This lucid and thoughtful book explores the idea that ‘psychagogy’ was an important guiding theme and grounding project throughout Augustine's life. ‘Psychagogy’ is understood in two senses: as guidance for one's own soul and that of others. What is involved is a process that combines intellectual or scholarly and ethical or spiritual dimensions. Crucially, for Augustine, as Kolbet presents him, the process forms an ongoing, and inevitably incomplete, journey towards spiritual understanding. Although Augustine became increasingly confident that Christianity offers the ultimate truth, he retained a view of Christian belief and practice as an interpretative and ethical quest (not adherence to a fixed, authoritative dogma), and his view of the rôle of psychagogy was integrally linked with this view. This motif is also linked by K. with Augustine's famous emphasis on the importance of God's grace. Although humans should do all they can (by both faith and works) to move towards spiritual perfection, our success depends on God, who also forgives our failure. K. finds the roots of Augustine's thinking about psychagogy in Classical sources, especially Platonic and Hellenistic (particularly Stoic) ideas about philosophy as therapy of the soul and about life as a continuing and (in some sense) spiritual journey. Hence, although Augustine is critical of many aspects of Greco-Roman antiquity, this Classical ideal remains a powerful influence on him.
After an introduction setting out clearly the main thesis, the book is divided into three parts. The first part offers an overview of psychagogy in its Classical form, principally Platonic and Hellenistic philosophical thinking on the therapy of the soul. This review is reliable (though highly familiar to anyone who knows this material). In this section K. explicitly goes beyond the sources that Augustine himself refers to, which are primarily Cicero, Seneca, and Plotinus (the latter is the main medium of Platonic ideas) (14). This is a defensible procedure; but it would have been helpful to have a more specific attempt to reconstruct exactly what Augustine knew of this tradition, as well as analysis of any explicit statements by Augustine about how he was adapting it. The main focus, throughout the book, is, rather, on the way in which Augustine (as K. maintains) reshapes this Classical ideal for his own concerns. This account is highly illuminating on its own terms; but I think the overall case would have been strengthened by a more detailed treatment of Augustine's reception of Classical texts than is offered here.
In the second part, K. retraces Augustine's professional movement from being a Classical-style orator (holding the public chair of rhetoric in Milan in a.d. 384–6) to his appointment as Christian priest and then bishop of Hippo in his native North Africa (in a.d. 395). He also outlines Augustine's spiritual journey, including his early rejection of (purely) rhetorical practice, his increasing engagement with philosophical ideas, and his response to the challenge — an initially unwelcome one — of combining the practical and public duties of a bishop with the reflective life to which he was more strongly inclined. This story has often been told (above all by Augustine himself in the emotionally intense and impressionistic Confessions). But K. focuses on the idea that this whole odyssey can be understood as a continuing re-interpretation of what the Classical ideal of ‘psychagogy’ meant, a claim fully documented by reference to a broad range of Augustine's writings during these years.
This idea is carefully worked out in a way that makes K.'s second part unified and coherent. However, the most innovative part of the book (as K. himself suggests) is the third. This centres on discussion of Augustine's sermons, a substantial and largely unstudied part of his writings, and on his rôle as a public preacher. K. suggests that in this way Augustine evolved a spiritually transformed version of his earlier rôle as a Classical-style orator. At the same time, Augustine worked out through this medium the two dimensions (self- and other-related) of psychagogy, by leading his congregation to engage in the spiritual and interpretative journey to which he was committed. In this way, Augustine converts a practice (therapy of the soul) formulated originally by a Greco-Roman intellectual élite, into one that, as well as being thoroughly Christianized, was also redirected at engaging a much broader social group, many of whom were not necessarily literate.
K.'s overall thesis is an interesting and credible one and one that is lucidly and attractively presented. As indicated earlier, I think that the book would have gained from a more detailed examination of Augustine's knowledge of, and explicit comments on, the Classical sources for the idea of psychagogy. I am not qualified to say whether K.'s account would convince experts on Augustine; but it is certainly coherently argued and supported by very full reference to Augustine's writings and relevant scholarship. It is a book that has a good deal to offer readers such as myself, who approach it from the study of ancient therapy of the emotions, as well as scholars and students of Late Antiquity and the interface between Classical and Christian ideas.
