Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T13:50:28.351Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Optimal rigid brush for fluid capture

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 July 2025

Basile Radisson
Affiliation:
Nonlinear Physical Chemistry Unit, CP231, Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), 1050 Bruxelles, Belgium
Hadrien Bense
Affiliation:
Nonlinear Physical Chemistry Unit, CP231, Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), 1050 Bruxelles, Belgium
Lucie Domino
Affiliation:
Nonlinear Physical Chemistry Unit, CP231, Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), 1050 Bruxelles, Belgium
Hoa-Ai Béatrice Hua
Affiliation:
Nonlinear Physical Chemistry Unit, CP231, Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), 1050 Bruxelles, Belgium
Emmanuel Siéfert
Affiliation:
Nonlinear Physical Chemistry Unit, CP231, Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), 1050 Bruxelles, Belgium
Fabian Brau*
Affiliation:
Nonlinear Physical Chemistry Unit, CP231, Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB), 1050 Bruxelles, Belgium
*
Corresponding author: Fabian Brau, fabian.brau@ulb.be

Abstract

Assemblies of slender structures forming brushes are common in daily life from sweepers to pastry brushes and paintbrushes. These types of porous objects can easily trap liquid in their interstices when removed from a liquid bath. This property is exploited to transport liquids in many applications, ranging from painting, dip-coating and brush-coating to the capture of nectar by bees, bats and honeyeaters. Rationalising the viscous entrainment flow beyond simple scaling laws is complex due to the multiscale structure and the multidirectional flow. Here, we provide an analytical model, together with precision experiments with ideal rigid brushes, to fully characterise the flow through this anisotropic porous medium as it is withdrawn from a liquid bath. We show that the amount of liquid entrained by a brush varies non-monotonically during the withdrawal at low speed, is highly sensitive to the different parameters at play and is very well described by the model without any fitting parameter. Finally, an optimal brush geometry maximising the amount of liquid captured at a given retraction speed is derived from the model and experimentally validated. These optimal designs open routes towards efficient liquid-manipulating devices.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.(a) Snapshots of a honeyeater (Acanthagenys rufogularis) feeding on sugar solution (scale bar: 5 mm; $\Delta t = 10$ ms). Credit: A.E. Hewes and A. Rico-Guevara. (b) Schematic of a brush composed of an equilateral triangular array of pillars showing its lateral size $D$, the distance $d$ between the centres of neighbouring pillars and their radius $R$. (c) Snapshots of an experiment where a brush ($R=300$ μm, $d=1.5$ mm) initially immersed at a depth $L_0 = 16$ mm is withdrawn from a bath of silicone oil ($\mu = 0.97$ Pa s) at a retraction speed $V = 30$ mm min−1 ($\Delta t = 6.4$ s). The height $h$ of the interface is initially equal to the Jurin height $h_J$ and varies during the retraction. This evolution is monitored by measuring the temporal evolution of interface height at the centre of the brush, $h_0(t) = h(0,t)$. (d) Evolution of $h_0-h_J$ as a function of time, rescaled by the time needed to displace the brush by a distance $L_0=11$ mm, for two brushes ($R=500$ μm, $d=2.0$ mm ($\phi _1 = 0.773$) and $R=500$ μm, $d=2.5$ mm ($\phi _2 = 0.855$)) withdrawn at various speeds $V$ as indicated in mm min−1. The maximum height $h_0^m$ reached by the interface during the retraction process is indicated with cross symbols. The dashed curve indicates a motion at the speed of the brush. (e) Same as (d) for various immersion depths $L_0$ as indicated in mm and $V=32$ mm min−1 except for the data represented by a star symbol where $V = 100$ mm min−1 and $R=400$ μm, $d=2.0$ mm ($\phi _2 = 0.855$). (f) Evolution of $h_0^m-h_J$ as a function of retraction speed for 13 different brushes where $4 \leqslant V \leqslant 2000$ mm min−1, $2\leqslant L_0 \leqslant 16$ mm, $15 \leqslant D \leqslant 21.2$ mm and $\mu =0.97$ Pa s. The number of pillars varies between 60 and 163 and $R$ and $d$ are given in μm and mm, respectively. The symbols with a black edge indicate the data for which $h_0^m$ is reached at the end of the retraction when $Vt/L_0 = 1$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) Evolution of the longitudinal and transverse permeabilities rescaled by $d^2$ as a function of the porosity $\phi$ for an equilateral triangular array of pillars where $4F_{\parallel } = [1-0.91 \sqrt {x}]^{4.6}[1-0.069(\ln x + K - 35 x)]$ and $12.4F_{\perp } = [1-1.05\sqrt {x}]^{2.5}[1-0.21(\ln x+K)]$ with $x = 1-\phi$ and $K=1.498$. These expressions are fits of numerical data (see Appendix C) and extend analytical asymptotic expressions (Drummond & Tahir 1984; Jackson & James 1986). (b) Spatio-temporal evolution of $H(\bar {r},\bar {t})$, computed with (3.16a), for two retraction speeds $\overline {V}$ and fixed values of $\bar {\delta }$ and $\bar {h}_J$. (c) Evolution of the transition speed $\overline {V}_{T}$ as a function of $\bar {h}_{J}$ for two values of $\bar {\delta }$. The dotted curve corresponds to the fit (3.18). Pressure field $\bar {p}=p/\rho g L_0$ (d) and velocity field normalised by $V$ at $\bar {t}=0.33$ (e) and at $\bar {t}=0.66$ (f) for $\overline {V}=0.25$, $\bar {\delta } = 0.5$ and $\bar {h}_J=0.25$ corresponding to the top panel of (b). The colour map in (e,f) corresponds to the norm of the velocity $\bar {v}=|\boldsymbol{v}|/V$.

