The purpose of this study, as expressed by Dionysius Agius in the first chapter of Classic Ships of Islam, is to “journey into the past” in order to reconstruct the history of seafaring during the early and middle medieval Islamic period in a vast geographical area, which extends from East Africa to West India. This multifaceted description of Islamic navigation is based on a great variety of archaeological, textual, and pictorial sources.
Chapter 2, “Early Maritime Contacts,” offers “important highlights of early maritime contacts from the Bronze Age to the emergence of Islam.” This represents an unnecessary deviation from the study's main objective, because the navigation of this very long period is not Islamic; besides, the author could not claim “expertise in pre-Islamic history and archeology” (p. 38). Instead of this digression the author should have studied the circumstances and activities of pre-Islamic Byzantine and Sassanid navigation, which is closely connected with the origins of Islamic seafaring. In this case, Agius would benefit from the rich information on navigation in the seas of the East, provided by the Byzantine sources of the 6th century (Malalas, Procopius, Martyrium Arethae, Cosmas Indicopleustes), in order to come to a better understanding of the origins of Islamic navigation (see J. Ch. Dimitroukas, Reisen und Verkehr im Byzantinischen Reich vom Anfang des 6. bis zur Mitte des 11. Jh.s [Athens: n.p., 1997], 505–10).
In Chapter 3, “Trade and Port Towns of the Classical and Medieval Islamic Period,” Agius examines the “general features of trade and some of the most important harbour towns . . . of Islam” (p. 65). Therein, he comes to the conclusion that during the first period (7th–10th centuries) of Islamic navigation the Persian Gulf was the center of trade with the East, and during the second period (10th–12th centuries) the commercial activities were shifted to and intensified in the Red Sea.
In Chapter 4, “Primitive Boats and Bronze Age Construction Features,” Agius describes various types of primitive watercraft and some construction methods of reed boats. Some illustrations in this chapter are also of some importance for the history of Byzantine communications, especially for the famous emigration of the philosophers of the neo-Platonic school in Athens to the court of the great Persian king Khosrau I (ca. 532 A.D.); probably they crossed the Mesopotamian rivers in such a kelek as the one we see in illustration 17 sailing down the Tigris River (M. Tardieu, Les paysages reliques [Paris: Louvain 1990], 71ff).
In Chapter 5, “Construction Features of Persian-Arabian and West Indian Ships in Medieval Islam,” the author describes instruments, materials, and methods of the construction of Islamic ships. The presentation is somewhat confusing, so that questions concerning the shape of the sternpost of the Islamic ships (p. 159) or the dating of the two main shipbuilding methods (p. 155–56) arise. Beside these ambiguities, Agius accepts (p. 154) the incorrect thesis that in the early period of Islam the Mediterranean Arabian warships were larger than the Byzantine ones.
In Chapter 6, “Seamanship,” Agius deals with various topics, some of which are important from the viewpoint of maritime technology: crews, maps, manuals, instruments, and the steering and sailing system of the Islamic ships. He tries often, but without success, to call into question traditional views on these topics. In contrast, his presentation becomes sometimes contradictory, as when he expresses different views concerning the introduction of lateen sail (“the two sails were in contemporaneous use,” “the lateen [was already in place] by 632” [p. 212]).
In Chapter 7, “The Ship at Sea: Trade and Hajj,” the author deals with the infrastructure of ports, customs and port duties, cargo ships and their size (e.g., the size of Chinese junks), the dangers of the sea, and the formation of convoys of vessels as a means of protection against pirates. In the final two fascinating sections he deals with rituals and superstitions dictated by the constant fear of the sea.
In Chapter 8, “The Ship at Sea: Naval Incursions,” Agius stresses the fact that although the Mediterranean Sea was dominated by the war of Islam against Byzantium, the east seas of Islam were mainly peaceful and dominated by trade until the arrival of the Portuguese. There, fleets were only rarely and ad hoc organized (p. 249–50). Concerning the supposed non-existence of a regular fleet and the naval preparedness of the Mamluks in the Mediterranean, he adopts (p. 262) the incorrect view of A. Fuess (see V. Christides, The Image of Cyprus in the Arabic Sources [Nicosia: n.p., 2006], 84ff).
In the following four chapters the author examines various ship types and divides them into groups: riverboats, pleasure crafts, warships, deep sea, and cargo. Agius analyzes the Islamic maritime technology and stresses the close relationship existing between the names of some Hellenistic/Byzantine and some Arabian/Islamic ship types. It is unfortunate that his understanding of maritime technology and naval war is very limited, as is demonstrated by some of his remarks on Islamic warships. He writes, for example, that four to six men of the crew of the warships corresponded to an oar (p. 330), a view that is to be rejected because the available space aboard a warship was very limited. Furthermore, he does not clearly distinguish between the various types of dromon (p. 331), that is, the original dromon, a light warship equipped with an iron ram that existed until the middle of the 6th century; the intermediary dromon-shini, a double-banked, slow-moving warship equipped with stone catapults, which was used in the sea battle of Phoinix/DhAt as-SawArI (655); and the late dromon-shini, the standard unit of the Byzantine and Arabic war fleets, a heavy warship equipped with a wooden castle and fire-launching tubes. Therefore, the author is also not in the position to distinguish between the different naval war tactics that correspond to the previously mentioned dromon types, that is, the old tactic of ramming and sinking the enemy's ships and the medieval one of burning or boarding and capturing them.
Generally speaking, most parts of Agius' excellently illustrated book are based on a deep knowledge of the Islamic sources and contain useful information for scholars and students of Islamic navigation; in contrast, there are some chapters that are rather irrelevant or lack a clear plan, and the structure of the material covered is not very well balanced. Another disadvantage of the study is the author's limited understanding of maritime technology, resulting in a sometimes contradictory picture of the Islamic ships. The vast bibliography reveals the author's scrupulous research, but he neglects some important Byzantine sources and works of Spanish specialists as well as of Greek scholars about both pre-Islamic and Islamic navigation.
