This very insightful volume discusses a segment of the population that does not “formally” exist: namely, the informal sector that functions in the underground economy. The book describes individual and firm characteristics in the informal sector, analyzes the reasons for joining the informal sector and the incentives of the institutional framework within it, and provides policy recommendations to incorporate the informal part of the economy into the social security and welfare system. The book focuses on Latin American countries. In its analysis, the book uses Latin American country employment surveys and presents the results of data collection about preferences for informal employment in urban areas of Argentina, Bolivia, Colombia, and the Dominican Republic. It also includes a thorough literature review of the topic.
The authors contend it is important to understand this “shadow economy” for a number of reasons. The shadow economy has an impact on the productivity and growth of the formal economy; in addition, a share of the families working within the informal sector live without social security protection or welfare programs and workers have less access to contract enforcement mechanisms and the courts. All of this can lead to the erosion of institutions and to government failures. Even more, the authors show a negative correlation between the size of a country's informal sector and its economic growth.
The authors also discuss what the informal sector is and how to classify it, noting that it consists of individuals and firms outside formal institutions. The book shows who the most prevalent players are in the informal sector: young people who need to accumulate work experience to gain access to a job in the formal sector, low-skilled individuals, workers in small firms with less than five employees, entrepreneurs, older individuals who cannot reenter the formal labor market after being laid off, and women of childbearing age. The characteristics of most firms in the informal sector are small and have a low potential to grow, have lower levels of productivity, and lack access to credit and other public services. This sector also includes middle-size firms that have a share of workers who are off the books. The authors' description shows how heterogeneous the informal sector is in terms of the individuals within it.
The informal sector, according to the book, includes both voluntary and involuntary salaried workers and the self-employed. Voluntary workers opt out of the formal system, while involuntary ones are unable to join the formal sector. Most of self-employed are voluntary and many of the salaried workers in the informal sector are involuntary. Those who are part of the informal sector value it because it provides such non-pecuniary benefits as flexibility of work hours, autonomy, or the ability to avoid paying duplicate taxation (for example, in some countries, when one family member is in the formal sector, all family members are covered by the worker's health care insurance).
Salaried workers in the informal sector include a high proportion of young workers, while self-employed workers consist of middle-age or older workers with expertise or training acquired as salaried workers in the formal sector. In many countries, there is constant migration between the formal and informal sectors. The authors suggest that involuntary workers eventually leave the informal sector, which makes it a transitory state. Young salaried workers grow dissatisfied in the informal sector and prefer moving to the formal sector. The entrepreneurial group in the informal sector is relatively better-off than other groups there. Highly productive firms move from the informal to the formal sector, but those firms with less potential stay in the informal sector.
In terms of wage differentials across sectors, there is no a priori assumption that wages should be higher in one sector than in the other one. The authors find higher salaries for informal self-employed individuals, who include lawyers, teachers, doctors, small firm owners, and artisans. Some Latin American countries, such as Argentina and Bolivia, show higher segmentation between sectors for salaried workers, but in Mexico there is very low segmentation. In Mexico and Brazil, there is higher labor turnover for informal salaried workers, and they are more likely to move to unemployment than are formal salaried workers. Macro shocks also have a stronger effect in informal salaried workers than on formal salaried workers. The proportion of individuals in the informal sector is highly correlated with the economic performance of the formal sector, with the proportion of individuals in the informal sector increasing when there are economic downturns. Salaries in the informal sector are more flexible and adjust more in economic crisis than do salaries in the formal sector. Workers in the formal sector value social security benefits, and formal self-employed workers report having the highest rates of job satisfaction compared to the other groups (formal salaried, informal salaried, and informal self-employed workers).
The authors note that institutional arrangements might provide individuals with incentives to move to the informal sector. Among these arrangements are high payroll contributions, the bundling of benefit packages (mandatory contribution to health care, life insurance, pensions, housing, among others), the lack of government effectiveness in providing services, government corruption, the lack of government enforcement, outdated labor regulation, overregulation, low opportunity costs to remaining informal, and barriers for entrepreneurial activity.
The authors suggest that providing those families in the informal sector with basic social security benefits and other welfare programs to help insure against risks (unemployment, disasters, among others) should be universal and should be paid through general taxation. They show that even accounting for informal mechanisms (social and community networks), households cannot fully insure themselves against income and health shocks. Health shocks may be even more difficult to insure against depending on the severity of the illness, with poor households being the most affected. The authors also propose targeting policies to improve the productivity of firms in the informal sector. In sum, this is a unique comprehensive analysis of the dynamics of the underground economy and transitions between the formal and informal sectors.