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Theoretical evolution of the largest value of $H_0$ in the time interval $0 \leqslant \bar {t} \leqslant 1$, $H_0^m$, as a function of $\overline {V}$ for several values of $\bar {\delta }$ and $\bar {h}_J$. The dots on the curves indicate the value $\overline {V}_{T}$ of the retraction speed beyond which $H_0^m$ is reached at $\bar {t}=1$. At low $\overline {V}$, $H_0^m$ varies linearly with $\overline {V}$, $H_0^m = C(\bar {h}_J,\bar {\delta }) \overline {V}$. (b) Evolution of $C(\bar {h}_J,\bar {\delta })$ as a function of $\bar {h}_J$ for several values of $\bar {\delta }$. The numerical data are fitted by $C = \bar {h}_J + \alpha (\bar {\delta })$. (c) Evolution of $\alpha$ as a function of $\bar {\delta }$ together with the fit $\alpha ^2(x)\approx \tanh [1/(2 x)^2]$. (d) Evolution of the height of the interface at the end of the retraction, $H_0(1)$, as a function of $\overline {V}$ for several values of $\bar {h}_J$ and $\bar {\delta }$. The circular dots on the curves indicate the value $\overline {V}_{T}$. At low $\overline {V}$, $H_0(1)$ varies linearly with $\overline {V}$, $H_0(1) = S(\bar {h}_J) \overline {V}$. (e) Evolution of $S(\bar {h}_J)$ as a function of $\bar {h}_J$ for several values of $\bar {\delta }$. The numerical data are fitted by $S = \bar {h}_J$. (f) Temporal evolution of $H_0(\bar {t})$ for $\overline {V}=10^{-2}$ and two values of $\bar {h}_J$ and $\bar {\delta }$ as indicated.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Snapshots of three experiments showing the spatio-temporal evolution of the air–liquid interface within brushes together with the theoretical profiles $h(r,t)$ (solid yellow curves). Scale bars: 10 mm. Snapshots correspond to experiments (a) $\phi _1$ ($L_0 = 6$ mm) in figure 5(a) and (b) $\phi _2$ and (c) $\phi _3$ in figure 5(b).

