David S. Brown has written a meticulously researched, brilliant study of the intellectual thought of one of the eminent American historians of our time, Richard Hofstadter. He seeks to explicate Hofstadter's most important breakthroughs in historical interpretation, to connect his life to his work, and to give attention to criticisms of his writings as well. Professor Brown succeeds and demonstrates that Richard Hofstadter, despite the many problems with the ground-breaking interpretations he championed, is more relevant than ever.
He begins with Hofstadter's roots and education. Many factors influenced the young man, including his parents' immigrant background, their cosmopolitanism, and the Great Depression. As was the case with many 1930s intellectuals, Hofstadter consequently became a sharp critic of capitalism. He rejected communism due to its intellectual rigidity and regimentation; but his first major work, Social Darwinism in American Thought, reflected his Depression-era disillusionment with free markets and his resultant New Deal liberalism. His book critiqued the historical role that economic individualism played in American life, especially what he saw as the rapacious capitalism of the Gilded Age.
His next book, The American Political Tradition and the Men Who Made It, continues this line of thinking. Hofstadter first playfully explored the many ironies and foibles of America's political history. He showed, for example, how America's founders often criticized and stymied democracy and that Lincoln, the emancipator, was also a political opportunist. But mainly he sought to examine the limitations of the different governing philosophies dominating America prior to 1933 and to criticize the notion that American political history was one, long morality play between “the interests” and “the people.” He further implicitly suggested the utility of avoiding rigid ideologies and moral crusades, and he hinted at the need for the consolidation of the gains made by the New Deal. Thus was born the “consensus” view of American history, though for years Hofstadter denied that this was his intention.
The American Political Tradition made Hofstadter famous, and his life between 1950 and 1965 saw him a fully “engaged” scholar. Hofstadter was a prolific writer, who in adopting the theories of psychological/social theorists such as Theodore Adorno and Karl Mannheim during this period and applying them to historical study, broke new intellectual ground. This achievement led him to write The Age of Reform, a sharp critique of the supposed intolerance and status anxieties existing among Populist leaders who, Hofstadter claimed, mainly wanted to retain their social and cultural privileges. He then wrote Anti-Intellectualism in American Life, arguing that suspicion of expertise was a theme running throughout American history, that too often Americans rejected intellectual challenges to orthodoxy in favor of iconic views of cowboys and frontiersmen. It was, in many ways, a condemnation of mass democracy, the thinking of which, Hofstadter was coming to believe, might not always lead to salutary New Deal-type reforms, but could end up in ill-considered hostilities and resentments. Then, Hofstadter criticized the rise of McCarthyism, Goldwaterism, and conservatism in general. He had grown more and more fascinated with what he saw as the role of irrational behavior in history, and he believed that McCarthyism was a perfect example of it. Thus, he contended that the American Right in the form of McCarthyism mistook the normal workings of history for conspiracy and was subject to irrational paranoia and status anxieties. Barry Goldwater's fierce anticommunism and antigovernment ideology similarly struck Hofstadter as frightening extremism in an age of nuclear weapons and government-secured prosperity; he feared that Goldwaterism and its supporters were a threat to the established two-party system. This conclusion culminated in Hofstadter's book The Paranoid Style in American Politics.
Hofstadter's work was controversial and earned him criticism. Brown does not ignore this. Critics of The Age of Reform jabbed away, suggesting that he was finding MCarthyism under every bed, and arguing that hidden psychological impulses ascribed to others could not be easily proven or disproved. Anti-Intellectualism in American Life struck many as a partisan response, from an Adlai Stevenson supporter (which Hofstadter was in 1952) to the anti-intellectualism supposedly manifested in the Eisenhower years. How could a lionized member of the intellectual elite such as Hofstadter imply that intellectuals were marginalized? Meanwhile, The Paranoid Style in American Politics failed to take the real concerns of conservative Americans—of excessive government regulation, of American failures in the Cold War—seriously, waving them aside as irrational, paranoid, psychological impulses.
Indeed, Hofstadter's final years were not always happy ones, as he faced illness, the student protests of the 1960s, and the demise of consensus liberalism. Hofstadter agreed with radical students in their criticisms of the Vietnam War, which is ironic given that these students were deeply critical of him. Yet he sharply disagreed with such radical tactics as the disruption of classes. His calls for the preservation of civility as essential to instruction were out of step with the radicalism of the 1960s, just as his later work—including a defense of America's two-party system—was out of touch with the new focus on monographic social history.
Hofstadter died far too young, in 1970 at the age of 54, of leukemia. Brown does an excellent job of connecting Hofstadter's work to his life and personality. He was a man of disciplined work habits, with a personality at times playful, at times full of melancholy (which is reflected in his writing, from his ironic jabs at America's founders to his frustrated musings on anti-intellectualism). His work, therefore, was sometimes erratic, sometimes contradictory, and certainly his conclusions were affected by his partisan biases. But Hofstadter's writings remain very much alive and relevant today. He was a historian who sought to write for a mass audience, who desired not only to illuminate the past, but also to show why it remained relevant today. Hofstadter was very much a public intellectual, engaged with the then and the now, and David S. Brown has brilliantly shown us just why his attempts to challenge orthodoxy and break new ground were relevant then, with all their flaws, and why they continue to be so today.
