthening economic co-operation in the region through analyzing the SAARC Preferential Trading (SAPTA) and the SAARC Agreement on South Asian Free Trade Area (SAFTA). The ultimate aim of these agreements is to guarantee free movement of goods and people across borders with zero duties and the removal of other trade barriers. However, fears of Indian manufacturing and services sectors’ dominance have deterred Least Developed Countries (LDCs) in SAARC, namely Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, the Maldives, and Nepal, from ratifying these agreements.
Environmental security, dealt with in Chapter 5, is a “key human security threat” (p. 87) and of topical importance. The region suffers from the maladies of development and is threatened by natural disasters, drought, air and water pollution, and ever-increasing deforestation. The single major challenge to the region is the impact of climate change, which enjoins states to undertake sustainable developmental measures. From the reviewer's perspective, India—a major player in climate change negotiations—must take the lead at the global and regional levels, to ensure the transfer of technology and financial resources to the other countries of the region. Why not have a regional SAARC Green Climate Fund to meet the incremental costs incurred by LDCs in undertaking adaptation and mitigation efforts, and to help the Maldives, which is facing an existential threat owing to rising sea levels?
Chapter 6 on “Human Welfare” brings out the overriding challenge of eradicating poverty. In fact, the first objective of the SAARC Charter is to “promote the welfare of the peoples of South Asia and to improve their quality of life”. With thirty-seven percent of the region categorized as “poor” (p. 109), the eradication of poverty, hunger, disease, and malnutrition remain pressing priorities for the governments of the region. While SAARC has created action plans and mechanisms such as the SAARC Development Goals (SDGs), the SAARC Development Fund (SDF), food banks, and the South Asian University (SAU) to impart quality education, these activities do not receive funding adequate to ensure their effectiveness.
Chapter 7 addresses the important challenge of “Co-operation in Security Matters”. SAARC has been home to numerous transnational crimes such as terrorism, money laundering, drug trafficking, the smuggling of small arms and weapons, illegal migration, and human trafficking (p. 133). SAARC has responded by adopting a wide range of legal frameworks and institutional mechanisms to strengthen regional co-operation. However, what is severely lacking is the political will to put in place the institutional mechanisms necessary for their full implementation, such as real-time intelligence sharing, extradition/mutual legal assistance agreements, or, as Ahmed points out, a regional INTERPOL such as SAARCPOL, which “is yet to be approved by SAARC” (p. 152).
Ahmed makes a case for learning lessons from the ASEAN region, especially in areas of political understanding, security co-operation, economic integration, and organizational development (p. 174). He draws some important, but known, conclusions for strengthening regional co-operation, pointing to the “legacy of mistrust” which has constrained the processes of co-operation and peace in the region (p. 175).
Zahid Shahab Ahmed's book is a sincere and honest effort to provide a robust analysis of the challenges faced by SAARC. SAARC has attempted to address various dimensions of human security but implementation has suffered from an “insufficient political commitment to regionalism”, which is manifested in inadequate funding and human resources. The book is a valuable addition to the existing literature on the subject and serves as a useful guide to the role and function of SAARC as a vehicle for guaranteeing regional security and human welfare.