Figure 4

Figure 5.(a,b) Comparison between temporal variations of $H_0(\bar {t})$ measured experimentally (symbols) and computed from (3.16a) (solid curves) for six brushes and four porosities. The data reported in (a) are those shown in figure 1(e) where the parameter values are given. The data reported in (b) correspond to: $(R,d)=$$(500, 2.0)$ [$\phi _1 = 0.77$], $(300, 1.5)$ [$\phi _2 = 0.85$], $(400, 1.75)$ [$\phi _3 = 0.81$], $(650, 1.8)$ [$\phi _4 = 0.53$], where $R$ and $d$ are given in μm and mm, respectively. Values of $V$ and $L_0$ are given, respectively, in mm min−1 and in mm and $\mu = 0.97$ Pa s. The corresponding dimensionless parameters vary in the range: $0.06 \leqslant \overline {V} \leqslant 0.91$, $0.15 \leqslant \bar {\delta } \leqslant 1.30$ ($0.22 \leqslant \delta \leqslant 1.84$) and $0.095 \leqslant \bar {h}_J \leqslant 1.27$. (c) Evolution of $H_0^m$ measured experimentally (symbols) as a function of a rescaled retraction speed identified in (3.19) for the data shown in figure 1(f) ($0.022 \leqslant \overline {V} \leqslant 8.53$). The grey area shows the region spanned by the theory when $\bar {\delta }$ and $\bar {h}_J$ are varied within the experimental range ($0.15 \leqslant \bar {\delta } \leqslant 1.30$, $0.05 \leqslant \bar {h}_J \leqslant 1.27$). The black curve is computed using their average value: $\bar {\delta }=0.73$ and $\bar {h}_J=0.35$. (d) Evolution of $\overline {V}$ as a function of $\bar {h}_{J}$ for the data shown in figure 1(f). The symbols with a black edge indicate the data for which $H_0^m$ is reached at the end of the retraction when $\bar {t} = 1$. For those data, $\overline {V} \gt \overline {V}_T$ as predicted by the theory, where $\overline {V}_T$ is given by (3.18) and shown as a black curve. Insets: evolution of $H_0$ as a function of $\bar {t}$ for some data.

Figure 5

Figure 6.(a) Evolution of the rescaled volume captured by a brush, $\overline {\mathcal{V}}$, defined in (5.1), as a function of the porosity, $\phi$, for $\delta =1$, $\tilde {h}_J=0.5$ and various values of $\widetilde {V}$ (see (3.5) and (5.2) for the definition of these parameters). The dashed curve shows the limiting value $\overline {\mathcal{V}}_{{up}} = \phi + \tilde {h}_{J} (1-\phi )^{1/2}$ reached at large retraction speed when the column of liquid initially inside the brush is entirely pulled out of the bath. (b) Evolution of the optimal porosity, $\phi _{{opt}}$, corresponding to the maximum of $\overline {\mathcal{V}}$ shown in (a), as a function of $\widetilde {V}$ for several values of $\delta$ and $\tilde {h}_J$ together with the fits (5.3). The horizontal dashed lines are analytical estimations, $\phi _{{opt}} = 1- \tilde {h}_{J}^2/4$, obtained by using $\overline {\mathcal{V}}_{{up}}$ for the volume of liquid captured. (c) Measured mass of liquid, $m_{{liq}}$, captured at the end of the retraction process by brushes with various pillar radii $R$ (expressed in μm) for two retraction speeds (expressed in mm min−1) and $d=1.8$ mm, $L_0 = 10$ mm, $\mu = 0.97$ Pa s. The solid curves correspond to the mass computed with the theory: $m_{{liq}} = \rho \, \mathcal{V}$, where $\mathcal{V}$ is given in (5.1). Diameters $D=15.8$ mm and $D=16.8$ mm were used in the theory for $V = 10$ and $V = 100$ mm min−1, respectively (see also Appendix D.4). The dashed curves correspond to the theory where the mass of the liquid deposited along each pillar during the retraction is considered by adding $m_{{LLD}} = \rho \mathcal{V}_{{LLD}}$ to $m_{{liq}}$ where $\mathcal{V}_{{LLD}}$ is given by (5.4).

