Empirical evidence demonstrates that minority and marginalized populations receive less and lower quality healthcare than more advantaged groups.1
Geiger HJ. Racial and ethnic disparities in diagnosis and treatment: A review of the evidence and a consideration of cause. In: Smedley BD, Stith AY, Nelson AR, eds. Unequal Treatment: Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Healthcare. Washington, D.C.: Institute of Medicine; 2003:417–54.
Powers M, Faden R. Racial and ethnic disparities in healthcare: An ethical analysis of when and how they matter. In: Smedley BD, Stith AY, Nelson AR, eds. Unequal Treatment: Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Healthcare. Washington, D.C.: Institute of Medicine; 2003:722–38.
Research into the causes of healthcare disparities tends to focus on race and ethnicity. Although race and ethnicity generally correlate with socioeconomic status (SES) in the United States, SES itself may be measured inconsistently, measured using inadequate proxies, or simply neglected.3
Krieger N, Williams DR, Moss NE. Measuring social class in US public health research: Concepts, methodologies, and guidelines. Annual Review of Public Health 1997;18:341–78; Williams DR, Collins C. US socioeconomic and racial differences in health: Patterns and explanations. Annual Review of Sociology 1995;21:349–86; Braveman P, Cubbin C, Egerter S, Chideya S, Marchi KS, Metzler M, Posner S. Socioeconomic status in health research: One size does not fit all. JAMA 2005;294:2879–88.
Comprehensive reforms will need to address non-healthcare sectors, because health disparities, which contribute to healthcare disparities, are the result not only of biologic–genetic differences and healthcare services, but, more importantly, cumulative effects of disparities in education, income, living and working environments, and broader societal, social, and environmental factors. Some health leaders suggest that more than 50% of population can be attributed to societal, social, and environmental factors. See Tarlov AR, St. Peter RF. Introduction. In: Tarlov AR, St. Peter RF, eds. The Society and Population Health Reader: A State and Community Perspective. New York: The New Press; 2000:x–xii.
Betancourt JR, Green AR, Carrillo JE, Park ER. Cultural competence and health care disparities: Key perspectives and trends. Health Affairs 2005;24:499–505.
SES-Related Sources of Healthcare Disparities
Possible sources of healthcare disparities implicate a range of U.S. institutions and actors. Factors include, for example, this nation's history of institutionalized racism, legal practices, current structures of care delivery, and clinician uncertainty and bias. The Institute of Medicine's (IOM) 2003 report Unequal Treatment: Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care identifies access-related factors as likely to be the “most significant barriers to equitable care,” (emphasis mine) and argues that they “must be addressed as an important first step toward eliminating healthcare disparities.”6
Committee on Understanding and Eliminating Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care. In: Smedley BD, Stith AY, Nelson AR, eds. Unequal Treatment: Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care. Washington, D.C.: Institute of Medicine; 2003:33.
See note 6, Committee on Understanding and Eliminating Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care 2003:5.
Sadly, most studies show that racial and ethnic disparities persist even after adjustment for income and insurance. The IOM committee was charged with examining only those healthcare disparities “not otherwise attributable to known factors such as access to care (e.g., ability to pay or insurance coverage).”8
See note 6, Committee on Understanding and Eliminating Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care 2003:3.
See note 6, Committee on Understanding and Eliminating Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care 2003:31.
The distinction between SES and race/ethnicity is somewhat artificial because racial and ethnic minorities are disproportionately represented in the lower SES groups. Class is mediated by race and ethnicity along numerous well-being indicators: Racial and ethnic minorities are disproportionately represented among those who live in or near poverty, drop out of high school, are unemployed, and lack health insurance.10
Maringoff M, Miringoff ML. The Social Health of the Nation. New York: Oxford University Press; 1999.
See note 3, Williams, Collins 1995.
Distinguishing between SES and race/ethnicity may be somewhat difficult for several reasons. Like race, low socioeconomic patient status has been shown to affect negatively the healthcare process12
See note 6, Committee on Understanding and Eliminating Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care 2003:151, 552–93, 1557–8.
