How can the State fulfil its three fiduciary duties related to homelessness and public property? How can the State end homelessness and treat unhoused persons with equal respect, protect public property’s communal worth, and legitimize laws that govern public space? And how can the State safeguard unhoused persons against domination?
This chapter aims to answer these questions. The opening parts of this chapter highlight the connection between the State’s fiduciary duty to end homelessness and its fiduciary duties to safeguard public property and legitimize the laws that govern it. It then sets out why the duty to end homelessness and treat unhoused persons with equal respect is comprised of three interrelated elements: the obligations to address the risk factors associated with homelessness, improve access to housing, and provide shelters and other interim resources until individuals become housed.
Later parts of the chapter provide a set of concrete proposals that illustrate how the State may attempt to fulfil its three fiduciary duties related to homelessness and public property. Laws that govern public property treat individuals with greater respect when the State alleviates homelessness and mitigates nonegalitarian coercion and punitive entrenchment. In doing so, the State can increasingly fulfil its three fiduciary duties discussed above, and ultimately, better respect its overarching fiduciary obligation to redress domination.
9.1 The Relationship between the State’s Three Fiduciary Duties
The State’s three fiduciary duties related to homelessness and public property are inextricably intertwined. The fiduciary duty to end homelessness and treat unhoused persons with equal respect must be fulfilled for the State to satisfy its other fiduciary obligations to protect public property’s value and to legitimize the laws that regulate it. The interconnection between the State’s three fiduciary duties related to homelessness and public property – and its overarching duty to counteract domination – can be summarized as follows.
First, the State must end homelessness and treat unhoused persons with equal respect to prevent and neutralize domination. Individuals who have access to housing are subject to less horizontal and vertical domination.Footnote 1 Housed persons are protected against others’ private power of exclusion and are safeguarded against the disparate enforcement of laws that govern public property.Footnote 2 They do not consistently depend on others to obey laws that regulate public space and are subject to fewer nonegalitarian trade-offs as the price to comply with these laws.Footnote 3 Ultimately, individuals who enjoy access to housing are better safeguarded against nonegalitarian coercion and punitive entrenchment.Footnote 4
Second, the State must end homelessness and treat unhoused persons with equal respect to fulfil its fiduciary duty to maintain public property’s shared value.Footnote 5 Individuals who have access to housing enjoy greater freedom to alleviate their needs on private property rather than on public property, which increases public property’s shared worth and reduces negative externalities in public spaces.Footnote 6
Access to housing is fundamental because it optimally absorbs negative externalities that would otherwise occur on public property.Footnote 7 Individuals who alleviate their needs in public enjoy the benefits of their conduct, bear little to none of its costs, and diffuse these costs onto many other persons.Footnote 8 In contrast, individuals who alleviate their needs within their home enjoy the benefits of that conduct and impose no negative externalities onto others.Footnote 9 Individuals are encouraged to alleviate their needs properly within their homes – for instance, by performing their bodily functions in their bathrooms rather than elsewhere in their homes – because they will principally bear the costs of such conduct. For these reasons, a home can internalize the costs of need-alleviating conduct so that they are not imposed onto others. Access to housing encourages rightsholders to alleviate their needs within their homes in a manner that imposes the fewest costs onto all persons. The State will better protect public property’s value when it ensures access to housing that internalizes negative externalities that would otherwise occur on public property.Footnote 10 Housed persons can freely alleviate their needs on private property and are not required to do so in public space.
Third, access to housing ensures that individuals enjoy maximal freedom to comply with laws that regulate public space and avoid coercion and punishment, which legitimizes these laws.Footnote 11 Individuals who have access to housing have the greatest undominated choice to obey the law, and their law-abidingness is less subject to others’ external control.Footnote 12 Housed persons may be subject to fewer nonegalitarian trade-offs as the price to obey laws that govern public property.Footnote 13 And they enjoy more protection against the State’s capacity to regulate, police, and punish their need-alleviating acts.Footnote 14 As discussed in previous chapters, housing provides greater physical and legal protection against surveillance, searches, intrusions, and law enforcement actions.Footnote 15
The State’s fiduciary duty to end homelessness and treat unhoused persons with equal respect is a keystone fiduciary obligation that must be fulfilled so that the State respects its other fiduciary duties.Footnote 16 Individuals will continue to experience horizontal and vertical domination when they lack access to housing.Footnote 17 Furthermore, since individuals must alleviate their needs somewhere, the State cannot protect public property’s role optimally unless it ensures that individuals are housed. Laws that govern public property will continue to lack legitimacy so long as they subject individuals to nonegalitarian coercion and punitive entrenchment. The fulfilment of the fiduciary duty to alleviate homelessness is a precondition to the fulfilment of the State’s other fiduciary duties related to homelessness and public property.
