Scholars of the Flavian era have long noted the connection of the period's major poets to the region of Campania. Statius was born in Naples, where his father taught poetry. Silius Italicus owned an estate in Naples that included Virgil's tomb, according to Pliny the Younger's death-notice for the poet and former consular. Though mostly resident at Rome, Martial wrote as an amused outsider, quick to notice the faults and hypocrisies of the leisure class as they recreated at the resort town of Baiae. We know very little about the life of Valerius Flaccus, but his Argonautica links the Argonauts to the region through similes, including the famous one on Vesuvius (4.507–11).
This collection of essays derives from a conference held in 2015 at two Neapolitan universities. Several contributors examine how the poets perpetuate the stereotypes of Campania created in the previous centuries, in keeping with the tradition-focused genres in which the poets worked. Martial's connoisseurs know the value of Neapolitan chestnuts, Lucrine oysters and Falernian wine. Baiae remains a source of marvel-inducing luxury and moral panic, just as it was in the speeches of Cicero (Claudio Buongiovanni, Étienne Wolff, Margot Neger). Martial honours his patron Silius Italicus with a cycle of poems celebrating the poet's veneration of Virgil's tomb — and then undercuts the gravity of his praise by juxtaposing an obscene poem (Neger, ch. 7). Lauren Donovan Ginsberg (ch. 3) examines the narrative of Agrippina's death in the pseudo-Senecan Octavia, likely a product of the early Flavian era. As Ginsberg observes, the play departs from the historiographic tradition in order to narrate a storm, a type-scene from Roman epic, and to make it the result of Nero's ira.
Statius’ Silvae include several poems on his home-town of Naples and the region of Campania. In Silvae 3.5, the poet addresses his wife on the subject of their return from Rome back to Naples. Federica Bessone (ch. 10) shows how Statius represents Naples as a city of conjugal love, the inverse of an adulterous Rome where Domitian has failed to create true moral reform. Silvae 4.3 is a panegyric of the via Domitiana, linking Sinuessa and Pozzuoli; Trajan would extend it to Naples. Paolo Esposito's chapter (ch. 8) shows how both poems emphasise the region's recovery from Vesuvius’ devastation. The eruption forms a minor sub-theme in the volume. Darcy Krasne and Nikoletta Manioti (chs 4 and 5) take up the ancient debate of which Giant was buried under Vesuvius, which under Aetna, and show how the question informs the Flavian epics. Gianpiero Rosati examines Statius’ villa-poems (ch. 9), which participate in the fiction of Campania as a paradise inhabited by Sirens.
Several books of Silius’ epic Punica are set in southern Italy, as the narrative follows Hannibal on his march across Campania and neighbouring Apulia. Marco Fucecchi (ch. 13) illuminates the Campanian frame of the battle of Cannae (Punica 8–11). His chapter elegantly demonstrates that the lengthy epic, far from being loose and episodic, is in fact carefully structured. Thomas Biggs’ chapter (ch. 14) complements Fucecchi's with a reading of the Liternum episode (Punica 6 and 7). Alison Keith (ch. 15) examines the Virgilian and Ovidian backgrounds to the songs of the poet Teuthras, who performs for Hannibal and his troops as they sojourn in Capua (Punica 11). Elina Pyy and Michiel van der Keur (ch. 17) examine the intertextual connections between Silius’ Capua and Virgil's fallen cities, Troy and Carthage. Claire Stocks (ch. 16) reads the Capua episode in the context of Dunstan Lowe's monster theory. Campania is located on the edge of the Underworld; Capua is a monstrous inverted Rome; Hannibal resembles a Giant, and thus Pacuvius’ son a would-be giant-slayer. As Stocks observes, ‘Silius thus portrays a place where the divine and monstrous meet, showing the range of possibilities available to the epic, “monstrous” (and sublime), poet’ (247).
As is inevitable with this sort of format, some chapters are annotated catalogues of references, others are variations on contributors’ previously published work, and more might have been done to differentiate some chapters and prevent the repetition of material. However, some chapters stand out. Arianna Sacerdoti (ch. 12) applies the psychiatric literature on trauma to Statius’ poems on Vesuvius’ aftermath, as well as Silvae 5.3, on the poet's grief at the death of his father. Seneca's Natural Questions provides the previous generation's perspective on disaster at Pompeii (in this case, an earthquake) and on the after-effects of trauma. Statius links ‘the collective trauma caused by the eruption’ to ‘his personal loss of [his] father’ and addresses both through ‘the rehabilitating power of poetry itself’ (172). This is a unique approach and a valuable contribution.
Ana Lóio's chapter (ch. 11) is one of the few to consider textual problems, in this case a series of problems in Statius’ Silvae 4.8. We depend on a unique manuscript held in Madrid for the Silvae, which is extremely corrupt. As Lóio pertinently observes, some of the manuscript's problems will always remain without a definitive solution, and ‘it is indeed hard to draw the line between bold poetic imagination and lack of sense’ (154). Ian Fielding concludes the volume (ch. 18) with a discussion of Renaissance poets’ adaptation of the Campanian poetic traditions discussed here. Panormita and Pietro Bembo celebrated Statius as a fellow Neapolitan, while Giovanni Pontano claimed to venerate Virgil's tomb, as Silius and Statius had done.
