This work is the product of a colloquium held in Cambridge about Islamic cities. It is the consequence of a typical career move by young academics these days: hold a conference on a big theme, and you have another book on the CV without too much effort. That is not to underrate the value of the work: it stands or falls on its own qualities. How then does it add to our knowledge of Islamic cities? As a colloquium, it is necessarily a little diffuse, as it depends on the interests of the participants.
In her introduction Bennison rightly calls attention to the question of what is an Islamic city. “Religion” appears in the subtitle, and the issue of spirituality is evoked a number of times even when it does not seem entirely necessary. The definition should, of course, be cities in the Islamic world or, given that many Islamic countries are multicultural, cities inhabited by Muslims. The introduction is a good summary of present thinking and refers to Abu Lughod's work, which usefully asks the question, What differences are there between a Muslim and non-Muslim city in the same country, for example, India?
In the initial section on the genesis of Islamic cities, Donald Whitcomb lays out a formal structure for an Umayyad city. In 1996 Whitcomb successfully showed that the earliest newly founded Islamic cities, the amṣār, were derived from the urban model of the Arabian peninsula. Here, he goes further and attempts to apply the same model to Umayyad cities in the Levant. The result is not so successful for the obvious reason that most cities in Bilad al-Sham had a long history before Islam, and the Umayyads would have had relatively little impact apart from building the congregational mosques that continue to adorn many Levantine cities.
It would also have been useful to recognize the basic difference between organic cities and the city-like settlements, palatine cities, madīnas, built by the elite essentially for their own entourage, beginning in the Umayyad period and best portrayed in the Round City of al-Mansur, where the list of inhabitants is given by al-Yaʿqubi. This basic distinction is little recognized in the volume, and its absence has a negative effect on many of the articles.
In the second piece, Simon O'Meara studies the common threads of foundation lore of Islamic cities, based upon the tradition of the foundation of Fez. The theme of the monk who predicts goes back to the time of the Prophet.
Tim Williams then gives us an introduction to his work on the plan of the pre-Mongol Islamic city at Merv, now called Sultan Kala. The plan of Sultan Kala can be recovered to a certain degree from Soviet-era aerial photographs, particularly with computer-aided enhancement. The result is useful, but because we know little about the functions of urban buildings in Central Asia, it is hard to come to significant conclusions. Williams is a field archaeologist, and his lack of access to the texts on the history of Merv is evident. Sultan Kala was originally founded as a Muslim suburb of Gyaur Kala, the Sasanian city, which subsequently developed as the main city, a phenomenon with a good many parallels.
In the second section, “Power and the City,” Amira Bennison gives us a roundup of the construction activities of the ruler in western Islam from the Umayyads to the Almohads. She underlines the development from the Alcazar in Cordoba, next to the mosque, to the grand palatine city of Madinat al-Zahra, the western equivalent of the Round City of Baghdad, to the Almohad palace quarter attached to the city of Marrakesh, a typological development that is well paralleled elsewhere.
Jonathan Bloom follows this with a monographic study of Fatimid al-Qahira, an urban history that is much needed. He reaches the conclusion that it started out as a military camp but became the palatial centre of the dynasty. It is curious that Bloom does not exploit the possibilities of archaeological parallels. If he had done so, he would have appreciated that military accommodation was always a major element of the palatine cities, although frequently the texts do not headline this point, and it may be difficult to dig out. It is a question of degree; there was either more or less military and a bigger or smaller palace. The point is well illustrated at Samarra, where al-Mutawakkiliyya (859–61) is mainly palace and elite housing while the cantonment of the Turks at al-Karkh is mainly military, but the same model is followed.
The palatine cities died out in the 11th century, and the following chapter by David Thomas treats a later model: the summer capital of the Ghurids at Firuzkuh (modern-day Jam) in Afghanistan. Thomas and his team have done well to recover traces of the settlement around the famous minaret. In the mountains, it was small and clearly a city dependent for its fortunes on the dynasty.
In the following chapter, Stephen Blake compares the later palatine settlement of the Moghul Akbar at Fathpur Sikri to Safavid Isfahan. It is a slightly bizarre comparison because Fathpur Sikri is a palatine city founded on a fresh site that subsequently failed for lack of water, whereas Safavid Isfahan is a palatial suburb to an existing organic city, in the style of the Almohad additions to Marrakesh, as mentioned by Bennison. Of course, study of Fathpur Sikri has been limited to the palace area, and this is what probably led to the comparison. It is interesting to note, however, that the Moghuls here went back to the earlier idea of a palatine city, an idea that had disappeared in the Middle East.
The third section treats the impact of religion on the city. Gascoigne focuses on the water supply of Tinnis in the Nile delta. The Tinnis economy was mostly supported through textile weaving, but it was surrounded by saline waters. Gascoigne studies the archaeological evidence of the cisterns, one of which may have been situated under the mosque, and the texts that speak increasingly as time goes on of the religious obligation of supplying water, no doubt as the water supply became more difficult, until residents were reduced to bringing water in boats.
Athena Syrakoy reconstructs the Nasrid māristān of Grenada, a good example of Islamic hospitals. Finally, Nicolas Warner studies the Ottoman complex of Ridwan Bey in Cairo. Typically, this 17th-century complex included a palace, a market street, several mosques, and a wikāla, the Egyptian term for an urban khan. Warner does well to reassemble this dispersed complex, especially in light of difficulties finding a single site in central Cairo in Ottoman times.
As might be expected from the publication of a colloquium, this volume is a good effort, interesting in the details, but it lacks an overall vision of the development of cities in Islam.
