Reviewing Lange and Madsen's collection of investigations into Cassius Dio's Roman History already has the feel of a retrospective, even though only three years have passed since its publication. The editors themselves indicate why in their introduction. They begin not with a summary of the papers which follow, or the conference from which the volume resulted, but with an overview of the aims of the international Cassius Dio Network (1–4). Publication of this volume coincided with the Network's first gathering in late 2016. Five more multi-day conferences followed, contributing to a glut in new scholarship on Dio which has yet to reach its peak (my own involvement with the Network's events informs my perspective here). The same Brill series has already published two further conference proceedings (C. Burden-Strevens and M. Lindholmer (eds), Cassius Dio's Forgotten History of Early Rome (2018) and J. Osgood and C. Baron (eds), Cassius Dio and the Late Roman Republic (2019)); several more edited volumes and monographs are in development. This volume is therefore best understood as only the opening salvo in a much more extensive barrage of new scholarship on Dio.
L. and M. divide the sixteen contributions into three sections: five papers on Dio's narrative of the transition from Republic to Principate; four covering imperial — primarily Severan — history; and seven discussions grouped under the broad heading ‘Rhetoric and Speeches’. It is not my intention to offer a detailed review of the individual analyses, though several will be referred to where appropriate. Instead, I consider how the volume as a whole advances the editors’ self-professed aim of transforming modern views of Dio, ‘from a historian sometimes judged as mediocre, to a politician and intellectual steeped in Roman history and historiography’ (1). It is inevitable that a selection of sixteen case-studies investigating an eighty-book history which originally covered a full millennium cannot act as a definitive re-shaping of Dio's reputation. Even so, reading across the volume as a whole quickly justifies the editors’ position.
At its best, this is a collection which highlights very effectively Dio's control over what was an enormous literary undertaking. The discussions of Dio's speeches, especially clear in the chapters by C. Burden-Strevens (191–216), A. Fomin (217–37) and A. Kemezis (238–57), offer a clear example. The repeated connections between speeches and Dio's explorations of political events show an author doing much more than displaying rhetorical skill. Alongside C. Mallan on parrhesia (258–75) and M. Coudry on Pompey (33–50), they feed into a wide-ranging demonstration of Dio's view of the collapse of the Republic as inevitable under the weight of the self-interest of its leading figures. The same could be said for Dio's presentation of tyranny. Among the Severan papers, J. M. Madsen (136–58) and J. Osgood (177–90) are highly effective in showing the depth of connections between Dio's contemporary books and his earlier imperial narrative, the latter in particular highlighting how the denigration of Elagabalus operates in specifically Dionean terms.
If readers are likely to be able to find such connections relatively easily, even without explicit guidance, there are further rewards available for those who go beyond the more obviously linked titles. V. Schulz (276–96) and G. Urso (11–32), primarily exploring Dio's accounts of Domitian and Sulla respectively, provide an effective foil to the Severan studies. Their discussions of how Dio responds to imperial representation are not only effective in their own right; they remind any reader interested in questions of imperial representation in Dio's narrative of the value of exploring beyond the bounds of their specific period. Moreover, this extends beyond the apparent division between Republic and Empire which the editors themselves maintain. C. H. Lange's investigation of triumphs (92–114) feels somewhat circumscribed in its categorisation as part of the transition from Republic to Principate, extending as far as Nero. C. Mallan (258–75) and B. Jones (297–315) are even wider-ranging, each including events from the Republic to Dio's contemporary books. As a result, while the organisation of papers into distinct sections is understandable, it rather undersells their cumulative effect. It might have been useful if the editors had included an afterword framing the relationships between individual studies. As it stands, scholars interested in Dio risk missing out on interesting areas of comparison, simply for the limited invitation to look for them.
Given the volume's framing as a starting point for something on a much grander scale, there are unsurprisingly areas of weakness. Most striking — and here, the impact of three years of Network meetings is felt especially strongly — is the limited concern about the state of the Roman History as a text. Several chapters depend on Xiphilinus’ epitomised version (Gowing, Madsen, Rantala, Osgood, Schulz), which also impacts on more general arguments from Dio's apparent silence on certain topics. A. M. Gowing is typical of the response when discussing Dio's apparent lack of interest in the city of Rome (132, with my emphasis): ‘Here, of course, we must confront the serious question of what Xiphilinus has omitted and what he has kept. But if Xiphilinus may be trusted, Dio says hardly anything at all about the Forum.’ The acceptance of epitomised texts as representative of Dio's original narrative is hardly exceptional. Three years and numerous conferences later, I would be very surprised if the same approach were taken. Here, the total absence of Christopher Mallan's elaboration of Xiphilinus’ methods as an epitomator (GRBS 53/3 (2013), 610–44) is telling.
Reading across the different papers from a more prosaically editorial perspective highlights wider challenges in the study of Dio. At first glance, the editors have made Dio accessible. All Greek quotations are translated into English, usually adapted from Cary's Loeb. Yet there are inconsistencies which continue to make the Roman History a deeply unfriendly text. For the most part, the editors have maintained the most common model of combining the book divisions employed by Boissevain alongside the earlier standard, along the lines of 73[72].17.1. That has not been done consistently, however. A reference to ‘62.14.2’ may appear innocuous enough (214 n. 90), but when book 62 has three separate 14.2s, the uninitiated are hardly well served. Gowing chooses to include [Xiph.] to mark passages taken from Xiphilinus; his is the only paper to do so, and even then it is inconsistent. These are unlikely to cause any issues for experts in Dio; newcomers will find no help in navigating any resultant confusion.
Yet for all its potential shortcomings, I cannot stress enough this volume's importance as a project. Problems stand out because these papers do not fully represent the field even now. These are precisely the discussions which have been allowed to play out through gatherings of Dio scholars, made possible by the success of the first conference. L. and M. are worthy of considerable praise for their role in bringing that about. It is certainly possible to find fault with the content of this volume. What is beyond question, however, is its transformative role in our understanding of a historiographical narrative which is vital to reconstructions of so much of Roman history.