Figure 6

Figure 7.(a) Snapshots of an experiment showing the spatio-temporal evolution of the air–liquid interface between two parallel plates ($d=1.58$ mm, $W=75$ mm, $L_0=42.8$ mm, $V=1000$ mm min−1) together with the theoretical profiles $h(r,t)$ (solid yellow curves). The red dashed line indicates the position of the interface at $t=0$ (i.e. $h=h_J$). (b,c) Comparison between some temporal variations of $H_0(\bar {t})$ measured experimentally (symbols) and computed from (6.1a) (solid curves) for two parallel plates: $L_0 = 40$ mm (disk), $L_0 = 10$ mm (diamond), $L_0 = 42$ mm (square), $L_0=42.8$ mm (cross), $0.8 \leqslant \delta \leqslant 1.14$ and $\mu = 0.097$ Pa s. Values of $d$ and $W$ are given in mm and $V$ in mm min−1. (d) Evolution of $h_0^m-h_J$ as a function of retraction speed for various $d$ and $W$, where $20 \leqslant V \leqslant 2000$ mm min−1, $5\leqslant L_0 \leqslant 65$ mm and $\mu =0.097$ Pa s except for the symbols with a red edge where $\mu =0.97$ Pa s.

Figure 7

Figure 8.(a) Evolution of the largest value of $H_0$ in the time interval $0 \leqslant \bar {t} \leqslant 1$, $H_0^m$, as a function of $\overline {V}$ for several values of $\delta$ and $\bar {h}_J$ and computed from (6.1a). The circular dots on the curves indicate the value $\overline {V}_{T}$. At low $\overline {V}$, $H_0^m$ varies linearly with $\overline {V}$, $H_0^m = C(\bar {h}_J,\delta ) \overline {V}$. (b) Evolution of $C(\bar {h}_J,\delta )$ as a function of $\bar {h}_J$ for several values of $\delta$. The numerical data are fitted by $C = \bar {h}_J + \beta (\delta )$. (c) Evolution of $\beta$ as a function of $\delta$ together with the fit $\beta (x) \approx \alpha (3 x/4)$, where $\alpha$ is given in (3.19). (d) Evolution of $H_0^m$ measured experimentally (symbols) as a function of a rescaled retraction speed for the data shown in figure 7(d). The dimensionless control parameters vary in the range: $0.024 \leqslant \overline {V} \leqslant 0.96$, $0.13 \leqslant \delta \leqslant 2.0$, $0.023 \leqslant \bar {h}_J \leqslant 0.92$. The black curve is computed using the average value of $\delta$ and $\bar {h}_J$: $\delta =1.0$ and $\bar {h}_J=0.15$. (e) Evolution of the rescaled volume captured by two parallel plates, $\overline {\mathcal{V}}$, defined in (6.4), as a function of their rescaled distance $\bar {d}$ for $\delta =1$ and several values of $h^{\star }_J$. Both $\bar {d}$ and $h^{\star }_J$ are defined in (6.3). (f) Evolution of the optimal distance, $\bar {d}_{{opt}}$, between two plates corresponding to the maximum of $\overline {\mathcal{V}}$ shown in (e) as a function $h^{\star }_J$ for several values of $\delta$. Inset: evolution of $\bar {d}_{{opt}}^{\,0} = \bar {d}_{{opt}}(h^{\star }_J \to 0)$ as a function of $\delta$ together with the fit (6.5a).

