This volume of essays, many of which address the phenomenon of artistic exchange between the historical Islamic lands, China, Europe, and India between the twelfth and nineteenth centuries, is dedicated to Doris Behrens-Abouseif, second holder of the Khalili Chair of Islamic Art and Archaeology at the School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London. The essays were offered by her students and colleagues shortly after her retirement. Preceded by a list of Behrens-Abouseif's numerous publications, the collection of beautifully illustrated short-form articles – organized under the categories of metalwork, architecture, ceramics, book arts and painting, and material culture – is a fitting tribute to a scholar whose range of research interests and intellectual commitments are fully reflected in this thematic Festschrift. Indeed, Behrens-Abouseif's most recent bookFootnote 1 examined the circulation of objects through various social practices and the parallel occurrence of artistic interactions, both intra- and inter-regionally.
Each of the 23 essays offers a deep dive into a case study – re-presenting some familiar objects, but also introducing others scarcely written about before – and presents new information, observations, and art historical arguments. Despite their breadth, there are notable convergences in themes and subject matter between the essays with clusters, for example, focused on Mamluk art and architecture, Ottoman architecture, and art in India from the Delhi Sultanate to the Mughals. These and other constellations of essays are described by the volume's editors (8–9). Several essays offer detailed (re)appraisals of artworks and buildings, addressing problems of historiography and interpretation, including Moya Carey's on a mid-thirteenth-century Mosul brass pen box, Bernard O'Kane and Bahia Shehab's on the mausoleum of Yahya al-Shabih in Cairo, Ünver Rüstem's on the symbolism of the Nusretiye Mosque in Istanbul, Mehmet Baha Tanman's on the spiritual and mystical aspects of Turkish bathing culture, and Sami de Giosa's on tile production during the reign of Sultan Qaytbay (r. 1468–96). Another group of essays focuses on the formation of visual types, often delving into questions of iconographic interpretation. These include Filiz Yenişehirlioǧlu's study of the Ottoman courtesan image, Mehreen Chida-Razvi's intervention on the painting of “Jahangir preferring a Sufi Shaykh to Kings,” and Malini Roy's contribution about the portraits of Mughal emperor Awrangzib (r. 1658–1707). Two essays focus on the mediums of khātam-kārī, the decorative inlay (Javad Golmohammadi), and bindings, specifically the corpus of books made for Mamluk Sultan Qansuh al-Ghawri (Alison Ohta).
Consistent with the stated emphasis of the volume, however, the majority of studies focus on issues related to the movement of finished objects, the materials from which they were made, and the people who made them, as well as the transformations inherent to these migrations. Several aspects of these complex synchronic and diachronic processes are engaged, including some of the consequences of how objects circulate (Scott Redford [on Port Saint Symeon ceramics]); moments in the post-production histories of objects, comprising their reception, adaptation, and reuse (George Manginis [Chinese export wares for Armenian patrons], Nikolaos Vryzidis [a Mamluk lamp owned by the monastery of Saint John the Theologian on Patmos], Rachel Ward [Mamluk objects “recycled” in Rasulid Yemen]); and relations between mediums and artistic traditions (J. M. Rogers [a pictorial decoupage attributed to the Deccan], Maria Sardi [fish motifs on Mamluk textiles], Tim Stanley [the impact of Iranian lacquer on European lacquer]), including different orders of emulation (Rosalind Wade Haddon [Islamic imitations of celadon wares], Melanie Gibson [British tile manufactures in the “Persian style”]). Objects that do not travel, chiefly immovable permanent architecture, are also explored interregionally through the incidence of shared architectural forms, plans, and programs of decoration (Jeremy Johns [between Palermo and Constantinople], Helen Philon [the Timurid world and the Deccan]), the habits of building practice (Alyson Wharton-Durgaryan [Armenian architects building in the Ottoman East]), and the repetition of epigraphic designs and inscriptions in sites remote from each other (Bora Keskiner [Tripoli and Istanbul]). Each essay offers a compelling case study for the diverse permutations that were in play when objects and ideas circulated across geographies, languages, religions, and time.
The essays certainly make valuable contributions to the field of Islamic art and architecture and a scholarly literature that increasingly proliferates these kinds of questions and interests. In 2018 alone, there were two monographs devoted to the study of the reception of European art by artists working in India and Iran,Footnote 2 and the biennial symposium organized by the Historians of Islamic Art Association at Yale University was devoted entirely to the concept “Border Crossing.” Such approaches have been an interest of art historians working in the field of Islamic art and architecture for many years now – they were arguably “globalists” avant la lettre – in response to several factors, e.g. the geography of Islam as a world religion, the conditions of formation and the historiography of the field, the tendency to study all kinds of mediums without the distinctions common to other fields of art history as a discipline, and the clear visibility of the effects of transcultural and transhistorical exchange in objects from early medieval through modern periods. The perpetually global nature of Islam – from the seventh century through the modern period – might in fact offer models to some other fields of art history that are now, somewhat belatedly, adopting similar approaches to their materials in recognition of the impact of their individual historiographies, the obfuscation and occlusion of artistic interactions because of nationalism, medium-specific approaches, distinctions between the fine, industrial, and decorative arts, and so on. Such a conversation would have been a welcome addition to the editors’ foreword or might equally have been taken up in a more overt and concentrated manner by any one of the authors. What theoretical and methodological insights can Islamic art and architecture offer to the discipline of art history as a whole?
