No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 June 2004
Democracy's Dilemma: Environment, Social Equity, and the Global Economy.
Democracy's Dilemma: Environment, Social Equity, and the Global Economy.
By Robert Paehlke. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2003. 304p. $27.95.
Democracy's dilemma is how the nation-states of the world resolve the conflicting needs of significant economic growth, environmental protection, and an equitable distribution of the means necessary to have a good and satisfying life. Robert Paehlke argues for a balance among growth, the environment, and equity.
The author sets his argument in historical perspective, identifying three stages of capitalism: craft, industrial, and electronic, and he provides insightful comparisons among the three and between the transitions between craft and industrial and industrial and electronic. He has devised an intriguing set of two tables in which he identifies the “negative trends within electronic capitalism” (including job loss, family breakdown, and environmental degradation) and its “positive potentials” (including higher levels of living, better worldwide communication, and greater workplace flexibility) (pp. 69–70). Unfortunately, there is no comparable historical review of either environmental protection or attempts to alleviate inequality and inequity. In his characterization of electronic capitalism, the author emphasizes the information and communication revolution and the “media monoliths” that dominate. The free flow of information is the lifeblood of democracy, and if a few corporations possess the technology and organization that can control that flow, there is reason to be alarmed.
The book's major portion deals with how to achieve a world in which the economy grows, the environment is healthy, and there is social and economic equality. The first task is getting a “three bottom line perspective” (pp. 119–159). Once one has the proper perspective, the problem becomes how one measures each bottom line. Economic prosperity is satisfactorily measured by GDP per capita. Measuring well-being and equity is more difficult. The book contains an excellent discussion of the use of the United Nations Environmental Program's human development index (HDI) to measure social well-being. The treatment of measuring environmental degradation is much less adequate. Significant sources and data are ignored.
Indeed, the major weakness of this book is its heavy reliance on authority and a neglect of reliable hard data and data analysis. Let me give some examples. Paehlke argues that an increase in international free trade leads to a shift of production from high-wage-rate to low-wage-rate countries. He refers to this as a race to the bottom. Recent data from the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development and the International Monetary Fund show that Germany in 2003 emerged as the world leader in the total value of exports. It outpaces the United States, whose economy is three times bigger, and Japan, whose economy is twice as big. It accounts for a full 19% of the total world value of exported machinery, the product of manufacturing. Yet Germany has close to the highest labor costs in the world. Another example: China is a country to which manufacturers in the developed world are shifting production to capitalize on low labor costs. They are in effect shipping jobs to China. China's export growth of about 240% since 1998 is a crude measure of jobs taken from the rest of the world. By the same token, Chinese imports represent jobs created in the rest of the world, and imports have grown by almost 300% since 1998. In just the first eight months of 2003, Japanese exports to China alone accounted for an increase in Japanese growth in GDP of 0.7%. That involves a lot of high-paid Japanese working on goods produced for China.
These examples suggest that Japan and Germany are not participating in the race to the bottom, and that there is data that, had they been taken into consideration, would have modified and focused the argument. Why cannot the United Sates with labor costs generally lower than those in Germany and Japan compete in the race to the top?
The United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) reports that in the decade of the 1990s, the share of manufacturing in the world stock of foreign trade investment (over five trillion dollars) fell from 40% to 35%, and the share in natural resources from 10% to 6%. Are not these trends something to be considered by anyone concerned about the impact of electronic capitalism on the environment?
But these examples aside, we must recognize that electronic capitalism has enormous potential for good and bad. How do we eliminate the bad without destroying the potential for the good? Industrial capitalism also had potential for good and bad, and the bad was mitigated by the rise of the regulatory state. The Federal Trade Commission, the Environmental Protection Agency, and the National Labor Relations Board were established in the United States (they had their counterparts in other countries) to oversee business practices, enforce environmental regulations, and help maintain fair labor practices. Is there not a need for a global government to regulate electronic capitalism? Paehlke has a good chapter on why this is not the road to take.
What, then, is the solution to the dilemma of growing economically but protecting, even enhancing, the environment and improving the social well-being of all? One of Paehlke's answers is surprising and provocative. Write environmental protection and labor rights provisions into international trade treaties and give the World Trade Organization enforcement powers. Paehlke has a case. One of the major weaknesses of international organizations that have some governmental-type functions is that they cannot enforce their edicts. And giving them the instruments necessary to do so creates great potential for abuse. But if environmental regulations were in a trade treaty, the sanction for violation would be readily available and there would be enormous incentives to use it. Assume, for example, that the next version of the WTO trade agreement contained a provision that every member nation must impose the same tax on every ton of carbon released into the atmosphere. A country that did not impose this tax properly (in order to reduce its manufacturing costs) could be challenged before the WTO by any member country, and if the case were proved, tariffs could be levied against imports of any kind from the offending country. The result would be an international race to reduce carbon emissions. This approach would not work for every problem, but where the pollution is an external cost of production that is borne jointly by the rest of the world, it could be mightily effective.
Paehlke has produced a good, balanced, and indeed a brave book. Democracy's Dilemma deserves a sequel that is more data-rich and analytically intensive.