Figure 8

Figure 9.Displacement of the crosshead of the traction machine (ZwickiLine Z0.5 from ZwickRoell) as a function of time for two programmed retraction speeds: $V=200$ mm min−1 (a,b) and $V=1000$ mm min−1 (c,d). (a,c) A constant retraction speed $V$ can be maintained over distances much larger than the immersion depth $L_0$ considered in this work. The maximum relative error on the programmed speed is 0.05 %. (b,d) The programmed retraction speed is reached within 20–30 ms after the beginning of the retraction.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Schematics of the systems. (a) Two parallel plates of width $W$ and separated by a distance $2d$ partially immersed in a liquid bath. The liquid rises up to $z=h_J$ between the plates. (b) Unit cell of an equilateral triangular array of cylinders of radius $R$ and separated by a distance $d$. The liquid rises up to $z=h_J$ between the cylinders. (c) Horizontal cross-sections of the systems shown in (a,b) highlighting the pore area $A_p$ (blue area) and the length of the solid–liquid interface $\ell _{LS}$ (red curves). (d) Experimental measurements of the Jurin height in an equilateral triangular array of cylinders with various porosities together with the theoretical prediction (B5).

Figure 10

Figure 11.Permeabilities of an equilateral triangular of cylinders. (a) Magnitude of the velocity field of a longitudinal flow along the $z$ axis for three value of $R$ at a given $d$. (b) Evolution of $k_{\parallel }/d^2$ as a function of the porosity $\phi$ obtained numerically together with the asymptotic relation (C1) and the fit (C3). (c) Magnitudes of the velocity and pressure fields for a transverse flow along the $x$ axis for three value of $R$ at a given $d$. (d) Same as (c) for a transverse flow along the $y$ axis. Both cases lead to the same value of the permeability. (e) Evolution of $k_{\perp }/d^2$ as a function of the porosity $\phi$ together with the asymptotic relation (C1) and the fit (C5). (f) Evolution of the ratio $k_{\perp }/k_{\parallel }$ as a function of $\phi$ together with the ratio of the fits (C5) and (C3) and a simpler fit (C6).

Figure 11

Figure 12.Relative error on $H_0^m$ when $H(\bar {r},\bar {t})$ is computed with (3.16a) instead of (3.15) as a function of $\overline {V}$ and $\bar {\delta }$ for $\bar {h}_J = 0.25$ (a) and $\bar {h}_J = 0.5$ (b). The two crosses correspond to illustrative cases shown in (c). (c) Spatio-temporal evolution of $H(\bar {r},\bar {t})$ computed with (3.16a) (solid curves) and with (3.15) (dashed curves) for $\bar {\delta }=1.0$ (top panel) and $\bar {\delta }=1.8$ (bottom panel) with $\bar {V}=0.4$, $\bar {h}_J=0.25$ for both panels. (d) Evolution of $(h_0^m-h_J)/h_J$ and $(h_0(1)-h_J)/h_J$ as a function of $L_0/h_J$ for $\tilde {\delta } \equiv \bar {\delta } \bar {h}_J = 0.1$. The dashed curve indicates the short-time behaviour whereas the horizontal dashed-dotted and dotted curves are estimations of the saturation values obtained from (3.19) and (3.20), respectively. (e) Same as (d) for $\tilde {\delta } = 1$. (f) Measured mass of liquid, $m_{{liq}}$, captured at the end of the retraction process by brushes with various pillar radii $R$ for two retraction speeds (expressed in mm min−1) and $d=1.8$ mm, $L_0 = 10$ mm, $\mu = 0.97$ Pa s. The solid curves correspond to the mass computed with the theory. Diameters $D=15.8$ mm and $D=16.8$ mm were used in the theory for $V = 10$ and $V = 100$ mm min−1, respectively. The dashed curve corresponds to the theoretical curve at $V = 100$ mm min−1 when $D=15.8$ mm is used. See text for discussion.