9.2 The State’s Fiduciary Duty to End Homelessness
9.2.1 The Scope of the State’s Fiduciary Duty to End Homelessness
The State’s first fiduciary obligation – the duty to end homelessness and treat unhoused persons with equal respect – is comprised of three elements, each of which secures freedom differently and protects individuals against domination in distinct ways. First, the State must address the risk factors associated with homelessness. The unhoused population is heterogeneous and has diverse needs.Footnote 18 Even if the State provides access to housing, many individuals require additional support to remain housed. For instance, individuals who obtain access to housing may require extensive mental health support.Footnote 19 Studies indicate that individuals with complex needs are more likely to remain housed when they have both access to housing and additional support mechanisms, such as Assertive Community Treatment that assists individuals with complex mental health needs.Footnote 20 Other studies suggest that individuals who are provided with access to housing may reexperience homelessness when they are not given necessary support, such as mental health care, treatment for substance use disorder, a primary physician, and greater income or employment opportunities.Footnote 21 Ending homelessness requires the State to respond to both a lack of access to housing and the risk factors associated with homelessness.
Second, the State must provide access to housing for individuals who lack the capacity to acquire it and who cannot safeguard themselves against domination. The State can fulfil this duty through different means. The State can provide rental housing subsidies – such as a housing voucher program – that secures access to housing and prevents many lower-income individuals from experiencing homelessness.Footnote 22 In other contexts, the State must do more to ensure that individuals can maintain access to housing and enjoy nondomination. More specifically, the State must provide access to some form of housing when voucher programs will not suffice to alleviate homelessness. Housing First programs may help individuals in such contexts.Footnote 23
Third, the State must provide access to shelters and other resources to assist individuals who suddenly experience homelessness or who require interim resources until they become housed. Shelters provide emergency services in contexts where individuals lose access to housing.Footnote 24 They also identify the need for various resources that can help individuals become housed, such as mental health services, treatment for substance use disorder, and access to housing and employment programs.Footnote 25 Studies indicate that homelessness is more frequently transitory than chronic.Footnote 26 Individuals may unexpectedly require access to an emergency shelter for various reasons.Footnote 27 For instance, they may experience homelessness due to interpersonal conflict, domestic violence, eviction, criminal charges or convictions, or health challenges.Footnote 28 The State better fulfils its fiduciary duty to end homelessness and treat unhoused persons with greater respect when it provides emergency shelter and interim resources that assist individuals until they become housed.
9.2.2 Mechanisms That Address Risk Factors Associated with Homelessness
The State can address certain risk factors associated with homelessness through different mechanisms, such as Assertive Community Treatment, outreach teams, Intensive Case Management, Critical Time Intervention, culturally sensitive and inclusive services, and reentry programs – many of which have been explored in depth by Carol Caton.Footnote 29 The mechanisms explored in this section draw significantly on her insightful scholarship. To be clear, these mechanisms are not intended to be exhaustive given the heterogeneity of the unhoused population, and given each unhoused person’s distinct needs. Nor can these mechanisms address every risk factor related to homelessness. Other useful services, programs, and resources also assist people experiencing homelessness. Yet these mechanisms exemplify different ways in which the State can address homelessness and its risk factors.