See note 6, Committee on Understanding and Eliminating Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care 2003:398–400.
See note 6, Committee on Understanding and Eliminating Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care 2003:75.
Social class is a suppressed category in the United States. U.S. citizens often believe theirs is a classless society.15
Scott J, Leonhardt D. Class in America: Shadowy lines that still divide. New York Times 2005 May 15:A1, A16–8.
Racism too may go unrecognized, a very serious problem confounded with what researchers call “white privilege.”16
See, for example, Hartington J. Establishing the fact of whiteness. American Anthropologist 1997;99(3):495–505.
Physicians appear to share nonphysicians' negative attitudes toward persons of low SES. How they morally evaluate such attitudes is unclear. See Cooper LA, Roter DL. Patient-provider communication: The effect of race and ethnicity on process and outcomes of health care. In: Smedley BD, Stith AY, Nelson AR, eds. Unequal Treatment: Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Healthcare. Washington, D.C.: Institute of Medicine; 2003:552–91.
Some of the ambiguity that surrounds SES may relate to how it operates. SES commonly is measured by proxies such as income, education, and occupational status and treated as a snapshot in time. Increasingly, however, social scientists are recognizing the need to capture the dynamic and cumulative effects of SES and are doing so by using additional proxies and the standard ones in new ways.18
See note 3, Williams, Collins 1995:354; see note 3, Braveman et al. 2005.
As these remarks suggest, SES is more “process” than status.19
See note 3, Williams, Collins 1995:357.
Taylor SE, Repetti RL, Seeman T. Health psychology: What is an unhealthy environment and how does it get under the skin? Annual Review of Psychology 1997;48:411–47.
Keating DP, Hertzman C, eds. Developmental Health and the Wealth of Nations: Social, Biological, and Educational Dynamics. New York: The Guilford Press; 1999.
Some commentators correctly stress that social class may be neither static nor self-conscious for individuals.22
Levin BW, Schiller NG. Social class and medical decisionmaking: A neglected topic in bioethics. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 1998;7:41–56.
See note 3, Williams, Collins 1995:350.
Marmot M. The Status Syndrome: How Social Standing Affects Our Health and Longevity. New York: Henry Holt and Company; 2004.
Mechanic D. Rediscovering the social determinants of health. Health Affairs 2000;19:267–76, at 269.
This social gradient in health has implications for healthcare. The implications are not obvious and any adequate analysis would need to be informed by a detailed account of the characteristics of and systems for healthcare delivery. But, the health data cited above suggest at least this: Many patients most in need of the most healthcare may be disadvantaged not only by the fact of their illness, but in other ways as well, and this added disadvantage may have implications for the extent and kind of healthcare they need. They may need more routine care, for longer periods of time, and have fewer personal resources to devote to healing and fewer social resources on which to draw than better off patients. Yet, as the IOM report suggests, these same patients are likely to be disproportionately overrepresented in low-end healthcare plans because the delivery and financing of U.S. healthcare is fragmented along socioeconomic lines. The social gradient in health, then, may interact with a social gradient in healthcare in ways that compromise clinicians' and patients' efforts to deliver and receive care, respectively. Below, I identify and briefly treat social, material, and psychosocial issues related to SES that may adversely affect the healthcare process.
Social
The United States is the only industrialized nation that lacks a collective policy approach to ensure universal access to healthcare for its citizens. Instead, it has a patchwork approach that combines market and state solutions that is widely viewed as failing.26
For a survey of problems with U.S. healthcare, see a collection of articles in The New York Times Magazine, April 18, 2004, section 6.
Reinhardt U. Reforming the health care system: The universal dilemma. American Journal of Law and Medicine 1993;19:21–36, at 29.
At its best, U.S. healthcare is recognized as the most technologically advanced and innovative biomedicine in the world.28
See note 27, Reinhardt 1993:27.
Pear R. Health spending rises to record 15% of economy, New York Times 2004 Jan 9. Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/2004/01/09/politics/09HEAL.html?hp.
