This book focuses on some of the main incidents and episodes in the politics of the important Brazilian state of São Paulo from the beginning of the Brazilian republic in 1889 to the revolt of São Paulo against the national government in 1932. It includes an immense amount of information from primary sources. I hesitate to call this data ‘evidence’, because that term is usually linked to information arrayed in support of analysis, or an interpretation.
Here there is little evidence of an interpretation, nor of an overall thesis, other than the truism that politics, society, economics, ideologies and institutional structures are connected. The emphasis is on what contemporary participants and observers said about what happened, rather than on the events themselves or how we today might understand them. As one moves through one lengthy but undigested quotation after another (in translations too often littered with false cognates and overly literal word order) and turns in frustration to endnotes that often pile on 20 or 30 discrete citations in support of a single paragraph (rendering such notes essentially useless, except to impress the reader with the considerable research effort that went into this compilation), one is frequently left to wonder about the author's main point, in the sense of building an empirical case for an explanation of what this all means in the light of research questions relevant today.
There is an impressive display of bibliographic name-dropping, without much discernible connection between those passing references to the body of the text, yet there is often no citation of the relevant bibliography. Instances of this include primitive rebels with no reference to Eric Hobsbawm, imagined communities with no reference to Benedict Anderson, and solids melting in air with no reference to Marshall Berman. From this book, one might conclude that the concept of the ‘public sphere’ originated with Argentinian historian Hilda Sábato, because Jürgen Habermas is nowhere mentioned. Given the eventual presentation of a sizeable body of information focusing on the trajectory of the Partido Democrático Paulista and its efforts to challenge the hegemony of the Partido Republicano Paulista in the late 1920s, however, the most egregious gap in the bibliography is the work of Mauricio Font, mentioned neither in the text nor in the notes.
It turns out that the omission is deliberate. In 2005 Woodard published an article in this journal that is primarily a critique of Font's 1990 book, Coffee, Contention, and Change.Footnote 7 In an epigram introducing that criticism of Font's thesis and the empirical basis for it, Woodard invoked Barrington Moore on the essentials of historical analysis: ‘To discover what is important it is necessary to ascertain all the forces at work, to assess on the basis of specific evidence their relative importance and relationship to each other’.Footnote 8 In view of the importance he apparently attaches to such precepts, one would have thought that in his book-length study of these topics Woodard would have provided his own interpretation of the trajectory of São Paulo's Partido Democrático by ascertaining the forces at work, assessing their relative importance and their relationship to each other, and then clearly presenting the results of that analysis. By pretending in this book that the work of Mauricio Font and the debates surrounding it never happened, Woodard does the standards of professionalism a disservice, and misses an opportunity.Footnote 9
Challenging not only Font (here implicitly) but also the cataloguing staff of Brazil's National Library (explicitly, on p. 4) and reams of prior scholarship, Woodard finds that ‘coffee oligarchy’ is not a particularly useful category of analysis. To shift the focus, the book's introduction suggests instead that ‘the structure of politics in São Paulo during these years was characterized by patronage and personalism, fraud and favor, corruption and clientele-building’ (p. 8). Furthermore, there was a ‘thorough interweaving of party and government’ in São Paulo's one-party state. São Paulo politics also ‘involved a far greater number and variety of players than has heretofore been imagined’, and ‘the relationships that tied these players together involved complex processes of give and take’. With these assertions we might agree with Woodard that he has succeeded in his effort to ‘resist the temptation to claim conceptual or methodological novelty’ (p. 12), but they might at least have served as the basis for structuring an interpretive conclusion. The author's purpose would be better served if the conclusion and epilogue, rather than going on about the personal hygiene of Jânio Quadros or the kleptocratic efficiency of Adhemar de Barros in the 1950s, had been dedicated to bringing together the periods and themes treated in earlier chapters in some sort of coherent analysis of São Paulo politics in the Old Republic. In fact, the period from 1889 to the early 1920s, three-quarters of the time period that the book covers and which takes up much of the first half of the text, is not mentioned in the conclusion and epilogue.
Of the analytical trilogy essential to understanding his topic, Woodard is strongest on the political and the social, while economic mechanisms are too often taken for granted or misunderstood. To give one example, although it is marginal to such major issues as agriculture versus industry or the economic effects of coffee price support policy, his take on economic mechanisms becomes unintentionally funny when he suggests that the colonato labour arrangement that became standard in the post-abolition coffee plantations in the west of São Paulo state involved profit sharing (p. 25). That would have come as a surprise to both planters and immigrant workers alike.
This book, presenting voluminous raw material related to questions that students of the history of Brazil consider important, is unsatisfactory. When all is said and done, we are not much closer to understanding the issues it treats than was the case some 30 years ago, when the analyses of these issues by Boris Fausto and Joseph Love appeared in print.