First, the State may provide Assertive Community Treatment (ACT), which is a model of care that combines outreach, access to community resources, integrated services, and continuity of care for individuals who have complex mental health needs.Footnote 30 Research indicates that mental illness is an important risk factor for homelessness, and many individuals who experience chronic homelessness struggle with mental illness.Footnote 31 ACT teams are comprised of professionals such as psychiatrists, nurses, social workers, substance use counselors, vocational counselors, and others.Footnote 32 They adopt a holistic approach to address the specific needs of unhoused persons.Footnote 33 These teams have relatively low caseloads to maximize their effectiveness.Footnote 34 Some studies suggest that ACT can improve access to housing for unhoused persons with mental health challenges more effectively than other forms of case management.Footnote 35 Research also indicates that the combination of ACT and Housing First programs can help house individuals with mental illness more effectively than traditional treatment models.Footnote 36
Second, local governments can provide interdisciplinary outreach teams that assist unhoused persons with complex needs. The city of Toronto offers a Multi-Disciplinary Outreach Team (MDOT) comprised of nonpolice specialists who streamline access to housing, social services, medical services, and mental health treatment.Footnote 37 Toronto’s MDOT incorporates a housing specialist, a nurse, outreach workers, and psychiatrists.Footnote 38 The team works closely with the healthcare system and with Housing First programs.Footnote 39 As a low-barrier program, there are no preconditions – such as sobriety or taking medication – to be assisted by Toronto’s MDOT team.Footnote 40 Some studies indicate that MDOT helped unsheltered unhoused persons receive necessary mental health care and obtain stable access to housing.Footnote 41
Third, the State can offer Intensive Case Management (ICM) to address risk factors associated with homelessness. Intensive case managers connect unhoused persons with healthcare providers, direct them to community services and treatment programs, advocate on their behalf, and assist them during crises.Footnote 42 ICM is less intensive than ACT.Footnote 43 Furthermore, there are differences between both treatment models.Footnote 44 The members of an ACT team provide direct treatment to unhoused persons, whereas intensive case managers do not.Footnote 45 Certain studies suggest that ICM can reduce the duration of homelessness.Footnote 46 Furthermore, as Carol Caton notes, research suggests that ICM can improve quality of life more effectively when combined with access to housing.Footnote 47
Fourth, governments can provide Critical Time Intervention (CTI) programs that aim to rapidly house individuals who enter the shelter system.Footnote 48 CTIs are short-term programs – generally between six to nine months – that assist unhoused persons while they transition from a shelter to community care.Footnote 49 Case workers provide continuity of care so that unhoused persons can access certain resources in the community and obtain access to housing.Footnote 50 Some research studies suggest that CTIs reduced the likelihood of homelessness and decreased the duration of homelessness more effectively than standard care.Footnote 51
Fifth, the State can support more inclusive and culturally sensitive resources that prevent homelessness, increase access to housing, and improve well-being for certain populations with specific needs. Indigenous persons are overrepresented in Canada’s unhoused population.Footnote 52 They face unique barriers to housing due to the impacts of colonization and the legacy of residential schools.Footnote 53 These realities resulted in increased rates of substance use, suicide, social dislocation, post-traumatic stress disorder, foster care, and unemployment.Footnote 54 Some research indicates that the risk factors associated with homelessness – and the pathways out of it – are different for Indigenous and non-Indigenous people.Footnote 55
Culturally sensitive programs and services can better prevent and address homelessness amongst Indigenous persons.Footnote 56 Studies show that cultural continuity is associated with improved health and wellness outcomes for Indigenous persons.Footnote 57 Brittany Bingham and colleagues note that traditional treatment models for substance use – an important risk factor for homelessness – are less effective for Indigenous persons than for non-Indigenous persons.Footnote 58 They explain that “approaches that create reconnection to community, culture and traditions have been shown to have a positive impact on substance use.”Footnote 59
Some jurisdictions have culturally sensitive and inclusive programs that aim to improve Indigenous persons’ access to housing and well-being, and reconnect them with their culture and traditions.Footnote 60 For instance, Anishnawbe Health Toronto (AHT) provides a range of services to support Indigenous persons.Footnote 61 These services include access to physical and mental healthcare, traditional teachings, Indigenous supportive housing, support from elders, a circle of care, substance use support, a mobile healing unit, and programs for Two-Spirit and transgender persons.Footnote 62 The State better fulfils its fiduciary duty to alleviate homelessness when it supports inclusive programs that address the distinct needs of communities who are overrepresented in the unhoused population.