Koizumi K. National Institutes of Health in the FY 2003 budget. AAAS Report XXVII. Available at: http://www.aaas.org/spp/rd/03pch8.htm.
At its worst, U.S. healthcare represents yet another polarized social sector. Some 61 million U.S. adults have no healthcare coverage, sporadic coverage, or are chronically underinsured.31
Schoen C, Doty MM, Collins SR, Holmgren AL. Insured but not protected: How many adults are underinsured? Health Affairs Web Exclusive, 2005 June 14. Available at: http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/publications_show.htm?doc_id=280812#areaCitation.
Krisberg K. Census: 45 million Americans now lack health insurance: Number of uninsured jumps by 1 million. The Nation's Health 2004 Oct. 11. Available at: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/490352.
PR Newswire Association. CDC data show that millions of uninsured adults forgo needed treatment for chronic health conditions; Poll: Americans want Congress, President to make health coverage a priority. 2005 May 2. Available at: http://www.rwjf.org/newsroom/newsreleasesdetail.jsp?productid=21848.
Schoen C, Doty MM, Collins SR, Holmgren AL. Insured but not protected: How many adults are underinsured? Available at: http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/publications_show.htm?doc_id=280812#areaCitation. Jewell M. Harvard study: Illness, medical bills account for about half of bankruptcies. Associated Press 2005 Feb 2. Available at: http://www.wsws.org/articles/2005/feb2005/medi-f09.shtml
Medical insurance premiums have increased annually by 10% or more for the past 6 years, forcing businesses to drop coverage or shift more of the premium cost to employees.35
Business editors/health/medical writers. Six straight years of double-digit medical rate increases has had a significant impact on both employers and employees. Business Wire, Inc. 2005 Mar 3. Available at: http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0EIN/is_2005_March_3/ai_n11840829.
See, for example, Hatcher B. Nonprofit hospital's closing leaves community in a bind. Knight Ridder/Tribune Business News: Athens Banner-Herald 2004 Jun 15; Bankrupt Indianapolis hospital announces it will close. Associated Press State and Local Wire 2004 Sep 2; Raffaele M. Families, advocates express fears about Harrisburg State Hospital closing. Associated Press State and Local Wire 2005 Jan 27. Available at: http://www.thetimes-tribune.com/site/news.cfm?newsid=13840803&BRD=2185&PAG=461&dept_id=415898&rfi=8.
Simon S. States rein in health costs; Legislatures are looking to cut Medicaid or add fees. Missouri poised to end the program, which many of the poor rely upon for care. Los Angeles Times 2005 Apr 24:A1.
U.S. healthcare joins a list of other goods increasingly characterized by polarization.38
Kawachi I, Wilkinson R, Kennedy B. Introduction. In: Kawachi I, Kennedy BP, Wilkinson RG, eds. The Society and Population Health Reader: Income Inequality and Health. New York: The New Press; 1999:xi–xxxiv.
Wilkinson R. The culture of inequality. In: Kawachi I, Kennedy BP, Wilkinson RG, eds. The Society and Population Health Reader: Income Inequality and Health. New York: The New Press; 1999:492–8.
Material
The lack of material resources can directly impair the delivery of healthcare through lower end healthcare plans, low-wage jobs, and resource-poor neighborhoods. As the IOM report documents, lower end plans are subject to severe resource constraints that breed clinical cultures and practice patterns deleterious to patient outcomes. Low spending caps and strategies for cost reduction limit the supply of physician services and referrals to specialists, disrupt physician–patient relationships, create long waiting times, and limit the time physicians can spend with patients.40
Kansas City Health Commission, Health Planning and Assessment Committee. The Community Speaks about Health. City of Kansas City, Missouri Health Department; 2004 Jul 1.
The low-wage workers represented in low-end plans may be constrained in their access to healthcare in other ways. For example, they are more likely to lack control over their schedule and less likely to be able to take time off during the workday without forgoing wages or jeopardizing employment status. Poor neighborhoods and communities further constrain access. Travel to healthcare facilities and pharmacies may be far; private and public transportation may be lacking or unreliable.41
See note 6, Committee on Understanding and Eliminating Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care 2003:8, 144.
