Published in 2016, Middle East Studies for the New Millennium focuses on the infrastructure of knowledge production on the Middle East in U.S. universities. It is the scholarly outcome of the first phase of a decade-long (2000–2010) research project organized by the Social Science Research Council (SSRC) in New York, which investigates area studies fields in U.S. universities, to examine the organization of international knowledge and international education in U.S. universities.
This edited volume draws on rich quantitative and qualitative data on area studies centers based at over fifteen U.S. universities. The process of data gathering has involved seventeen week-long site visits to twelve case study universities (both public and private, degree granting and non–degree granting) across the United States during the academic years 2005 to 2008. These qualitative site visits resulted in numerous ethnographic observations, and a total of 368 in-depth conversations with scholars and directors of area studies centers and focus groups. Additional sources of data included, but were not limited to, two national surveys of centers of area studies (which included 37 centers and 235 students), and also analysis of the Middle East Studies Association members database (452).
Informed by and reflexive of the multiple and contradictory burdens that MES scholars are facing, especially after events such as 9/11, the Iraq invasion, the so called “war on terror,” and the “Arab Spring,” this research expands on the historical study of institutionalization and infrastructure of Middle East studies during and especially after the Cold War. This emphasis on the material and institutional conditions of production of knowledge assists the research to historically trace the changing configuration of Middle East studies as a result of the post Cold War shift toward globalization theories, quantitative methods, and the so called “cultural and linguistic turn” in humanities.
Structurally, the book is divided into three parts. The first part, “Disciples and Their Boundaries,” allocates an article to each of the four disciplines of political science, sociology, economics, and geography in U.S. academia and the challenges and trajectories that each of them have in producing disciplinary knowledge about the Middle East. Lisa Wedeen, for example, discusses how normative conditions in political science, such as presupposing the value of liberal politics, are an integral part of the imperialism project in the Middle East, structuring the terms in which the Middle East is studied (32). Karen Pfeifer points to the penetration of Western neoclassical economic ideas and modeling techniques in the study of the Middle East (112), and the ways in which the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank Group further promote econometric methods and ideologically neoliberal assumptions in their role in producing knowledge on this region and supporting structural adjustment programs.
The second part, “Middle East Studies and the University,” discusses changing institutional forms and their affect on the organization of knowledge on the Middle East. Friedman and Miller-Idriss discuss why the internationalization of American universities in the context of education commercialization has not benefited area studies in their drive to increase expertise of the world beyond U.S. borders (191). Anderson Worden and Browne point to the realities of institutionalized knowledge to criticize the post 9/11 premise that universities should or even could produce specialists with language expertise to fill the government's needs (227).
The third part, “The Politics of Knowledge,” historicizes U.S.–Middle East relations to investigate the power dynamics that produce, and also silence, specific knowledge production on the Middle East. Ussama Makdisi criticizes both American neo-Orientalism and postcolonial nativism and proposes that instead there is need for a theory that appreciates the uneven and unequal dialectic that has characterized U.S.–Middle East relations (402).
In her afterword to the book, Lisa Anderson argues that “democratization” has succeeded “modernization” as the prevailing frame for American political science after the Cold War. She brilliantly discusses how this new framing masks its normative liberal bias behind the curtain of “technical objectivity” (434). Anderson suggests that initiatives to strengthen social sciences in the region will strengthen social science of the region (443). However, the limitation of research sites (as a result of travel warnings), along with limited fieldwork, and less scholarship are so threatening to the future of the field that, according to Anderson, we might anticipate a new generation of American social scientists without lived experience in most of the Middle East. This would easily result in mechanically applying analytical approaches and techniques designed for a very different context to the issues of the region. The scientific community in the region, on the other side, is also deprived of both reliable data and academic freedom (442).
This book certainly contributes to our understanding of how knowledge production in U.S. academia in the fields of area studies, and specifically Middle East Studies, operates in contemporary post-Cold War era. In this sense, the book is successful in linking the constitutional apparatus of American Orientalism to an institutional history of higher education in the United States (5). This edited volume fits very well in graduate courses on theory and method in Middle East studies, as it significantly broadens our knowledge of the material and institutional conditions of knowledge production on this region, as well as provides a historical understanding of the trends in its scholarship, theoretical and methodological shifts, and the challenging and changing relation between area studies and other humanities disciplines.
However, while the contributors share bold and precise criticism of the contemporary geopolitics of knowledge production in the field, the book overall falls short in presenting a synthesis of what should be done, specifically in terms of the relation between federal funding and Middle Eastern centers. Most contributors affirm and are worried about the growing crises in the field, yet their suggestions to resist this multi-layered phenomena are mainly limited to advocating interdisciplinary engagements or reform in neoliberal theories, and thus do not follow the sense of urgency embedded in their criticism. For instance, Reşat Kasaba suggests pushing the Title VI funding toward cross-disciplinary collaborations (105); Karen Pfeifer seeks to respond to failures of neoliberalism in the Middle East by stressing the necessity of localizing neoliberal policies, structures, and agendas (140); and Elizabeth Worden and Jeremy Brown support the idea that foreign language training for national defense agendas should start as early as high schools (247). I contend that the current geopolitics of knowledge production in the field, which is very well documented in this book, necessitates a bold theoretical and methodological intervention informed by a historical understanding of the internal relations of imperialism and ideology in this region. Such an intervention should also address creative methods of resistance and solidarity building within the scholarly world in the current era of securitization of knowledge.