Sixth, the State can devise reentry programs that increase access to housing for unhoused persons who had prior contact with the criminal justice system. Ready, Willing, and Able is a New York City-based initiative that offers various resources for unhoused persons. The program offers paid employment opportunities, physical and mental health support, career training, and housing.Footnote 63 Many individuals who complete the program secure access to housing.Footnote 64 Furthermore, those who completed the program tend to have less contact with the police, are less likely to reoffend, and have higher rates of stable employment.Footnote 65 Ready, Willing, and Able also saves New York City significant financial costs that would be spent on the criminal justice system.Footnote 66 Other cities, such as Boulder, Philadelphia, Washington, and Atlanta have adopted similar programs.Footnote 67
9.2.3 Access to Housing
The State must also ensure access to housing to fulfil its fiduciary duty to end homelessness and treat unhoused persons with equal respect. Cities can implement two notable mechanisms that improve access to housing: Housing First programs and housing vouchers.Footnote 68 Housing First programs offer private market accommodations with no preconditions, such as sobriety, mental health treatment, or employment.Footnote 69 People experiencing homelessness can be given access to housing through a private landlord without having to initially pass through the shelter system or transitional housing.Footnote 70 By employing a harm-reduction approach, Housing First users are not required to abstain from alcohol or drug use as a condition to obtain housing.Footnote 71 Individuals in Housing First programs are provided additional community-based support for mental health challenges, substance use disorder, and more.Footnote 72
Housing First programs are typically contrasted with traditional Treatment First models. Treatment First models require unhoused persons to first seek care for substance use or mental illness to obtain housing.Footnote 73 Case managers then allocate available housing spaces based on an individual’s adherence to treatment and readiness to be housed.Footnote 74
Some empirical studies suggest that Housing First can reduce homelessness and improve housing stability more effectively compared to Treatment First models.Footnote 75 Furthermore, certain research indicates that Housing First can produce other benefits, such as fewer hospitalizations and emergency room visits.Footnote 76
Different cities have employed Housing First models. Beginning in 2008 in Canada, the federal government implemented the At Home/Chez Soi Housing First program and conducted a study to evaluate its effectiveness.Footnote 77 As part of this program, the government offered a Housing First program in five major Canadian cities: Montreal, Moncton, Toronto, Winnipeg, and Vancouver.Footnote 78 The study lasted a period of five years. Its results were compared to traditional programs designed to reduce homelessness.Footnote 79 Results indicated that the combination of Housing First and other mechanisms – such as ACT or ICM – improved quality of life more significantly than other forms of treatment.Footnote 80
Certain studies observe that the costs of Housing First are not entirely offset by reductions in other financial costs associated with homelessness, such as fewer emergency room visits, fewer hospitalizations, increased use of social programs, and more.Footnote 81 However, some research suggests that Housing First can offset roughly two-thirds of the costs associated with traditional programs and initiatives to reduce homelessness.Footnote 82 As some scholars note, this cost disparity can be justified because Housing First may result in better outcomes compared to other programs.Footnote 83
To be clear, given the heterogeneity of the unhoused population, Housing First is not a one-size-fits-all solution. Given the costs of implementation, Housing First programs may be difficult to scale. Furthermore, as discussed above in Section 9.2.2, the State must provide resources that address the risk factors associated with homelessness, such as treatment for mental illness and substance use disorder, and that allow individuals to secure access to housing while avoiding dependency on the State.
Housing vouchers – meaning government issued financial support for private market accommodation – are another mechanism that can improve access to housing.Footnote 84 Carol Caton notes that in the United States, Section 8 housing voucher recipients pay roughly 30 percent of their income to rent.Footnote 85 The State, subsidies, or private charities pay the remaining portion of rental costs.Footnote 86 Studies suggest that housing vouchers are an effective means to reduce homelessness.Footnote 87 Furthermore, systematic reviews indicate that these vouchers also improve housing stability and food security.Footnote 88 Housing vouchers have also been shown to produce more positive outcomes for certain subpopulations of people experiencing homelessness, such as unhoused families and pregnant women.Footnote 89
Various studies highlight the effectiveness of housing vouchers. In a New York City study, families living in a homeless shelter who received a housing voucher were roughly four times more likely to be housed compared to families who received no voucher.Footnote 90 More specifically, 80 percent of unhoused families who received the voucher were housed at that five-year period compared to 18 percent of participants who received no voucher.Footnote 91 Similarly, in a study that evaluated the impact of housing vouchers in a dozen sites across the United States – the Family Options study – individuals who received vouchers were significantly more likely to be housed compared to individuals who did not receive them.Footnote 92 These outcomes highlight the importance of housing vouchers as a mechanism to alleviate homelessness.Footnote 93
9.2.4 Inclusive Emergency Shelter and Interim Resources
The State’s duty to end homelessness and treat unhoused persons with equal respect requires it to provide access to shelters and to other interim resources until individuals become housed. The State better fulfils this duty when it allocates resources that respond to the general needs of all unhoused persons and to the distinct needs of subsets of the unhoused population. In terms of general needs that are shared by all unhoused persons, the State must provide access to resources that fulfil basic subsistence needs in emergency contexts, such as access to food, clothing, sanitation infrastructure, and safe shelter.Footnote 94
The State better fulfils its fiduciary duty to end homelessness when it also addresses the discrete needs of subsets of the unhoused population. Chapter 1 explained how certain individuals are more likely to experience homelessness compared to the general population. Examples include survivors of domestic violence, members of the LGBTQ community, immigrants, veterans, individuals with prior criminal justice system involvement, and racialized and Indigenous persons.Footnote 95 The State better fulfils its fiduciary duty to end homelessness and treat unhoused persons with equal respect when it offers resources that are inclusive, culturally sensitive, and capable of accommodating the distinct needs of subsets of the unhoused population.