Psychosocial
The social and material issues described above can adversely influence health- and healthcare-related behaviors and attitudes in numerous ways. First, class disparities between physicians and their worse off patients may impede and impair care delivery. Physicians have been shown to be less comfortable with, less accepting of, and/or less skilled in communication with low SES patients.42
Magnus SA, Mick SS. Medical schools, affirmative action, and the neglected role of social class. American Journal of Public Health 2000;90(8):1197–200; see note 17, Cooper, Roter 2003:557.
Second, physicians' use of classist stereotypes also may contribute to healthcare disparities. The IOM report suggests that in situations characterized by cognitive complexity, uncertainty, and time pressure, physicians may rely more on cognitive shortcuts than comprehensive medical and personal information gathered from the actual patient. These shortcuts are clusters of stereotypes associated with attributes like presumed race, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, gender, and age.43
See note 6, Committee on Understanding and Eliminating Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care 2003:160–1.
Blacksher E. Desperately seeking difference. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 1998;7:11–16.
See note 17, Cooper, Roter 2003:557–8.
Third, characteristics and behaviors of low SES patients also may contribute to healthcare disparities. Low SES patients are likely to be less healthy upon presentation within the healthcare system, require more healthcare resources, and engage in less healthy behaviors than better off patients.46
Epstein AM, Stern RS, Weissman JS. Do the poor cost more? A multihospital study of patients' socioeconomic status and use of hospital resources. New England Journal of Medicine 1990;322(16):1122–8; see note 3, Williams, Collins 1995:352.
See note 3, Williams, Collins 1995:375.
Evans RG, Stoddart GL. Producing health, consuming health care. In: Evans RG, Barer ML, Marmor TR, eds. Why Are Some People Healthy and Others Not? The Determinants of Health of Populations. Hawthorne, NY: Aldine De Gruyter; 1994:27–64.
The Remediation of Healthcare Disparities: Structural and Clinical Reform Strategies
The discussion above implicates both macrolevel and microlevel factors in the production of healthcare disparities. Macrolevel or structural factors refer to the mechanisms and resources for care delivery. Microlevel or clinical factors refer to the behaviors, attitudes, and skills exhibited by agents in the care process. The account above suggests that structural and material deficits prime the care process for failure and harm and, by implication, suggests that improvements in the former will yield improvements in the latter.
Indeed, the IOM report's first recommendation for eliminating racial/ethnic healthcare disparities is structural: “Avoid the fragmentation of health plans along socioeconomic lines.”49
See note 6, Committee on Understanding and Eliminating Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care 2003:13.
Calls to improve or universalize access to healthcare have a long and unsuccessful history in the United States. Even popular U.S. presidents who have made healthcare reform central to their platform have proven unable to effect change.50
Gordon C. Dead on Arrival: The Politics of Health Care in Twentieth-Century America. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 2003.
Stone JR. Healthcare inequality, cross-cultural training, and bioethics: Principles and applications. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, this issue, 216–26.
SES and Cultural Competency Education
Cross-cultural education aims to increase providers' awareness and knowledge of how cultural and social factors influence healthcare and improve their skills for communicating with and treating patients from backgrounds different from their own.52
Office of Minority Health. National Standards on Culturally and Linguistically Appropriate Services (CLAS). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Available from: http://www.omhrc.gov/clas/ds.htm.
Betancourt JR. Cultural competence—Marginal or mainstream movement? New England Journal of Medicine 2004;351(10):953–5.
See note 44, Blacksher 1998.
Increasingly, a “patient-centered care” approach to cultural competency has emerged that emphasizes the development and exercise of attitudes, such as empathy and sensitivity.55
See note 53, Betancourt 2004.
