Heavenly Merchandize is essential reading for anyone who hopes to understand the evolution of moral teaching about markets in early American history. For 150 years before the War of Independence, the American colonies in New England struggled to grow economically while remaining true to their Protestant Puritan moorings, even as the intellectual and political landscape was constantly shifting. Tracing out the complexities of this journey is, at times, tedious, with scores of preachers and merchants referenced, requiring nearly seventy pages of notes and references. Absorbing the details takes time but is rewarding in many ways, despite the anecdotal nature of the narrative.
The book begins with the stories of merchants Robert Keayne and John Hull. The battle between the moral codes of civic humanism and orthodox Puritan piety comes through clearly, as each struggled mightily with their own conscience, their commercial enterprises, and the church that was determined to exercise religious discipline over commerce. John Cotton and other clergy of the mid-seventeenth century condemned usury, prices above meager markups, legal attempts to recover accounts receivable, and displays of luxury when social needs and poverty were present in the community. Church discipline could be severe, and excommunication was always a threat. The struggle between clergy and merchants is not presented as two opposing parties in conflict. Rather, that struggle is shown to be a sincere effort on the part of all to build a social order that could be economically and morally viable. By being successful in business, by exhibiting a devout faith, and by contributing much to the general welfare of the community, Keayne and Hull laid the foundation for changing the conceptions of church, providence, and the civic order.
The changes that led to more acceptance of profitable commerce came as the political environment in Europe became more divided. The colonists viewed England as being champions of Protestantism and liberty, while France represented Catholicism and tyranny. Clergy led by Samuel Willard, Cotton Mather, and Increase Mather began preaching that market competition—and England’s battle with Catholic France—was the basis for God’s rule in the world. Linkages between the religious, civic, and economic order became increasingly common, as the chapter on Samuel Sewall illustrates.
All this was still framed in the context of a providential plan for the world, so market economics could still be justified, despite its secular tendencies. In this section of the book, key figures in the history of economic thought of the seventeenth century are frequently discussed. Thomas Mun, William Petty, and Josiah Child are examples of those who promoted mercantilism with its array of policy recommendations. Churchmen readily identified with the productive value of overseas trade, and this elevated the moral stature of merchants. Concern is expressed about speculation in bills of credit, stock trading, or other profit schemes not related to foreign trade, but, by the early decades of the eighteenth century, concerns about normal commercial instruments such as usury had all but disappeared. In a paper called “The Maxims of Piety,” Cotton Mather listed what served as a general expectation for Christian merchants. The key doctrinal issues were the belief in the Trinity and the necessary role of Christ for salvation. In addition, a display of public spirit and the virtues of charity and fair dealing were the behavioral expectations. Clearly, the detailed restrictions were being dropped in favor of accommodation to a new way of thinking about economic issues.
As the eighteenth century progressed, there were new ways of looking at social organization. The hand of providence was seen in the creation of natural systems rather than in hands-on determinism. The created order included appropriately constructed markets that led to the social good. Under the influence of Enlightenment thinkers such as Anthony Shaftesbury, moral behavior was derived from sentiments, and passions instilled in humans by the Creator. Given the proper care, there was an inherent harmony among the psychological, social, economic, and moral components of society. In Valeri’s words, the puritan preachers of the early and mid-1700s “began to understand the market not merely as a political good but as a universal and natural imperative” (p. 177). However, they still did not separate the market from religious concepts, so economic rationality and politeness, though necessary, were not sufficient qualities for the true believer.
The latter part of the book describes increasing secularization of the church’s position on the market economy. The notion that markets fostered increased sociability, politeness, loyalty, and deference led a new generation of preachers to see markets as an instrument promoting religious values. The chapter on Hugh Hall illustrates how merchants began to see their most ambitious tactics as a contribution to the fulfillment of the divine law of creation, and, in the process, market capitalism and Christianity became co-promoters of the divine plan. Religious regulations against high consumption were changed to relate to personal attitudes toward luxuries, and polite behavior was viewed as a Christian virtue. Even extensive slave trade escaped the rebuke of the clergy when other private and public virtues were apparent. All this did not mean that the merchants were skeptical of the Christian religion. Instead, they were deeply religious. Personal piety and actions for social good were prominent in their discourse and action. What changed is that religion and commerce were now complements rather than substitutes in the social order. Valeri concludes that:
By the 1740s, it was a given: God had made the laws of commerce; they were instruments of providence. No one seriously doubted that the commodification of credit, rational pricing, civil litigation, entrepreneurial ambition, and slave trading expressed diligence and acuity. They fulfilled the vocations of overseas merchants, who maintained their moral balance through the practice of refinement and gentility. (p. 233)
The book closes with some reflection on the religious revival movement of the early and mid-eighteenth century. Preachers such as George Whitefield encouraged merchants to focus on true spiritual riches and a vital religion from which virtue could flourish. With this foundation, the more temporal and material blessings of markets could properly be enjoyed in the spirit of humility. Spiritual values would also help the merchants and the social order deal with the difficult times that came with mismanaged monetary policy, declining trade opportunities, and increasing restrictions on commerce from England.
The most significant contribution of this book is the way it illustrates how social-system analysis must be understood in the historical context in which it occurs. This has many important ramifications that come though clearly in the chapters. First, some analysis is necessary to discern what drives what. Does religion adapt itself to changing situations or does changing religious belief influence circumstances? This study is helpful in approaching this complicated question. Second, the importance of trade as a stimulus to economic development comes through clearly, putting new light on the mercantilist controversy of the eighteenth century. Third, the early Puritan religious constraints on commerce qualify, to some degree, Max Weber’s Protestant ethic argument, but the later accommodation of commerce by Puritan clergy lends support to the thesis.
In addition to the historical insights of the book, there are other interesting issues entertained. First, the power of scientific rationality over custom and belief creates persistent challenges for religion as a revealed faith. Second, the lack of reliable legal and financial institutions severely limits trade possibilities, so traders must rely on the limited reach of trust to make trade flow. This is a relevant insight for development in any time and place. Finally, the acceptance of slave trade as legitimate for Christians is evidence that markets alone do not provide a moral compass for an economy. The stories in this book speak to the need for some moral component apart from the mechanics of trade.
In summary, I highly recommend this book for all these good qualities. It is not an easy read because the enormous volume of material surveyed is scattered across the chapters in ways that make chronological tracking difficult at times. Hundreds of people are referenced but only the most prominent are developed as key characters, and many minute details are included from diaries, sermon notes, and miscellaneous writing. Given the anecdotal nature of the content, the education level of the masses in New England, and the lack of aggregate data, it is hard to get a clear picture of what market capitalism and democracy meant in this era of strong individual personalities. In spite of these constraints, Valeri has made a valuable contribution to an understanding of early American economics and religion.