Two examples illustrate this point. First, domestic violence shelters offer specific resources and support that can help individuals leave abusive relationships, prevent revictimization, secure access to housing, and increase employment stability.Footnote 96 Such specialized shelters aim to counteract a unique type of horizontal domination – domestic violence – that other unhoused persons may not experience. The State alleviates and counteracts homelessness more effectively when it allocates shelters and other resources that address the unique needs of domestic violence survivors.
Second, homeless shelters and other programs can better accommodate the specific needs of members of the LGBTQ community.Footnote 97 For instance, transgender persons who stay in conventional homeless shelters are vulnerable to distinct type of domination based on their personal characteristics. Research indicates that transgender persons are more likely to be victims of violent crimes compared to the general population, and that they report feeling unsafe in conventional shelters due to risks of harassment, discrimination, and violence.Footnote 98 Yet cities may create more inclusive transitional housing and shelters that better accommodate transgender persons.Footnote 99 Shelters may also provide inclusive policies, outreach, training, and support services for unhoused members of the LGBTQ community that aim to decrease discrimination, harassment, and violence.Footnote 100
Jurisdictions can implement other types of inclusive services for members of the LGBTQ community. Some studies suggest that unhoused male members of the LGBTQ community are more at risk to contract HIV compared to the general population, which highlights the need for specific services to address this reality.Footnote 101 Some jurisdictions have implemented preventive HIV case management programs for transgender women – a population that disproportionately experiences homelessness.Footnote 102 Some research suggests that this program reduced homelessness and improved participants’ quality of life.Footnote 103 These are just some examples, but they highlight how inclusive shelters and services may help reduce homelessness and address the unique needs of unhoused members of the LGBTQ community.
9.3 Reduce Nonegalitarian Coercion and Punitive Entrenchment
The State must also decrease nonegalitarian coercion and punitive entrenchment to fulfil its three fiduciary duties related to homelessness and public property. Laws that govern public property treat individuals with greater concern and respect when the State counteracts domination associated with these laws. Furthermore, by avoiding punitive entrenchment, the State can better fulfil its duty to end homelessness. Different mechanisms can help achieve these aims, such as avoiding incarceration, graduating economic sanctions (or day fines), collateral consequence minimalism, automatic criminal record expungements, and criminal justice debt absolution.
9.3.1 Avoiding Incarceration
The State can reduce punitive entrenchment – and treat individuals with greater respect – when it avoids incarcerating unhoused persons because they violated laws that govern public property or could not afford to pay their fines.Footnote 104 Previous chapters illustrated how incarceration can enmesh individuals in the condition of homelessness.Footnote 105 Furthermore, incarceration can result in financial difficulties, physical or psychological harm, lower income, and unemployment.Footnote 106
The relationship between homelessness, criminal justice debt, and incarceration underpins the need to avoid incarceration in the contexts described above.Footnote 107 Homelessness is associated with a greater likelihood of incarceration.Footnote 108 Studies indicate that individuals who have been incarcerated are more likely to experience homelessness compared to individuals who have not been imprisoned.Footnote 109 Some research suggests that approximately 23 percent of incarcerated persons were unhoused when they were sentenced to prison.Footnote 110 A Public Health Agency of Canada survey study observed that most unhoused youth have been incarcerated or have spent time in youth-detention.Footnote 111 The John Howard Society estimates that roughly 45 percent of people discharged from prison are either unhoused or are at risk of experiencing homelessness upon release.Footnote 112
Other studies have highlighted the connection between criminal justice debt and homelessness.Footnote 113 Some research indicates that criminal justice debt is associated with longer periods of homelessness.Footnote 114 Furthermore, this research suggests that criminal justice debt increased the duration of homelessness in ways that other types of debt – such as student loans or credit card debt – did not.Footnote 115
This does not mean that the State can never incarcerate unhoused persons because they violated a law that governs public property. As a general principle, the State can more justifiably resort to imprisonment in such contexts as a last resort and when no others reasonable alternatives are appropriate.Footnote 116 For instance, incarceration can be more legitimate in situations where an unhoused person repeatedly or deliberately engages in conduct that harms or endangers others, creates meaningful public health or safety risks, or violates basic norms of public order (for instance, engaging in sexual acts in public), and where harm-reduction strategies and alternative sanctions are ineffective. In such contexts, incarceration may be an appropriate sanction.
