Through the Lens of Allen E. Cole is a well-researched introduction to the work of Cleveland's foremost early African American photographer. Cole was born in West Virginia in 1883. His father, Allen Cole Sr., was an industrious individual who worked as a craftsman, blacksmith, and wagon maker. From the time he could lift a hammer, Allen Jr. helped his father in his blacksmith shop until he went away to Storer College in Harpers Ferry in West Virginia. Cole's family was also held together by Stewart Chapel African Methodist Episcopal Church. Altogether, family life in rural West Virginia, faith, and African American organizations and institutions prepared Allen Cole Jr. for his professional work as a visual storyteller.
Samuel Black and Regennia Williams examine Cole's professional work in context, linking it to important milestones in African American history. Cole was drawn to the world of professional photography at the turn of the century, when the steady pace of black migration to cities across America created opportunity and subject matter for black photographers. They began to provide services to an emergent clientele that included families, churches, businesses, fraternal groups, women's clubs, political organizations, neighborhood groups, and social-service centers. In Cleveland, Cole's potential customer base had reached 34,000 people by 1925.
Therefore the authors emphasize that Allen Cole did not establish a successful photography business depicting the black community in Cleveland as poverty-stricken and violent – stereotypes that already dominated American popular culture. Cole's photographs expressed the values and beliefs of the African American middle class, in which the ideology of racial uplift was a persistent visual theme. Cole succeeded in producing such imagery because he was deeply entrenched in the political, social, and business affairs of the Cleveland community, sharing their values and beliefs in thrift, industriousness, and the pursuit of education.
Cole's influence can be seen in the illustrations he provided for Cleveland's new weekly black newspaper, the Call & Post. The paper was established in the late 1920s by editor and publisher William O. Walker. Walker made a strategic decision in hiring Cole on the grounds that he brought a large core of patrons who knew that their portraits might appear in the new weekly. Cole's ability to bring in community participation can be seen in a photograph essay series he produced for the paper's “newsboy competition” in 1934. Cole covered the story and kept the community interested with his publicity portraits of the contest participants. The culminating photograph that appeared in the Call & Post on 29 December 1934 featured all of the participants with their awards. It is one of the best examples illustrating how Cole understood and strived to convey black Cleveland's pride in family, work, and community through the lens of the camera.
Cole's standing in the community enabled him to present images connected to spiritual belief and practice with the same respect and pride. One of his most innovative series of pictures documented the funeral rituals that marked the passing of “Professor” Tomlinson in 1933. As an Elk and a Mason, Cole was allowed to photograph some of the more “hidden” rituals associated with fraternal orders and secret societies, such as the “guardian ritual” that occurred the night before Tomlinson's elaborate funeral. It is a richly detailed work of art that brings a visual dimension to the study of African American sacred culture. The authors suggest that it indicates the presence of African-influenced spiritual traditions in Cleveland.
By investigating Cole's work from the inside out the authors show that photographs can no longer be studied primarily as images that simply replicate the real world. It is just as critical to look at the social functions of photography and its influence on modern societies through its many modes of representation. While early black photographers employed the medium as a means of social documentation, the images were just as effective as powerful, counteractive material against racism.
Cole was an accomplished photographer, entrepreneur, and “race” man whose creative work can be situated within a turn-of-the-century African American photographic practice influenced by racial uplift ideology. Through the Lens of Allen E. Cole is a beginning study that raises evocative questions about the early history of African American photography from a regional perspective.