Figure 12

Figure 13.(a) Evolution of $\bar {\delta }_0$, defined in (D7) and (D8), as a function of $\overline {V}$ and $\bar {h}_J$. The crosses correspond to illustrative cases shown in (b). (b) Temporal evolution of $H_0$ computed with (3.16a) for various values of $\overline {V}$ and $\bar {h}_J$ and $\bar {\delta } \simeq \bar {\delta }_0$. The dashed lines show the temporal evolution of $H_0^{1D}$ computed with (D6). (c) Evolution of $\varDelta$, defined in (D11), as a function of $\overline {V}$ and $\bar {h}_J$ for $\bar {\delta }=1$. (d) Comparison between the temporal evolution of $H_0$ computed with (3.16a) and the approximate expression $H_0^+$, defined in (D10), for various values of $\overline {V}$ and $\bar {h}_J$ and $\bar {\delta }=1$. In these examples, $\varDelta \lt 0.27$ for $\overline {V} = 1$, $\varDelta \lt 0.73$ for $\overline {V} = 0.5$ and $\varDelta = 0.53$ for $\overline {V} = 0.2$. (e) Evolution of $\varDelta$, defined in (D11) with $H_0^{+}$ replaced by $H_0^{-}$, as a function of $\overline {V}$ and $\bar {h}_J$ for $\bar {\delta }=1$. $H_0^{-}$ is given by (D13). (f) Comparison between the temporal evolution of $H_0$ computed with (3.16a) and the approximate expression $H_0^-$ for various values of $\bar {h}_J$, $\overline {V}=0.01$ and $\bar {\delta }=0.1$. In these examples, $0.76 \leqslant \varDelta \leqslant 0.99$.

Supplementary material: File

Radisson et al. supplementary movie 1

Retraction of a brush (D = 17 mm, R = 0.5 mm, d = 2.0 mm) at various speeds (V = 4, 8, 16, 32 mm/min) from a bath of silicon oil (μ = 0.97 Pa s, initial immersion depth L0 = 16 mm), the frame rate being adjusted to synchronize the retractions.
Download Radisson et al. supplementary movie 1(File)
File 6.5 MB
Supplementary material: File

Radisson et al. supplementary movie 2

Retraction of a brush (D = 16 mm, R = 0.3 mm, d = 1.5 mm) at various speeds (V = 2, 8, 32, 128 mm/min) from a bath of silicon oil (μ = 0.97 Pa s, initial immersion depth L0 = 7 mm), the frame rate being adjusted to synchronize the retractions.
Download Radisson et al. supplementary movie 2(File)
File 7.6 MB
Supplementary material: File

Radisson et al. supplementary movie 3

Retraction of a brush (D = 17 mm, R = 0.5 mm, d = 2.0 mm) at various initial immersion depths (L0 = 6, 11, 16 mm) from a bath of silicon oil (μ = 0.97 Pa s, retraction speed V = 32 mm/min), the frame rate being adjusted to synchronize the retractions.
Download Radisson et al. supplementary movie 3(File)
File 4.9 MB
Supplementary material: File

Radisson et al. supplementary movie 4

Withdrawing of brushes of various rod radii (R = 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7 mm) but with the same distance between the rod centers d = 1.8 mm, diameter D = 16 mm and immersion depth L0 = 10 mm at constant speed V = 100 mm/min from a silicon oil bath (μ = 0.97 Pa s). The movie stops when the brushes have been displacement by a distance L0.
Download Radisson et al. supplementary movie 4(File)
File 2.7 MB
Supplementary material: File

Radisson et al. supplementary movie 5

Withdrawing of two parallel plates (d = 1.58 mm, W = 75 mm) immersed at a depth L0 = 42.8 mm at constant speed V = 1000 mm/min from a silicon oil bath (μ = 0.097 Pa s).
Download Radisson et al. supplementary movie 5(File)
File 1.9 MB