9.3.2 Graduating Economic Sanctions (Day Fines)
Second, the State can replace fixed financial penalties with graduating economic sanctions (or day fines) to mitigate punitive entrenchment.Footnote 117 Jurisdictions in Canada and the United States tend to impose fixed financial penalties (or tariff fines) irrespective of the defendant’s income or financial capacities.Footnote 118 Tariff-fines disproportionately impact impecunious persons and result in additional fees and consequences due to nonpayment, which are referred to as “poverty penalties.”Footnote 119 In contrast, day fines impose financial penalties that are proportionate to the defendant’s daily adjusted income and to the gravity of the offense.Footnote 120 Countries such as Sweden, Finland, and Denmark use day fines.Footnote 121 Some US jurisdictions have also experimented with day fines.Footnote 122 Staten Island (New York), Maricopa County (Arizona), Polk County (Iowa), Bridgeport (Connecticut), and several counties in Oregon implemented day fines as part of a pilot project.Footnote 123
The quantum of a day fine is calculated through a two-step process.Footnote 124 First, the State determines the number of days for a particular offense.Footnote 125 The number of “days” represents a numerical value (or number of points) that increases according to the gravity of the offense.Footnote 126 Second, the State determines the number of units that apply to the offender.Footnote 127 The number of “units” represents a fraction of the offender’s daily adjusted income which considers personal and family living expenses.Footnote 128 The total cost of the fine is calculated by multiplying the number of days by the number of units.Footnote 129 A day fine cannot exceed a certain proportion of the offender’s daily adjusted income. In Finland, for example, the amount of the fine cannot be greater than one-third of the offender’s daily adjusted income.Footnote 130
Some object to day fines on the grounds that these financial penalties impact affluent offenders disproportionately. For instance, an affluent motorist in Finland received a €110,000 fine for speeding.Footnote 131 However, certain mechanisms can prevent excessive day fines. The State can impose a statutory cap (or ceiling) on the severity of fines that resembles the current maximum fine imposed by statute.Footnote 132 This ensures that individuals do not pay exorbitant amounts for minor offenses, and that individuals will not pay more than they did prior to the implementation of a day fine scheme.Footnote 133
Day fines may also benefit cities and local governments. Although the quantum of day fines tends to be lower than tariff fines, certain studies suggest that defendants who received day fines paid higher amounts compared to defendants who received fixed financial penalties.Footnote 134 Furthermore, some research suggests that defendants were more likely to pay their day fines within a year compared to those who received fixed financial penalties.Footnote 135 Increased complete payment rates, for their part, can reduce the costs that cities expend to issue bench warrants for unpaid fines and to hold collection hearings.Footnote 136
Certain measures may also improve defendants’ payment and compliance rates without increasing cities’ expenditures significantly. The justice system can develop flexible and longer payment plans for more expensive day fines.Footnote 137 Cities can remove mandatory court appearances for missed payments, avoid warrants for nonpayment, and send phone or text message reminders to defendants who do not pay on time.Footnote 138 Furthermore, as Beth Colgan notes, some cities employ supportive collection methods – such as self-addressed and stamped envelopes and clear payment instructions – that reduce administrative burden and may increase collection rates.Footnote 139
9.3.3 Collateral Consequence Minimalism
Third, the State can minimize collateral consequences for unpaid fines that entrench individuals in homelessness. The collateral consequences of unpaid fines include additional fees and penalties, driver’s license suspensions, civil asset forfeiture, parole revocation, loss of public benefits, disclosure of unpaid fines to consumer reporting agencies, and default civil judgments against defendants, amongst others.Footnote 140
Chapter 6 demonstrated how these collateral consequences exacerbate nonegalitarian coercion and punitive entrenchment in different ways.Footnote 141 Defendants who cannot afford to pay their fines must pay additional fines, fees, and penalties rather than their rent.Footnote 142 Furthermore, individuals who owe criminal justice debt are less able to save money, qualify for a mortgage, and buy a home.Footnote 143 Unpaid fines may result in a loss of social assistance – such as public housing or social security – that result in homelessness.Footnote 144 Suspended driver’s licenses, for their part, can lead to unemployment and lower income.Footnote 145 Unpaid fines can be disclosed to a credit agency, which can decrease an individuals’ credit rating and capacity to rent an apartment.Footnote 146 Collateral consequence minimalism may help decrease punitive entrenchment, safeguard individuals against domination, and legitimize laws that govern public property.