This latest generation of cultural competency models, like its forerunners, emphasizes racial and ethnic differences. The emphasis is justified by the persistence of racial and ethnic disparities in healthcare and increasing racial and ethnic diversity in U.S. demographics.56
See note 6, Committee on Understanding and Eliminating Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care 2003:201–3.
The significance of this shared original dependency for quality healthcare is twofold. First, it should remind clinicians that everyone is delivered helpless into the hands of some and not others, reared in contexts of vastly different resources and skills, and only much later learns to evaluate that situation as better or worse. Second, it should remind clinicians that family SES has profound and lasting effects on patients' life skills and life chances—including health status, health habits, and health-related skills. Childhood SES, as I have already mentioned, exerts an independent influence on adult health.
This admittedly very general suggestion needs more development to be operationalized within a cultural competency program, work I do not undertake here. However, even this general suggestion is subject to objections. Skeptics might question whether our original dependency can facilitate sensitivity to diverse families of origin. Will not clinicians simply reflect on their own stories of origin, eclipsing the manifold differences that characterize other life trajectories? Given self-referential cognitive tendencies, what pedagogical value could such a strategy have unless fleshed out by differing narratives and other data sources?
First, a powerful meta-theme characterizes all stories of origin, no matter how different from one another they are: They are unchosen and formative, for better or worse. Should clinicians grasp this fact at a deep level, it could have transformative potential for clinician interactions with patients from very different social backgrounds. Second, any cultural competency education incorporating such a strategy indeed should incorporate a rich variety of data sources, such as individual narratives and population health studies (of the sort I have cited) that demonstrate the pervasive effects of families of origin.
Importantly, narratives should be selected to reveal the varied contours of low SES and poverty. Despite the robust predictive power of low SES for life chances, the experience is not monolithic, and stories illustrate the diversity. In the United States both absolute and relative deprivation exist, and deprivation is multidimensional, as I have tried to show. Some families may be materially poor but capability rich; others may be lacking in resources all around. Stories about people (or better, stories told by people) from varied class backgrounds should convey a range of experiences and feelings, struggles and strengths, triumphs and failures related to health and healthcare. Any number of pedagogical approaches could be used, including novels, short stories, patient testimonies, or dramatic vignettes in the classroom.
Still, skeptics may advance another objection. They may acknowledge that families are the primary site of socialization (how could they not?) and even concede the predictive power of childhood SES on adult health (they need only read the ample social scientific evidence). But, they might stress, adults should be held accountable for behavior and attitudes that influence their health. I do not disagree. But, an emphasis on personal responsibility can support the healthcare and healing process or derail it. On the one hand, an emphasis on patient agency delivered supportively and accompanied by ancillary services could convey respect for the responsibility and autonomy of patients, foster health agency, and build a trustful clinician-patient relationship. On the other hand, an emphasis on patient agency might be delivered in the absence of any attention to patients' resource challenges and needs and lead to an attitude of victim blaming, clinician indifference, lackluster advocacy, and patient abandonment.
Might the proposed addition to cultural competency education cultivate the former, more productive clinical attitude? Perhaps. It may promote clinicians' reflection on their own family of origin, remind them of where they got lucky in life, say with natural talents or a supportive family or role model. More importantly, it should remind clinicians that all patients have their own stories to tell, and that to care for them well, clinicians need to ask, wait, and listen.
Conclusion
This article argues for the importance of social class as an explicit category of analysis in healthcare disparities research and reform efforts. Although SES has received more attention in the matter of health disparities, even here national health leaders contend that SES is the “ignored determinant of the nation's health.”57
Isaacs SL, Schroeder SA. Class—The ignored determinant of the nation's health. New England Journal of Medicine 2004;351(11):1137–42.
Even if such clinical strategies were to improve clinician skills, however, they would do nothing to improve structural impediments to good healthcare. Rather, they help individuals beat a system that fails both patient and clinician. We can, of course, delight in the fact that such strategies help dedicated clinicians deliver respectful, appropriate care to underserved patients. But we should not rest satisfied with good individualistic strategies when what we need are good social policies that serve the public at large.