The State can reduce the collateral consequences of criminal justice debt in different ways. Jurisdictions can establish independent commissions to review and modify the consequences of unpaid fines.Footnote 147 Governments can abolish driver license suspensions associated with criminal justice debt.Footnote 148 For instance, states such as New York and Montana have limited driver’s license suspensions for unpaid fines.Footnote 149 Other jurisdictions, such as Texas, mandate judges to hold ability-to-pay hearings for fines and offer alternative options to indigent persons, such as fee-waivers or community service.Footnote 150 Statutes can require fees and surcharges to be imposed proportionally to individuals’ income, or eliminate them entirely for impecunious persons.Footnote 151 Although these are just some examples, they show how cities and states may attempt to mitigate punitive entrenchment.
Courts may also attempt to counteract collateral consequences that function as poverty penalties. For instance, judges may determine that mandatory collateral consequences – such as additional fees and surcharges – violate the Excessive Fines Clause in the United States or the constitutional right to be free from cruel and unusual punishments in Canada.Footnote 152 As discussed in Section 9.3.5, the Supreme Court of Canada has decided that mandatory surcharges impose a cruel and unusual punishment on indigent persons.Footnote 153 Together, cities and courts may counteract the collateral consequences of criminal justice debt and reduce punitive entrenchment.
9.3.4 Automatic Criminal Record Expungements
Fourth, jurisdictions can adopt automatic criminal record expungement schemes to reduce punitive entrenchment.Footnote 154 Jurisdictions typically require defendants to apply for a criminal record expungement (also referred to as a “pardon” or “criminal record suspension”).Footnote 155 Individuals may have to wait many years until they become eligible for a criminal record expungement.Footnote 156 In Canada, the criminal record suspension ineligibility period is five or ten years following the conclusion of one’s punishment.Footnote 157
Criminal records can contribute to homelessness.Footnote 158 Individuals who have a criminal record can become ineligible for public housing.Footnote 159 Landlords tend to screen for prospective renters’ criminal records.Footnote 160 Furthermore, research suggests that landlords are less willing to rent private accommodations to individuals with prior convictions compared to individuals with no criminal record.Footnote 161 Prior convictions can also reduce employment opportunities and result in public benefit ineligibility, both of which limit access to housing.Footnote 162
The criminal record expungement application process can be complex and may impose heavy administrative burdens.Footnote 163 For instance, jurisdictions may require individuals to ascertain eligibility requirements, fill out complex forms, pay application fees, obtain copies of fingerprints, visit police stations, and mail an application package.Footnote 164 Eligible individuals may not apply for a criminal record expungement due to these administrative burdens.Footnote 165 Furthermore, indigent persons may not request a record suspension due to expensive applications costs and fees.Footnote 166
The uptake rate for criminal record expungements is low.Footnote 167 Research suggests that fewer than 20 percent of eligible persons in certain US states apply for a criminal record expungement (note that fewer than 10 percent apply in other states).Footnote 168 Similarly, following the decriminalization of simple possession of marijuana in Canada, the uptake rate for criminal record suspensions for that offense was low.Footnote 169 Roughly 10,000 persons were estimated to be eligible for a criminal record suspension for simple possession of marijuana.Footnote 170 However, only 780 people applied over a two-year period, and only 484 of those individuals received a criminal record suspension.Footnote 171
More recently, some jurisdictions have implemented automatic criminal record expungement schemes that avoid many of the problems associated with traditional expungement applications.Footnote 172 Some European jurisdictions also expunge individuals’ criminal records automatically after a fixed period.Footnote 173 Automatic expungements models eliminate complexity, administrative burdens, and fees that discourage individuals from criminal record expungement applications.Footnote 174 Furthermore, automatic expungements may be a relatively simple and cost-effective way to increase uptake rates, and ultimately, counteract punitive entrenchment and domination.
9.3.5 Criminal Justice Debt Absolution
Fifth, criminal justice debt absolution may also help reduce punitive entrenchment and domination. The term “criminal justice debt absolution” implies that individuals have a right to be released from criminal justice debts that entrench them in homelessness and poverty.Footnote 175
Individuals enjoy a constitutional right to be protected against excessive fines in the United States, and a right to be protected against cruel and unusual punishments in Canada.Footnote 176 In Timbs v. Indiana, the US Supreme Court decided that the Eighth Amendment right to be free from cruel and unusual punishments – including the Excessive Fines Clause – is incorporated into the states through the Fourteenth Amendment.Footnote 177 The Excessive Fines Clause also applies to municipal ordinances, including laws that govern public property.Footnote 178 Canadian law also offers some protection against excessive fines. In R v. Boudreault, the Supreme Court of Canada concluded that a mandatory $100 or $200 victim surcharge constituted a cruel and unusual punishment due to its impact on unhoused and impecunious persons.Footnote 179 The Court reasoned that the fine violated section 12 of the Canadian Charter because it imposed the equivalent of an indeterminate sentence, resulted in civil and administrative collection efforts, and impacted indigent offenders disparately.Footnote 180 These constitutional provisions provide some protection against excessive fines.
Yet individuals may have accumulated significant criminal justice debt even when courts determine that a particular fine is cruel and unusual.Footnote 181 Research indicates that some unhoused persons in Montreal have accumulated over $10,000-worth of unpaid fines.Footnote 182 Beth Colgan notes that in the United States in 2016, individuals owed $110 billion-worth of restitution for financial penalties, $100 billion-worth of which the federal government estimated will not be recouped because individuals cannot afford to pay them.Footnote 183 Although defendants may successfully challenge a particular fine’s excessiveness, the right to be free from cruel and unusual punishments does not absolve their past criminal justice debts that flow from other offenses.
Some jurisdictions have implemented criminal justice debt relief programs. The city of Montreal’s Programme d’Accompagnement Justice-Itinérance à la Cour Municipale (PAJIC) – which works together with the municipal court and the Droits Devant community organization – offers a criminal justice debt relief initiative to unhoused persons.Footnote 184 Between 2015 and 2016, roughly 150 people completed the PAJIC program and the municipal court absolved roughly 2,400 unpaid fines.Footnote 185 Other cities, such as Los Angeles, decided to void a significant number of fines issued to unhoused persons and relieved them of their criminal justice debts.Footnote 186 These programs can help counteract punitive entrenchment and reduce domination. But unhoused and impecunious persons lack a statutory or constitutional right to be absolved of their criminal justice debts that they cannot pay – an important step to obtain access to housing.
In the future, courts or lawmakers may recognize a right to criminal justice debt absolution.Footnote 187 A judicially recognized constitutional right to criminal justice debt absolution – a right to be freed from cruel and unusual criminal justice debts – would confer stronger protection against punitive entrenchment.
9.4 Conclusion
This chapter argued that the State’s three fiduciary duties – ending homelessness and treating unhoused persons with equal respect, protecting public property’s value, and legitimizing laws that govern the urban commons – are interconnected. It demonstrated why the State must alleviate homelessness to fulfil its other fiduciary duties. It explained the three components of the State’s fiduciary duty to alleviate homelessness: addressing the risk factors associated with homelessness, improving access to housing, and providing emergency shelter and interim resources until individuals become housed.
The later parts of this chapter offered a set of concrete proposals for how the State can better fulfil its fiduciary duties related to homelessness and public property, and ultimately, counteract nonegalitarian coercion, punitive entrenchment, and domination. The implementation of these proposals can better ensure that the State regulates public property in a manner that treats unhoused persons with greater respect and consideration.
